Fact Check: Rockland County, NY is recounting 2024 election votes

Fact Check: "Rockland County, NY is recounting 2024 election votes"

What We Know

The claim that Rockland County, NY, is recounting the 2024 election votes is based on ongoing legal proceedings initiated by a group called SMART Legislation. This group has filed a lawsuit alleging discrepancies in the vote counts for the presidential and U.S. Senate elections in Rockland County. According to Newsweek, the lead plaintiff in the case has submitted extensive document requests as part of the discovery process, which includes a call for a full, transparent, hand recount of the votes. The lawsuit highlights alleged irregularities, such as discrepancies between the number of voters who claimed to have voted for certain candidates and the official counts reported by the Board of Elections.

The court has allowed the discovery process to proceed, indicating that the allegations are serious enough to warrant further investigation (source-2). The next court hearing is scheduled for September 22, 2025, and the case is expected to go to trial early next year (source-1).

Analysis

The lawsuit filed by SMART Legislation is primarily concerned with the integrity of the vote counts in Rockland County. The group claims that statistical anomalies and sworn affidavits from voters indicate that the official counts do not accurately reflect the votes cast (source-2). For instance, they cite instances where more voters claimed to have voted for a specific candidate than were recorded by the Board of Elections, raising questions about the accuracy of the vote tabulation process.

However, the Rockland County Board of Elections has publicly stated that they believe the election was conducted fairly and that all votes were counted correctly (source-2). The county's attorney has expressed confidence in the integrity of the election process, suggesting that the claims made in the lawsuit lack merit (source-1).

The credibility of the sources involved in this situation varies. SMART Legislation is described as a nonpartisan watchdog group, but the context of their claims and the nature of the lawsuit may introduce some bias, particularly given the political implications of the allegations. The Board of Elections, on the other hand, is a governmental body tasked with overseeing elections, which lends it a degree of authority and credibility in the matter.

Conclusion

The claim that Rockland County is recounting the 2024 election votes is Partially True. While there is no official recount currently taking place, the legal proceedings initiated by SMART Legislation could potentially lead to a recount if the court finds sufficient grounds to warrant one. The ongoing discovery process and upcoming court hearings indicate that the situation is fluid, and the outcome remains uncertain.

Fact Check: Rockland County, NY is recounting 2024 election votes