Fact Check: Judge orders full hand recount of 2024 Presidential and Senate races in Rockland County.

Fact Check: Judge Orders Full Hand Recount of 2024 Presidential and Senate Races in Rockland County

What We Know

A lawsuit has been filed in Rockland County, New York, questioning the accuracy of the 2024 Presidential and Senate election results. The case, brought by SMART Legislation, alleges significant discrepancies in the reported votes, particularly for independent Senate candidate Diane Sare, whose vote count was reportedly lower than the number of voters who claimed to have voted for her in sworn affidavits (source-1). The lawsuit also highlights statistical anomalies in the presidential election results, including instances where Vice President Kamala Harris allegedly received zero votes in districts where Democratic Senator Kirsten Gillibrand performed strongly (source-3).

On May 29, 2025, Judge Rachel Tanguay of the New York Supreme Court ruled that the lawsuit could proceed to the discovery phase, which may include a full hand recount of the ballots (source-4). The plaintiffs argue that a transparent recount is essential to ensure the integrity of the election process (source-1).

Analysis

The claim that a judge ordered a full hand recount is partially true. While the judge has indeed allowed the lawsuit to proceed to discovery, which may lead to a recount, there has not yet been a definitive order for a full hand recount. The ruling allows for the examination of ballots and other evidence, but the actual recount is contingent upon further court proceedings (source-5).

The sources cited in this fact check include both advocacy groups and mainstream media, which lend credibility to the claims made. However, it is essential to note that the lawsuit itself does not provide conclusive evidence of election fraud or misconduct; it raises questions based on statistical anomalies and discrepancies reported by voters (source-3). The reliability of the claims hinges on the forthcoming discovery process, which may clarify the validity of the allegations.

Conclusion

The claim that a judge has ordered a full hand recount of the 2024 Presidential and Senate races in Rockland County is Partially True. While the court has allowed the lawsuit to advance and may lead to a recount, no formal order for a recount has been issued yet. The situation remains fluid, and further developments in the case will determine the next steps regarding the election results.

Fact Check: Judge orders full hand recount of 2024 Presidential and Senate races in Rockland County.