Fact Check: Scott Lively is Homophobic
What We Know
Scott Lively is an American evangelical activist and attorney known for his strong opposition to LGBTQ+ rights. His organization, Abiding Truth Ministries, has been classified as a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center due to its anti-gay rhetoric and activities (AP News). Lively's involvement in promoting anti-gay legislation, particularly in Uganda, has drawn international attention. He played a significant role in the events leading to Uganda's controversial "Kill the Gays" bill, which proposed severe penalties for homosexuality, including the death penalty (Foreign Policy).
In May 2023, Uganda enacted a harsh anti-LGBTQ law, further solidifying the country's stance against homosexuality, which has been described as state-sponsored homophobia (Reuters). Lively has publicly stated his belief that society should adhere to biblical teachings regarding sexual morality, which he interprets as opposing homosexuality (AP News).
Analysis
The claim that Scott Lively is homophobic is supported by multiple credible sources that detail his actions and statements. His classification as a hate group leader by the Southern Poverty Law Center indicates a recognized pattern of promoting anti-LGBTQ+ sentiment. The SPLC's designation is based on extensive research and monitoring of hate groups, lending credibility to their assessment of Lively's activities (AP News).
Moreover, Lively's involvement in Uganda's anti-gay legislation, particularly the 2009 proposal for the death penalty for homosexual acts, highlights his direct influence on harmful policies that target LGBTQ+ individuals (Foreign Policy). This connection to legislative efforts that promote violence against LGBTQ+ people further substantiates the claim of his homophobia.
While Lively has attempted to reframe his message by suggesting a more inclusive approach towards "authentically conservative homosexuals," his foundational beliefs and actions remain firmly anti-LGBTQ+. His rhetoric and the policies he supports have consistently marginalized and endangered LGBTQ+ individuals, particularly in regions like Uganda where such laws have dire consequences (AP News).
Conclusion
The claim that Scott Lively is homophobic is True. His history of promoting anti-LGBTQ+ legislation, his classification as a hate group leader, and his direct involvement in harmful policies against LGBTQ+ individuals in Uganda provide substantial evidence supporting this assertion. The consistent pattern of his actions and beliefs aligns with the definition of homophobia, making the claim credible and well-founded.
