Fact Check: "When Billionaires Get Tax Cuts & You Get the Bill"
What We Know
The claim discusses several elements of President Trump's "One Big Beautiful Bill," which was a significant tax and spending package passed by Congress. Key components of the bill include the elimination of the tanning bed tax, the introduction of a tax exemption for tips, and the establishment of savings accounts for newborns, known as Trump Investment Accounts. The bill also proposed cuts to various social support programs, including food, healthcare, and energy assistance for working families.
-
Elimination of the Tanning Bed Tax: The tanning bed tax was indeed repealed as part of the bill, which was a point of contention among critics who argued it disproportionately benefited wealthier individuals who could afford such luxuries (source-1).
-
No Tax on Tips: The bill introduced a provision allowing tipped workers to deduct up to $25,000 in tips from their taxable income. This change was seen as beneficial for many workers in the service industry but raised concerns about its long-term impact and potential for misuse (source-3).
-
Cuts to Support Programs: Critics of the bill highlighted that it included significant cuts to Medicaid and other social support programs, which could affect millions of Americans. A government analysis suggested that over ten million people could lose health insurance as a result of these cuts (source-3).
-
Expansion of Savings Accounts: The bill proposed the establishment of savings accounts for newborns, aimed at securing financial futures for children from birth. This initiative was part of a broader effort to support working families (source-1).
Analysis
The claim presents a mixed view of the "One Big Beautiful Bill," highlighting both its benefits and drawbacks.
-
Source Reliability: The primary source of information about the bill comes from official government documents and reputable news outlets. For instance, NPR and CNBC provided detailed analyses of the bill's provisions and implications, which are generally considered reliable (source-3, source-4). However, the official White House summary may present a more favorable view of the bill, emphasizing its benefits while downplaying the negative aspects (source-1).
-
Economic Impact: The elimination of the tanning bed tax and the no-tax-on-tips provision are seen as tax cuts that primarily benefit higher-income individuals and specific sectors. Critics argue that these measures come at the expense of essential services for lower-income families, which could exacerbate economic inequality (source-3, source-6).
-
Public Sentiment: The response to the bill has been polarized, with supporters praising the tax cuts for stimulating economic growth, while opponents criticize the potential harm to vulnerable populations due to cuts in healthcare and food assistance programs (source-3, source-4).
Conclusion
The claim that the "One Big Beautiful Bill" benefits billionaires while imposing costs on working families is Partially True. While the bill does include provisions that could be seen as beneficial for certain groups, such as the no-tax-on-tips policy and the establishment of savings accounts for children, it also entails significant cuts to essential support programs that could adversely affect lower-income families. The overall impact of the bill is complex, reflecting both positive and negative consequences.
Sources
- President Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Prevents the Largest ...
- H.R.1 - 119th Congress (2025-2026): One Big Beautiful Bill Act
- What no tax on tips means for American workers : NPR
- What Trump’s 'one big beautiful bill' means for your money
- Big, beautiful bill gives tipped workers a new tax break ...
- 'Big Beautiful Bill' summary shows the biggest changes for you
- No Tax on Tips Passes in Trump's Big Beautiful Bill: What to ...
