Fact Check: Russia started war against Ukraine to protect itself from NATO

Fact Check: "Russia started war against Ukraine to protect itself from NATO"

What We Know

The claim that "Russia started war against Ukraine to protect itself from NATO" is rooted in a narrative that suggests Russia's military actions were a defensive response to NATO's eastward expansion. This perspective has been articulated by Russian officials, including President Vladimir Putin, who has framed NATO's enlargement as a threat to Russian security. In a statement, Putin demanded that Western leaders pledge to halt NATO's expansion as a condition for peace negotiations (Reuters).

However, the broader context reveals that the war in Ukraine, which escalated dramatically in February 2022, is characterized by a series of aggressive actions taken by Russia, including the annexation of Crimea in 2014 and the support of separatist movements in Eastern Ukraine (Wikipedia). NATO has consistently condemned Russia's actions, labeling them as unprovoked aggression against a sovereign nation (NATO).

Furthermore, NATO has clarified that it is not at war with Russia and supports Ukraine's right to self-defense, emphasizing that no formal agreement was made to prevent NATO's expansion after the Cold War (NATO).

Analysis

The assertion that Russia's invasion of Ukraine was a defensive measure against NATO lacks substantial evidence and is contradicted by multiple credible sources. The narrative of NATO as a direct threat to Russia is often cited by Russian state media and officials but is widely regarded as a justification for aggressive military actions rather than a legitimate security concern (NPR, KCL).

Critically, the claim overlooks the historical context of Russia's actions in Ukraine, which began long before NATO's expansion became a prominent issue. The conflict's roots can be traced back to Ukraine's 2014 Revolution of Dignity, which resulted in the ousting of a pro-Russian president and led to Russia's annexation of Crimea. This sequence of events indicates that Russia's motivations are more complex and intertwined with its imperial ambitions rather than purely defensive against NATO.

Moreover, the reliability of sources promoting the claim of NATO as a threat must be scrutinized. Many of these sources are state-controlled or aligned with Russian interests, which raises concerns about bias and the accuracy of their narratives (NATO). In contrast, NATO and independent analyses consistently affirm Ukraine's sovereignty and the illegitimacy of Russia's military actions.

Conclusion

The claim that "Russia started war against Ukraine to protect itself from NATO" is False. The evidence indicates that Russia's military aggression is rooted in its own expansionist policies and historical grievances rather than a legitimate defense against NATO. The narrative of NATO as a threat is largely a construct used by Russian leadership to justify its actions, which have been widely condemned as violations of international law and Ukraine's sovereignty.

Sources

1. Exclusive: Putin's demands for peace include an end to NATO enlargement
2. Ukraine has dominated NATO summits since Russia's invasion. Not this time with Trump
3. Russo-Ukrainian War
4. How NATO's expansion helped drive Putin to invade Ukraine
5. NATO - Topic: NATO's response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine
6. NATO - De-bunking Russian disinformation on NATO
7. Did Putin invade Ukraine because of NATO's "broken promise"?