Prices of Eggs Are Down: A Fact-Check

Introduction

The claim that "prices of eggs are down" has gained traction in recent discussions about food prices in the United States. This assertion appears to reflect a trend observed in recent months, but the specifics of the claim warrant a closer examination of the data and context surrounding egg prices.

What We Know

1. Recent Price Trends: According to the Agricultural Marketing Service (AMS), the average price for a dozen Grade A eggs in the U.S. was reported at $3.37 in October 2024, which is a decrease from the previous month and significantly lower than the peak price of $4.82 in January 2023 4. This indicates a downward trend in prices over the past year.

2. Historical Context: Egg prices hit a record high of $4.95 in January 2025, which was the highest recorded price in recent history 3. However, by March 2025, prices had reportedly plummeted to $3.45 per dozen, marking a significant decline of over 57% from the January peak 7.

3. Current Data: A recent report from the AMS indicated that wholesale prices for trucklot quantities of eggs rose slightly to $3.26 per dozen as of April 2025, suggesting some fluctuations in the market 2. Meanwhile, other sources indicate that prices have decreased significantly since earlier highs 9.

4. Price Tracking: Websites like EggPrices.org provide real-time tracking of egg prices across various regions, reflecting ongoing changes in the market 56.

Analysis

The claim that egg prices are down is supported by several credible sources, including the AMS and reputable news outlets. However, it is essential to consider the following points:

• Source Reliability: The AMS is a government agency that provides market reports based on data collected from various stakeholders in the agricultural sector. This lends credibility to their reports, although the data can be influenced by market volatility and seasonal trends.

• Conflicting Information: While some reports indicate a decrease in prices, others highlight that prices remain high compared to historical averages. For instance, the average price of $3.37 in October 2024 is still significantly higher than the price from October 2023, which was $2.07 4. This suggests that while prices may be declining from recent peaks, they are not necessarily low in a historical context.

• Potential Bias: News outlets such as Newsweek and AP News provide valuable insights but may have editorial biases that influence how they present data. For example, sensational headlines about price drops may attract more attention but could oversimplify the complexities of market trends.

• Methodology Concerns: The AMS reports are based on wholesale prices, which may not always reflect retail prices consumers pay at grocery stores. Additionally, the fluctuations in prices can be attributed to various factors, including supply chain issues, changes in consumer demand, and external events like avian influenza outbreaks.

Conclusion

Verdict: Mostly True

The assertion that "prices of eggs are down" is mostly true, as evidenced by recent data from the Agricultural Marketing Service, which shows a significant decrease in egg prices from their peak in early 2025. The average price of $3.37 in October 2024 reflects a downward trend compared to earlier highs, indicating that consumers are currently experiencing lower prices than in previous months.

However, it is important to contextualize this claim. While prices have decreased from recent peaks, they remain elevated compared to historical averages, such as the price of $2.07 in October 2023. This nuance suggests that while the trend is downward, it does not necessarily mean that prices are low in an absolute sense.

Moreover, the evidence is not without limitations. The data primarily reflects wholesale prices, which may not accurately represent retail prices faced by consumers. Additionally, fluctuations in the market can be influenced by various factors, including seasonal trends and supply chain disruptions.

Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information regarding food prices and consider both current trends and historical context when assessing claims about price changes.