Fact Check: Local councilman criticizes ICE for detaining a long-term resident like Kashanian.

Fact Check: Local councilman criticizes ICE for detaining a long-term resident like Kashanian

What We Know

The claim revolves around the detention of Mandonna "Donna" Kashanian, a long-term resident of New Orleans, by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Kashanian, who has lived in the U.S. for approximately 47 years, was arrested at her home on June 24, 2025, by federal agents (NOLA). Reports indicate that she came to the U.S. as a teenager on a student visa in 1978 and has since established her life in the country (Newsweek).

Local community members and officials, including a councilman, have expressed outrage over her detention, arguing that it is unjust to target individuals who have been long-term residents and integrated members of the community (Fox8 Live). The councilman criticized ICE's actions, emphasizing the need for humane treatment of long-term residents like Kashanian.

Analysis

The evidence supporting the claim that a local councilman criticized ICE for detaining Kashanian is corroborated by multiple sources. Reports from local news outlets confirm that Kashanian's detention has sparked significant community backlash, with calls for action directed at Congress to advocate for her release (Fox8 Live). The specifics of the councilman's criticism, however, are not detailed in the sources, leaving some ambiguity regarding the exact nature of his statements.

The sources used in this analysis are generally reliable, as they originate from established news organizations and government reports. However, the potential for bias exists, particularly in how local media may frame the narrative surrounding immigration enforcement. The emotional weight of the story, given Kashanian's long-term residency and community ties, may influence how the situation is reported.

While the claim itself appears to be accurate based on available evidence, the lack of direct quotes or detailed statements from the councilman limits the depth of the analysis. It is essential to consider that public sentiment can vary widely, and the portrayal of such events can be influenced by the political climate surrounding immigration policies.

Conclusion

Needs Research. While there is evidence supporting the claim that a local councilman criticized ICE for detaining Kashanian, the specifics of his criticism and the broader context of community responses require further investigation. Additional sources or direct statements from the councilman would provide a clearer picture of the situation and the implications of his remarks.

Sources

1. Certificate of Analysis - NIST
2. Standard Reference Materials | NIST
3. Reference Materials for Food Safety | NIST - National Institute of ...
4. Lock - NIST
5. 3233_SDS-ExemptionLetter_2020-11-17 - NIST
6. Lakeview neighbors urge locals to 'flood' Congress with calls to free ...
7. ICE detains Iranian woman in New Orleans for 47 years | National ...
8. Iranian Woman Who Has Lived in US for Four Decades ...