Fact-Check: "Gaza has reached level five starvation which means that there's they're at a point of no return."
What We Know
The claim that Gaza has reached "level five starvation" refers to the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) system, which categorizes food insecurity into five phases. According to NPR, Gaza is currently classified at phase four, termed "emergency," where food gaps widen and acute malnutrition rates rise. The IPC defines phase five, or "famine," as a situation where specific criteria must be met: at least 20% of households face "catastrophe," 30% of children under five suffer from acute malnutrition, and two out of every 10,000 adults die daily from non-trauma causes.
Recent reports indicate that while Gaza is experiencing severe food insecurity, it has not officially been declared a famine. The World Food Programme noted that a third of Gaza's population is going multiple days without food, and the situation is described as "astonishing levels" of hunger. The IPC has warned that the worst-case scenario of famine is unfolding, particularly in Gaza City, where acute malnutrition thresholds have been reached (WHO).
Analysis
The assertion that Gaza has reached "level five starvation" is misleading. While the situation is dire, with reports of widespread starvation and malnutrition (BBC), the IPC has not officially classified Gaza as being in phase five. The criteria for declaring a famine are stringent, and as of now, Gaza is categorized in phase four, indicating an emergency but not yet meeting the criteria for famine (NPR).
The sources cited, including the IPC and WHO, provide credible information based on systematic assessments of food security. However, the urgency of the situation is emphasized by various humanitarian organizations, which warn that without immediate action, the conditions could deteriorate further (Reuters, UN News). The IPC's classification process involves multiple layers of review, and while it indicates severe food insecurity, the lack of an official famine declaration suggests that the situation, while critical, has not yet reached the point of no return as defined by the IPC.
Conclusion
The claim that Gaza has reached "level five starvation" is Partially True. While the situation is extremely serious and characterized by high levels of food insecurity and malnutrition, it has not been officially classified as a famine according to the IPC criteria. The ongoing humanitarian crisis necessitates urgent action to prevent further deterioration, but as of now, the formal classification remains at phase four, not phase five.
Sources
- What does it take for a famine to be declared in Gaza?
- IPC Gaza Strip Food Insecurity and Malnutrition Alert
- Gaza crisis could get famine label, global hunger monitor ...
- People in Gaza starving, sick and dying as aid blockade ...
- Famine 'currently playing out' in Gaza, UN-backed experts ...
- In Gaza, mounting evidence of famine and ... - UN News
- IPC Gaza Strip Food Insecurity and Malnutrition Alert PDF
- UN Agencies warn key food and nutrition indicators exceed ...