Fact-Check: "94-year-old Palestinian woman burned alive by Israeli soldiers in Gaza"
What We Know
The claim that a 94-year-old Palestinian woman, Naifa Rizq al-Sawada, was burned alive by Israeli soldiers during a raid in Gaza has been reported by multiple sources. On March 21, 2024, Israeli forces raided her family's home in Gaza City, during which they reportedly forced her family to evacuate while leaving her behind. According to Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, the soldiers laid her on her granddaughter's bed and set fire to the house. The family later found her remains among the ashes of the burned home, leading to the conclusion that she died in the fire, although the exact circumstances of her death remain unclear.
Reports also indicate that Naifa suffered from dementia and required constant care, which raises questions about her treatment during the raid. A detailed account from Haaretz describes how the soldiers separated the family members and did not allow them to take her with them, despite requests to stay with her. After the raid, the family searched for her for several days but could not locate her until they returned to the burned house and found her remains.
Analysis
The evidence surrounding this claim is substantial but also complex. The reports from Reuters and Al Jazeera confirm that Naifa was indeed left behind during the raid and that her remains were later discovered in the burnt house. However, the exact details of how she died—whether she was intentionally burned or succumbed to the conditions of the fire—are not definitively established in the sources.
The reliability of the sources varies. Mainstream media outlets like Reuters and Haaretz provide corroborated accounts with a degree of journalistic integrity, while other sources, such as Palestine Nexus, may carry more bias due to their political stance. The emotional weight of the story, particularly in the context of the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict, can influence the interpretation of events.
Furthermore, the lack of direct evidence or eyewitness accounts detailing the moment of her death complicates the narrative. The family’s testimony, while compelling, is based on their experiences and the aftermath of the raid, which may not provide a complete picture of the events as they unfolded.
Conclusion
The claim that a 94-year-old Palestinian woman was burned alive by Israeli soldiers is Partially True. While it is confirmed that Naifa Rizq al-Sawada was left behind during a military raid and that her remains were found in a burned house, the specifics of her death—whether it was a direct result of the soldiers' actions or an unintended consequence of the raid—are not definitively established. The available evidence suggests a tragic outcome, but the exact circumstances surrounding her death remain ambiguous.
Sources
- Burned Palestinian's relatives describe aftermath of Israeli attack
- Gaza: The Israeli army burned an elderly women on her granddaughter's bed
- Israeli Troops Separated a Gazan Grandma From Her Family; Her Death Will Haunt Her Descendants
- Meet Naifa Al-Suda, the 94-year-old Palestinian Grandmother Murdered by Israeli Military
- Israeli army forces family to leave 94-year-old grandmother
- Remains of Palestinian grandmother found after Israeli raid
- We didn't expect to find bones: Inside one Gaza family's nightmare
- 94-year-old Palestinian woman burned alive by Israeli soldiers in Gaza
