Fact Check: Even israelis dont believe the if they gave back the hostages none of this would have happened line....

Fact Check: "Even Israelis Don't Believe the If They Gave Back the Hostages None of This Would Have Happened Line. They Are Bombing Hospitals, Burning Babies, Killing Children"

What We Know

The claim suggests that there is a general disbelief among Israelis regarding the narrative that returning hostages would have prevented the current violence, while also asserting that Israeli military actions are resulting in severe humanitarian crises, including bombings of hospitals and civilian casualties.

Hostage Situation and Military Response: On October 7, 2023, Hamas launched a surprise attack on Israel, leading to the abduction of hostages, including children. This event provoked widespread outrage in Israel and led to a military response characterized by heavy bombardment of Gaza, which has resulted in significant civilian casualties (source-2).
Impact on Hospitals: Reports indicate that the health system in Gaza is under extreme pressure due to ongoing military operations. The World Health Organization (WHO) has reported that many hospitals are either damaged or out of service, with claims of attacks on medical facilities (source-3). The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) have denied targeting hospitals without justification, asserting that Hamas has used these facilities for military purposes (source-1).
Civilian Casualties: The conflict has resulted in substantial civilian casualties, with reports of hundreds of deaths and thousands injured in Gaza as a result of Israeli airstrikes and ground operations (source-3). The humanitarian situation has been described as dire, with hospitals overwhelmed and lacking essential supplies (source-3).

Analysis

The claim contains elements that are both supported and contested by various sources:

Disbelief Among Israelis: The assertion that "even Israelis don't believe" the narrative surrounding hostages lacks direct polling data or specific statements from a significant portion of the Israeli population. However, public sentiment in Israel is complex, with many citizens expressing fear and concern for the hostages while also supporting military actions against Hamas. Reports indicate that a significant number of Israelis view military operations as necessary for security (source-7).
Bombing Hospitals and Civilian Impact: The claim that Israel is "bombing hospitals" is supported by reports from WHO and other humanitarian organizations indicating that hospitals in Gaza have been damaged and are operating under severe constraints (source-3). However, the IDF has consistently argued that their operations target Hamas military infrastructure, which they allege is often located near civilian facilities, complicating the situation (source-1). This creates a narrative where both sides claim moral high ground, making it difficult to ascertain the full truth without bias.
Emotional Language: The phrases "burning babies" and "killing children" reflect the extreme emotional toll of the conflict and are often used in rhetoric to highlight the humanitarian crisis. While civilian casualties are indeed high, the specific language used can be seen as inflammatory and may not accurately represent the complexities of military engagement in urban environments.

Conclusion

The claim is Partially True. While there is evidence of significant civilian suffering and damage to hospitals in Gaza due to Israeli military actions, the assertion that "even Israelis don't believe" in the narrative surrounding hostages lacks substantiation from credible polling or widespread public sentiment data. Moreover, the complexities of military operations and the use of civilian infrastructure by Hamas complicate the narrative, suggesting that while there is a humanitarian crisis, the motivations and beliefs of the Israeli public regarding hostages and military actions are more nuanced than the claim suggests.

Fact Check: Even israelis dont believe the if they gave back the hostages none of this would have happened line....