TruthOrFake Logo
TruthOrFake
Fact Check: "Earlier reports highlighted that fingerprints on the water bottle were crucial in identifying Mangione, yet the most recent article does NOT mention them at all. Mangione was arrested in Altoona on December 9 but was NOT fingerprinted or DNA tested. The most recent article focuses on DNA not matching anyone, which seems like a DEAD END. But back in December, Kenny explicitly said that “DNAfound to be a match on the water bottle.” If that IS the case, why is the newest article only discussing the lack of a DNA match in the database?…"

Fact Check: "Earlier reports highlighted that fingerprints on the water bottle were crucial in identifying Mangione, yet the most recent article does NOT mention them at all. Mangione was arrested in Altoona on December 9 but was NOT fingerprinted or DNA tested. The most recent article focuses on DNA not matching anyone, which seems like a DEAD END. But back in December, Kenny explicitly said that “DNAfound to be a match on the water bottle.” If that IS the case, why is the newest article only discussing the lack of a DNA match in the database?…"

Published March 11, 2025•Updated June 18, 2025
ByFactChecker 1.1 avatarFactChecker 1.1
±
VERDICT
Partially True

# Fact Check: Inconsistencies in Fingerprint and DNA Evidence in the Mangione Case ## What We Know The claim centers around the evidence presented in...

Fact Check: Inconsistencies in Fingerprint and DNA Evidence in the Mangione Case

What We Know

The claim centers around the evidence presented in the case against Luigi Mangione, who is accused of murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. Initial reports indicated that Mangione's fingerprints were found on a water bottle and a KIND snack bar wrapper near the crime scene, which were crucial in identifying him as a suspect (source-1). These fingerprints were confirmed by law enforcement and marked the first forensic link tying Mangione to the murder (source-4).

However, recent articles have shifted focus to DNA evidence, stating that the DNA found on the water bottle does not match anyone in the existing database, which has led to speculation about a potential dead end in the investigation (source-2). This change in narrative has raised questions regarding the reliability of the forensic evidence being discussed.

Analysis

The initial reports regarding Mangione's fingerprints are corroborated by multiple sources, confirming that his fingerprints matched those found on the water bottle and KIND bar wrapper (source-1, source-4). This evidence is considered strong, as fingerprints are generally reliable indicators of identity.

Conversely, the recent emphasis on DNA evidence presents a more complex picture. Earlier statements from law enforcement indicated that DNA found on the water bottle was a match for Mangione (source-3). However, subsequent reports have indicated that the DNA does not match anyone in the database, which has been interpreted as a setback (source-5).

The conflicting narratives regarding the DNA evidence could stem from evolving investigative processes, where initial findings may change as more data becomes available. The reliability of the sources discussing these developments varies; while law enforcement statements are generally credible, media interpretations can sometimes introduce bias or misinterpretation.

Conclusion

The claim that earlier reports highlighted the importance of fingerprints while recent articles do not mention them is Partially True. Fingerprints were indeed crucial in identifying Mangione, as confirmed by multiple reliable sources. However, the narrative surrounding DNA evidence has shifted, leading to confusion about its role in the investigation. While the fingerprints provide a solid link to the crime, the evolving information regarding DNA suggests that the investigation is still ongoing and complex.

Sources

  1. Luigi Mangione's fingerprints match those on KIND bar, water bottle ... (https://nypost.com/2024/12/11/us-news/luigi-mangiones-fingerprints-match-those-on-kind-bar-water-bottle-found-near-scene-of-brian-thompson-shooting/)
  2. Fact Check: "Earlier reports highlighted that fingerprints on the water ... (https://truthorfake.com/blog/earlier-reports-highlighted-that-finger-1107)
  3. What's the evidence against Luigi Mangione in ... (https://www.cbsnews.com/news/evidence-luigi-mangione-unitedhealthcare-ceo-shooting/)
  4. Gun found on Luigi Mangione matches shell casings at ... (https://www.fox5ny.com/news/unitedhealthcare-ceo-murder-luigi-mangiones-family)
  5. The gun CEO killing suspect Luigi Mangione had upon arrest ... - MSN (https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/fingerprints-match-between-luigi-mangione-and-prints-found-at-scene-of-unitedhealthcare-ceo-killing-police-say/ar-AA1vE3iE)
  6. Fingerprints From Brian Thompson Killing Match Murder Suspect Luigi ... (https://people.com/fingerprints-scene-ceo-brian-thompson-killing-match-murder-suspect-mangione-8759265)
  7. Police describe arrest of suspected killer of health ... (https://hutchpost.com/posts/a2f8a0d7-bed8-4ef1-88f5-43d95b9c2696)
  8. Midtown Assassin: Luigi Mangione's Fingerprints Found - amNewYork (https://www.amny.com/news/midtown-assassin-luigi-mangione-fingerprints-match/)

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

💡 Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
✓100% Free
✓No Registration
✓Instant Results

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...

More Fact Checks to Explore

Discover similar claims and stay informed with these related fact-checks

Fact Check: Transcript 00:00 911 was a false flag. For the first 10 years, I did not think anything other than the official narrative then after being shown a video, a close up video of building number seven coming down and that got me going because it's obvious to me that building seven was was a controlled demolition because the building collapses from the bottom down. The trade centers were unique in that they were designed to withstand the 00:33 impact of a a a jet. From what I understand the the outer skeleton of the building. The outer columns was like a a fish net and you had these inner core columns which was substantial thick steel beams to withstand four or five times what the loads were. Got it. The engineers always over design a building. No steel frame building has ever collapsed before or since 9/ eleven. So that should say something right there. And it said that building seven it was 01:05 aggressive collapse that it was caused by fire but progressive collapse unlike the twin towers, the twin towers collapse from the top down. That's a progressive collapse. Sure. Floor by floor by floor. But if you look at the videos of building seven collapsing, it collapses uniformly, it's collapsing from the bottom, the building stays intact all the way to the bottom of the ground and you could see the sides caving in on it. For a building to collapse uniformly which the video show all the load bearing it would have to have failed 01:36 simultaneously. Now, fire doesn't act like that. I came across an analogy of the twin towers and if you could visualize cast iron stoves stacked. One on top of each other. The stoves up at the top. Yes, there's fire and they've been damaged but the stoves on the bottom, they haven't been damaged. Okay. So, the structure underneath all of that is intact. So, it's impossible for a building to collapse near free fall speed and increase. Without a 02:07 controlled demolition. You're running into the path of most resistance. I something else is going on. I don't believe that it was just the planes or the fires I think that and they examine the dust and they found what they call thermitic material which is like a explosive incendiary which was in the dust samples and that's documented. There were reports of the buildings were undergoing a extensive elevator renovation in the two or three years prior to all kinds of 02:40 workers they had access to the the core the cores of the building and on the day of the attack the the elevator company would not assist in the operations of the elevators and the elevator company was the elevator company it subsequently went out of business and a couple of years after that
False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Transcript 00:00 911 was a false flag. For the first 10 years, I did not think anything other than the official narrative then after being shown a video, a close up video of building number seven coming down and that got me going because it's obvious to me that building seven was was a controlled demolition because the building collapses from the bottom down. The trade centers were unique in that they were designed to withstand the 00:33 impact of a a a jet. From what I understand the the outer skeleton of the building. The outer columns was like a a fish net and you had these inner core columns which was substantial thick steel beams to withstand four or five times what the loads were. Got it. The engineers always over design a building. No steel frame building has ever collapsed before or since 9/ eleven. So that should say something right there. And it said that building seven it was 01:05 aggressive collapse that it was caused by fire but progressive collapse unlike the twin towers, the twin towers collapse from the top down. That's a progressive collapse. Sure. Floor by floor by floor. But if you look at the videos of building seven collapsing, it collapses uniformly, it's collapsing from the bottom, the building stays intact all the way to the bottom of the ground and you could see the sides caving in on it. For a building to collapse uniformly which the video show all the load bearing it would have to have failed 01:36 simultaneously. Now, fire doesn't act like that. I came across an analogy of the twin towers and if you could visualize cast iron stoves stacked. One on top of each other. The stoves up at the top. Yes, there's fire and they've been damaged but the stoves on the bottom, they haven't been damaged. Okay. So, the structure underneath all of that is intact. So, it's impossible for a building to collapse near free fall speed and increase. Without a 02:07 controlled demolition. You're running into the path of most resistance. I something else is going on. I don't believe that it was just the planes or the fires I think that and they examine the dust and they found what they call thermitic material which is like a explosive incendiary which was in the dust samples and that's documented. There were reports of the buildings were undergoing a extensive elevator renovation in the two or three years prior to all kinds of 02:40 workers they had access to the the core the cores of the building and on the day of the attack the the elevator company would not assist in the operations of the elevators and the elevator company was the elevator company it subsequently went out of business and a couple of years after that

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Transcript 00:00 911 was a false flag. For the first 10 years, I did not think anything other than the official narrative then after being shown a video, a close up video of building number seven coming down and that got me going because it's obvious to me that building seven was was a controlled demolition because the building collapses from the bottom down. The trade centers were unique in that they were designed to withstand the 00:33 impact of a a a jet. From what I understand the the outer skeleton of the building. The outer columns was like a a fish net and you had these inner core columns which was substantial thick steel beams to withstand four or five times what the loads were. Got it. The engineers always over design a building. No steel frame building has ever collapsed before or since 9/ eleven. So that should say something right there. And it said that building seven it was 01:05 aggressive collapse that it was caused by fire but progressive collapse unlike the twin towers, the twin towers collapse from the top down. That's a progressive collapse. Sure. Floor by floor by floor. But if you look at the videos of building seven collapsing, it collapses uniformly, it's collapsing from the bottom, the building stays intact all the way to the bottom of the ground and you could see the sides caving in on it. For a building to collapse uniformly which the video show all the load bearing it would have to have failed 01:36 simultaneously. Now, fire doesn't act like that. I came across an analogy of the twin towers and if you could visualize cast iron stoves stacked. One on top of each other. The stoves up at the top. Yes, there's fire and they've been damaged but the stoves on the bottom, they haven't been damaged. Okay. So, the structure underneath all of that is intact. So, it's impossible for a building to collapse near free fall speed and increase. Without a 02:07 controlled demolition. You're running into the path of most resistance. I something else is going on. I don't believe that it was just the planes or the fires I think that and they examine the dust and they found what they call thermitic material which is like a explosive incendiary which was in the dust samples and that's documented. There were reports of the buildings were undergoing a extensive elevator renovation in the two or three years prior to all kinds of 02:40 workers they had access to the the core the cores of the building and on the day of the attack the the elevator company would not assist in the operations of the elevators and the elevator company was the elevator company it subsequently went out of business and a couple of years after that

Jul 28, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Dear Ms. Clay, Thank you for reaching out to inquire about these important questions—it's always encouraging to hear from residents who take an active interest in the health and infrastructure safety of our community. 1. Fluoride in Tombstone Water: • Tombstone does not add fluoride to its municipal water supply. • Testing results show fluoride levels well under federal safety limits, averaging around 0.3 to 0.34 ppm, far below the EPA's maximum of 4 ppm. • The EPA’s Safe Drinking Water System database confirms no fluoride violations for our system in the past decade (EWG, EWG). 2. EMFs from Cell Towers: • Any cell towers in our area are required to meet FCC limits for EMF emissions, well below levels regarded as harmful. • Although some residents worry about long-term exposure, there is no credible evidence that FCC-compliant towers pose health risks. 3. Upcoming Treatment Plant Tour: • The City is organizing a guided tour of the Water and Wastewater Treatment Plants next week and we’d be pleased to have you join once the date is finalized. If you'd like to keep on top of the water quality reports, you can visit the City’s Annual Drinking Water Quality Report page here: 🔗 https://cityoftombstoneaz.gov/public-works-department/ Please feel free to let me know if you'd like a spot on the plant tour. I’ll send details once it’s scheduled.
True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Dear Ms. Clay, Thank you for reaching out to inquire about these important questions—it's always encouraging to hear from residents who take an active interest in the health and infrastructure safety of our community. 1. Fluoride in Tombstone Water: • Tombstone does not add fluoride to its municipal water supply. • Testing results show fluoride levels well under federal safety limits, averaging around 0.3 to 0.34 ppm, far below the EPA's maximum of 4 ppm. • The EPA’s Safe Drinking Water System database confirms no fluoride violations for our system in the past decade (EWG, EWG). 2. EMFs from Cell Towers: • Any cell towers in our area are required to meet FCC limits for EMF emissions, well below levels regarded as harmful. • Although some residents worry about long-term exposure, there is no credible evidence that FCC-compliant towers pose health risks. 3. Upcoming Treatment Plant Tour: • The City is organizing a guided tour of the Water and Wastewater Treatment Plants next week and we’d be pleased to have you join once the date is finalized. If you'd like to keep on top of the water quality reports, you can visit the City’s Annual Drinking Water Quality Report page here: 🔗 https://cityoftombstoneaz.gov/public-works-department/ Please feel free to let me know if you'd like a spot on the plant tour. I’ll send details once it’s scheduled.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Dear Ms. Clay, Thank you for reaching out to inquire about these important questions—it's always encouraging to hear from residents who take an active interest in the health and infrastructure safety of our community. 1. Fluoride in Tombstone Water: • Tombstone does not add fluoride to its municipal water supply. • Testing results show fluoride levels well under federal safety limits, averaging around 0.3 to 0.34 ppm, far below the EPA's maximum of 4 ppm. • The EPA’s Safe Drinking Water System database confirms no fluoride violations for our system in the past decade (EWG, EWG). 2. EMFs from Cell Towers: • Any cell towers in our area are required to meet FCC limits for EMF emissions, well below levels regarded as harmful. • Although some residents worry about long-term exposure, there is no credible evidence that FCC-compliant towers pose health risks. 3. Upcoming Treatment Plant Tour: • The City is organizing a guided tour of the Water and Wastewater Treatment Plants next week and we’d be pleased to have you join once the date is finalized. If you'd like to keep on top of the water quality reports, you can visit the City’s Annual Drinking Water Quality Report page here: 🔗 https://cityoftombstoneaz.gov/public-works-department/ Please feel free to let me know if you'd like a spot on the plant tour. I’ll send details once it’s scheduled.

Jul 17, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Did surviving nonbird dinosaurs reports in early 1900s may have roots in earlier pseudohistorical narratives, particularly surrounding Great Zimbabwe
Unverified
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Did surviving nonbird dinosaurs reports in early 1900s may have roots in earlier pseudohistorical narratives, particularly surrounding Great Zimbabwe

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Did surviving nonbird dinosaurs reports in early 1900s may have roots in earlier pseudohistorical narratives, particularly surrounding Great Zimbabwe

Jul 5, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: A Trump-appointed judge overturned a Biden-era rule that removed medical debt from credit reports. The ruling came days after Republicans voted to kick millions of Americans off healthcare which will likely cause medical debt to skyrocket.
Partially True

Fact Check: A Trump-appointed judge overturned a Biden-era rule that removed medical debt from credit reports. The ruling came days after Republicans voted to kick millions of Americans off healthcare which will likely cause medical debt to skyrocket.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: A Trump-appointed judge overturned a Biden-era rule that removed medical debt from credit reports. The ruling came days after Republicans voted to kick millions of Americans off healthcare which will likely cause medical debt to skyrocket.

Jul 28, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Trump Once Made Epstein A Racy Birthday Card With A Strange Note, WSJ Reports
Partially True

Fact Check: Trump Once Made Epstein A Racy Birthday Card With A Strange Note, WSJ Reports

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Trump Once Made Epstein A Racy Birthday Card With A Strange Note, WSJ Reports

Jul 28, 2025
Read more →
🔍
Partially True

Fact Check: Abortion pills are 22 times more harmful than previous FDA reports suggest.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Abortion pills are 22 times more harmful than previous FDA reports suggest.

Jul 14, 2025
Read more →
Explore All Fact Checks