Fact Check: E. Jean Carroll's Attorney's Statement on Appeals Court Decision
What We Know
On October 27, 2023, E. Jean Carroll's attorney, Roberta Kaplan, made a statement regarding the recent decision by a federal appeals court. The court declined to rehear President Donald Trump's appeal concerning a $5 million verdict awarded to Carroll for sexual assault and defamation. Kaplan expressed that Carroll was "very pleased" with the court's decision, stating, "Although President Trump continues to try every possible maneuver to challenge the findings of two separate juries, those efforts have failed" (BBC, CBS News). This statement reflects the ongoing legal battles between Carroll and Trump, particularly regarding the findings of two juries that ruled against Trump.
Analysis
The claim that Roberta Kaplan stated Carroll is pleased with the appeals court decision is supported by multiple credible sources. Both the BBC and CBS News reported Kaplan's remarks, confirming that Carroll is indeed satisfied with the court's ruling. The context of her statement is crucial; it highlights Trump's continued legal challenges and the failure of those efforts to overturn the jury's findings.
The sources used for this fact check are reputable news organizations known for their journalistic integrity. The BBC and CBS News are established media outlets with a long history of reporting on legal and political matters. Their coverage of the Carroll case has been consistent and factual, lending credibility to their reporting on Kaplan's statement.
Additionally, the details surrounding the appeals court's decision are significant. The court's refusal to rehear Trump's appeal indicates a strong affirmation of the previous jury's findings, which adds weight to Kaplan's assertion that Trump's legal maneuvers have not succeeded (Reuters, Newsweek).
Conclusion
Verdict: True. Roberta Kaplan's statement regarding E. Jean Carroll's satisfaction with the appeals court decision is accurate and well-supported by reliable sources. The ongoing legal challenges faced by Trump, as noted in Kaplan's remarks, further validate the claim that his efforts to overturn the jury's decisions have failed.
