Fact Check: Did /a/nonymous magica write a Madoka fanfic called Magia Revolution?
What We Know
The claim in question is whether a user known as /a/nonymous magica authored a fanfic titled "Magia Revolution" related to the popular anime series "Puella Magi Madoka Magica." According to a page on TV Tropes, "Magia Revolution" is described as a series of Choose Your Own Adventure (CYOA) games based on "Puella Magi Madoka Magica," created by /a/nonymous magica. The games began with a basic premise and evolved through community contributions and interactions.
The CYOA format allows users to make choices that affect the narrative, which is a popular method in fanfiction and interactive storytelling. The games are said to be directly ported from the 4chan community, specifically from the /a/ board, which is dedicated to anime and manga discussions. Furthermore, the author of the subsequent series "Magia Rebuild" explicitly credits /a/nonymous magica for the original work, indicating a collaborative nature within the fan community (source-4).
While various fanfiction archives, such as Archive of Our Own (AO3) and FanFiction.net, host numerous works related to "Puella Magi Madoka Magica," there is no direct mention of a fanfic titled "Magia Revolution" in these databases (source-4). However, the collaborative and anonymous nature of contributions on platforms like 4chan often complicates the attribution of authorship.
Analysis
The evidence surrounding the claim that /a/nonymous magica wrote "Magia Revolution" is primarily derived from community-driven sources, which raises questions about reliability and verification. The TV Tropes page is a user-edited site that compiles information about various media, including fanworks. While it can be informative, the accuracy of its content can vary due to its open-editing nature. The lack of formal citations or references to primary sources diminishes its reliability.
In contrast, the claim is supported by the explicit attribution found in the "Magia Rebuild" series (source-4), which acknowledges /a/nonymous magica as the original creator. This suggests that the community recognizes /a/nonymous magica's role in the creation of "Magia Revolution." Additionally, discussions on forums like SpaceBattles further confirm the existence of "Magia Revolution" as a CYOA game initiated by /a/nonymous magica (source-6).
However, the absence of the title in major fanfiction archives may indicate that it is not classified as a traditional fanfic but rather as an interactive narrative unique to the 4chan community. This distinction is important when evaluating the claim.
Conclusion
Verdict: True
The claim that /a/nonymous magica wrote a Madoka fanfic called "Magia Revolution" is true. The evidence from community sources, particularly the acknowledgment in subsequent works and discussions on platforms dedicated to fan content, supports the assertion. While the nature of the work may differ from traditional fanfiction, the collective recognition of /a/nonymous magica as the creator of "Magia Revolution" affirms the validity of the claim.