The Claim: "Clinton deported 10m and Obama 3m illegal aliens"
Introduction
The assertion that President Bill Clinton deported 10 million illegal aliens and President Barack Obama deported 3 million has circulated in various discussions about U.S. immigration policy. This claim raises questions about the accuracy of the figures and the context surrounding deportation statistics during these administrations.
What We Know
-
Clinton Administration: Estimates of deportations during Clinton's presidency (1993-2001) vary significantly. According to a report by the Migration Policy Institute, more than 12 million people were "deported" or returned during Clinton's time in office, but this figure includes both formal deportations and voluntary returns, which complicates the interpretation of the data 10. Other sources, such as an infographic site, suggest that deportations surged, reaching over 5 million during Clinton's first term and peaking at nearly 7 million in his second term 7.
-
Obama Administration: During Obama's presidency (2009-2017), it is widely reported that more than 3 million individuals were deported. A fact-check by Snopes confirms that the number of deportations exceeded 3 million, with a significant percentage of those deported not having the opportunity to contest their removal in court 5. The New York Times also corroborates this figure, noting that the Obama administration's policies led to substantial deportations, although they were often criticized for their impact on families and communities 3.
-
Methodology of Counting Deportations: The figures for deportations can vary based on how they are defined. Deportations can include formal removals ordered by a judge as well as voluntary departures. This distinction is crucial when interpreting the numbers. For instance, the Cato Institute highlights that the Obama administration's deportation figures include a significant number of individuals who were returned without a formal hearing 9.
Analysis
The claim that Clinton deported 10 million illegal aliens appears to be an exaggeration when compared to verified statistics. The figure of 12 million cited by the Migration Policy Institute encompasses both deportations and voluntary returns, which may inflate the perception of enforcement actions taken during Clinton's presidency 10. Furthermore, the methodology used to compile these statistics is critical; without a clear distinction between deportations and voluntary returns, the numbers can be misleading.
In contrast, the figure of 3 million deportations under Obama is well-supported by multiple credible sources, including Snopes and the New York Times, which provide a consistent narrative about the administration's immigration enforcement policies 53. However, the context of these deportations—particularly the high percentage of individuals who did not have the chance to contest their deportation—raises ethical questions about the enforcement practices of that era 5.
The reliability of the sources varies. Academic and non-partisan organizations like the Migration Policy Institute and Snopes are generally regarded as credible, while political commentary or opinion pieces may carry inherent biases that could affect the presentation of facts. For example, the Washington Post's analysis of statements made during political debates provides a critical perspective on how these figures are used in political rhetoric 4.
Conclusion
Verdict: Mostly False
The claim that President Clinton deported 10 million illegal aliens is largely exaggerated, as the figures often conflated deportations with voluntary returns, leading to inflated numbers. While the Migration Policy Institute reports over 12 million "deported or returned," this includes both categories, making it misleading to assert that 10 million were formally deported. In contrast, the assertion regarding President Obama deporting 3 million individuals is supported by credible sources, including Snopes and the New York Times, which confirm that this figure is accurate. However, the context surrounding these deportations, particularly the lack of due process for many individuals, complicates the narrative.
It is important to recognize that the methodology used to count deportations can vary, and the figures presented may not fully capture the complexities of immigration enforcement. The available evidence does not provide a definitive answer, and there are limitations in the data regarding how deportations are categorized and reported. Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information and consider the nuances involved in discussions about immigration policy and statistics.
Sources
- Deportation and removal from the United States. Wikipedia. Link
- AP FACT CHECK: Sour notes on immigration, security in ... AP News. Link
- 3 Million People Were Deported Under Obama. What Will ... New York Times. Link
- Ted Cruz gets it very wrong on recent presidents ... Washington Post. Link
- US deported more than 3M people during Obama presidency. Snopes. Link
- Article: The Obama Record on Deportations. Migration Policy Institute. Link
- Deportations Under US Presidents: Surprising Statistics. Infographic Site. Link
- Fact Check: Yes, US deported more than 3M people during Obama. Yahoo News. Link
- Deportation Rates in Historical Perspective. Cato Institute. Link
- Obama deportations vs. Trump: Context is everything. CNN. Link
