Fact-Check: Claim Regarding Israel's Disengagement from Gaza and Hamas' Actions
What We Know
The claim states that Israel fully disengaged from Gaza in 2005, removing all Jewish families, synagogues, and cemeteries, and that since Hamas took power in 2006, no Jews have lived in Gaza. It also asserts that Hamas has a charter calling for the destruction of Jews and that the group demonstrated this intent during the October 7, 2023 attacks.
-
Israel's Disengagement: In August and September 2005, Israel executed a unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip, removing all Israeli settlements and military presence. This operation is known as the Israeli disengagement from Gaza. The withdrawal included the evacuation of approximately 8,000 Israeli settlers.
-
Hamas' Rise to Power: Hamas won the Palestinian legislative elections in January 2006 and subsequently took control of Gaza in June 2007 after a violent conflict with the rival Fatah party. This takeover marked the beginning of Hamas' governance in the region, during which it has maintained a strict Islamist regime and has been involved in numerous conflicts with Israel (Hamas Overview).
-
Hamas' Charter: The original Hamas charter, published in 1988, included anti-Semitic language and called for the destruction of Israel. In 2017, Hamas released a new charter that moderated some of the language, stating that its struggle was against "Zionists" rather than Jews as a whole (Hamas Doctrine). However, the group has consistently expressed its commitment to armed resistance against Israel.
-
October 7, 2023 Attacks: On this date, Hamas launched a coordinated attack on Israel, resulting in the deaths of approximately 1,200 people, including civilians. This attack has been described as one of the most brutal acts of terrorism in recent history, with reports of indiscriminate killings of non-combatants (The Road to October 7).
Analysis
The claim contains elements that are accurate but also oversimplifies and generalizes complex historical and political realities.
-
Disengagement and Demographics: The assertion that "every single Jew is pulled out" is technically correct in that Israel evacuated all settlements and military personnel from Gaza in 2005. However, it is important to note that while no Jews reside in Gaza since the disengagement, the context of this demographic change is rooted in a broader conflict and the subsequent governance by Hamas, which has enforced a strict anti-Israel policy.
-
Hamas' Ideology and Actions: The claim that Hamas' charter calls for the destruction of Jews is partially true. The original charter did include such language, but the revised 2017 charter attempted to reframe the conflict as one against Zionism rather than Judaism. Nevertheless, the group's actions, particularly the attacks on civilians, reflect a continued commitment to violence against Israelis, which aligns with the claim about their intentions (Hamas Overview, The Road to October 7).
-
Context of Violence: The description of the October 7 attacks as targeting "babies, grandmas, and festival-goers" is corroborated by multiple sources, including U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken's remarks, which highlighted the brutality of the attacks (The Road to October 7). This paints a clear picture of the indiscriminate nature of the violence perpetrated by Hamas.
Conclusion
The claim is Partially True. While it accurately states that Israel disengaged from Gaza and that no Jews currently live there, it oversimplifies the complexities surrounding Hamas' governance and ideology. The assertion regarding Hamas' charter and their violent actions against civilians reflects a historical continuity of hostility towards Israel, but the nuances of their ideological evolution are not fully captured in the claim. The context of the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict is critical to understanding these dynamics.
Sources
- Israel and Hamas Conflict In Brief: Overview, U.S. Policy
- The Road to October 7: Hamas' Long Game, Clarified
- Israel and Hamas October 2023 Conflict: Frequently Asked Questions
- Hamas
- Doctrine of Hamas
- Israel’s disengagement from Gaza
- 20 Years Later: Lessons from Israel’s Disengagement
- Israel, Blockade of Gaza and the Flotilla Incident