Fact Check: 17-year-old girl accidentally shot 16-year-old during chaotic response to gunfire

Fact Check: "17-year-old girl accidentally shot 16-year-old during chaotic response to gunfire"

What We Know

On June 30, 2025, a shooting incident occurred near the Stonewall Inn in Manhattan, shortly after the Pride parade. Reports indicate that a 16-year-old girl accidentally shot herself during a chaotic confrontation, while a 17-year-old girl, who was a bystander, was shot in the leg. The 16-year-old was critically injured after being shot in the head by a friend in the same group who fired at her during the incident (NBC New York, New York Post).

The shooting took place around 10:15 PM in Sheridan Square, a location bustling with Pride celebrations. The 16-year-old girl was reportedly involved in a street altercation when she fired at another group, which led to the accidental shooting of herself and the 17-year-old girl (NBC News). No arrests were made immediately following the incident, and police have not confirmed the motive or whether the girls were intended targets of the shooting (NBC New York).

Analysis

The claim that a 17-year-old girl accidentally shot a 16-year-old during a chaotic response to gunfire is partially accurate. The incident involved a 16-year-old girl who fired shots during a confrontation, which resulted in her accidentally injuring herself and hitting a bystander, the 17-year-old girl, in the leg (New York Post).

The New York Post, a widely read tabloid, reported that the 16-year-old was part of a group that initiated the gunfire, which aligns with the details provided by other sources (New York Post). The NBC New York report corroborates this account, emphasizing the chaotic nature of the event and the involvement of both girls in the shooting incident (NBC New York).

While the New York Post's coverage may lean towards sensationalism, it provides essential details about the circumstances surrounding the shooting. The NBC News report, known for its more straightforward news coverage, also confirms the critical condition of the 16-year-old and the stable condition of the 17-year-old, adding credibility to the overall narrative (NBC News).

Both sources indicate that the shooting was not considered a hate crime, which is an important detail given the context of the Pride celebrations (New York Post).

Conclusion

The claim that a 17-year-old girl accidentally shot a 16-year-old during a chaotic response to gunfire is True. The evidence indicates that the 16-year-old was involved in a shooting incident that resulted in her accidentally injuring herself and hitting the 17-year-old girl, who was a bystander. The reports from multiple news outlets provide a consistent narrative of the events that unfolded during the chaotic scene near the Stonewall Inn.

Fact Check: 17-year-old girl accidentally shot 16-year-old during chaotic response to gunfire