Fact Check: Wisconsin couple plotted to poison two women from dating apps
What We Know
A couple from Wisconsin, Paul VanDuyne Jr., 43, and Andrea Whitaker, 41, have been charged with multiple serious offenses, including attempted murder, aggravated battery, and stalking. The charges stem from allegations that they conspired to poison two women whom VanDuyne had previously dated after meeting them on dating apps (NBC News, DNYUZ).
According to court documents, one of the victims reported experiencing severe illness after being poisoned with thallium, a toxic substance that has been banned for household use in the U.S. since 1965 due to its dangerous properties (NBC News). Another victim reported that her bottled water, which she had left in her vehicle, tested positive for cyanide and thallium (DNYUZ). The couple allegedly attempted to poison the victims multiple times, using various toxic substances, including cyanide and abrin, which can be derived from rosary pea seeds (NBC News, Madison.com).
Both victims had minimal interactions with VanDuyne, with one stating she went on only two dates with him and had expressed disinterest in continuing the relationship. Despite this, both VanDuyne and Whitaker reportedly developed a delusional belief that they were in a relationship with her (NBC News).
Analysis
The evidence presented in the court documents is substantial and paints a disturbing picture of the couple's alleged actions. The detailed accounts from the victims, including one who described finding Whitaker near her vehicle, lend credibility to the claims against VanDuyne and Whitaker (NBC News). Furthermore, the medical evidence linking the victims' illnesses to poisoning with thallium and cyanide supports the allegations of attempted murder (Madison.com).
The sources used in this fact-check are primarily news articles from reputable outlets such as NBC News and local Wisconsin news platforms, which have reported on the court proceedings and the details of the case. These sources are generally reliable, as they provide direct quotes from court documents and statements from law enforcement officials. However, it is important to note that ongoing legal proceedings can evolve, and new information may emerge that could alter the context of the case.
The claims made by the victims, supported by medical evidence and the nature of the charges, suggest a serious and premeditated attempt to harm them. The couple's alleged actions, including the use of toxic substances and the stalking behavior, indicate a significant threat to public safety.
Conclusion
Verdict: True
The claim that a Wisconsin couple plotted to poison two women from dating apps is substantiated by multiple credible sources detailing the charges against them and the evidence presented in court. The serious nature of the allegations, combined with the medical findings linking the victims' illnesses to poisoning, supports the conclusion that the couple engaged in a deliberate and malicious plot.
