Fact-Check Article: Water in Space
What We Know
The claim states that "water in space vacuum quickly evaporates into water vapor and it quickly freezes," and that the outcome depends on proximity to the Sun or being shielded from it. Here are the relevant facts regarding this claim:
-
Behavior of Water in a Vacuum: When liquid water is placed in a vacuum, it experiences a significant drop in pressure, which causes it to boil. This phenomenon is well-documented; water boils at lower temperatures when the pressure is reduced, as noted in a Forbes article.
-
Freezing of Water in Space: In the vacuum of space, if the temperature is sufficiently low, water can freeze rapidly. The temperature in space can drop to around 2.7 Kelvin, which is far below the freezing point of water. This is supported by NASA's research, which discusses the conditions under which water can freeze in space.
-
Sequential Processes: When liquid water is exposed to the vacuum of space, it first boils due to the low pressure and then can freeze almost immediately as the vapor cools. This process is known as desublimation, where vapor turns directly into solid ice, as described in a detailed analysis.
-
Influence of Solar Proximity: The behavior of water in space can vary depending on its distance from the Sun. Water that is closer to the Sun may not freeze as quickly due to higher temperatures, while water in shadowed areas or farther from the Sun can freeze rapidly. This is discussed in various sources, including an article on cosmic phenomena.
Analysis
The claim about water in space contains elements that are both accurate and misleading.
-
Evaporation and Freezing: The assertion that water "quickly evaporates into water vapor" is correct in the context of a vacuum, as the low pressure causes water to boil. However, the term "quickly" may imply an immediate transition without acknowledging the sequential nature of the processes involved. The water does not simply evaporate; it first boils and then can freeze due to the extreme cold of space.
-
Dependence on Solar Proximity: The statement that the outcome depends on how close one is to the Sun is partially true. Water near the Sun may remain in a liquid state longer due to higher temperatures, while water in shadow or farther from the Sun can freeze quickly. However, this aspect of the claim could be misleading if interpreted to suggest that proximity to the Sun is the only factor influencing the state of water.
-
Source Reliability: The sources cited provide a mix of scientific explanations and anecdotal evidence. For example, the Forbes article is written by a science communicator and is generally reliable, while NASA's research is a primary source that provides empirical data. Other sources, such as Stack Exchange discussions, may vary in reliability due to their informal nature and reliance on community expertise.
Conclusion
The claim that "water in space vacuum quickly evaporates into water vapor and it quickly freezes" is Partially True. While it accurately describes the boiling and freezing processes of water in a vacuum, it oversimplifies the sequence of events and the conditions that affect these processes. The influence of solar proximity is valid but should not be seen as the sole determinant of water behavior in space.
Sources
- NASA-CR-1501117) ICE IN SPACE
- Water In Space: Does It Freeze Or Boil?
- Water in vacuum (or space) and temperature in space
- How Does Water Freeze in Outer Space If the Sun is So Hot?
- Does Water Evaporate in a Vacuum? Understanding the Science ...
- The sun - How long would 1 liter of water need to evaporate ...
- What Happens to Water in Space/Vacuum?
- A Bucket Full Of Water In Space: Freezes Or Evaporates?