Fact Check: "Trump's immigration crackdown targets long-compliant individuals like Kashanian."
What We Know
The claim that Trump's immigration crackdown targets long-compliant individuals is supported by recent reports highlighting the arrests of individuals who have lived in the U.S. for decades without issues. For instance, Mandonna "Donna" Kashanian, who had been in the U.S. for 47 years, was arrested by ICE while gardening at her home in New Orleans. She had married a U.S. citizen and raised a family, yet her long-standing compliance with immigration laws did not protect her from deportation under the Trump administration's policies (source-4, source-6).
The Trump administration's immigration policies have indeed shifted focus over time. Initially, the administration targeted undocumented immigrants with criminal records, but reports indicate that this focus expanded to include individuals without criminal histories, such as Kashanian (source-2). This shift has led to widespread arrests of individuals who had previously been compliant with immigration regulations.
Analysis
The evidence suggests that the Trump administration's immigration policies have increasingly targeted individuals who have been long-term residents, including those who have not violated any laws. The case of Kashanian exemplifies this trend, as her arrest occurred despite her long-term residency and lack of criminal activity (source-4, source-7).
However, the reliability of the sources varies. The New York Times and AP News are reputable outlets with a history of journalistic integrity, while some reports may be less comprehensive or lack detailed context. For example, while the New Orleans report provides a personal narrative, it may not fully capture the broader implications of the immigration policies (source-2, source-1).
The administration's policies have faced criticism for their impact on industries reliant on immigrant labor, indicating a complex interplay between political objectives and economic realities. Trump's acknowledgment of the negative effects of his policies on certain industries suggests a recognition of the consequences of targeting long-compliant individuals (source-2).
Conclusion
The claim that Trump's immigration crackdown targets long-compliant individuals like Kashanian is Partially True. While there is substantial evidence that the administration's policies have increasingly affected individuals who have been compliant with immigration laws, the extent and implications of these actions are complex and influenced by various factors, including political and economic considerations. The case of Kashanian illustrates the broader trend of targeting individuals who have long resided in the U.S. without legal status, but it also highlights the challenges and criticisms faced by the administration regarding its immigration policies.
Sources
- Iranians who've been in the US for decades are being arrested in Trump ... AP News
- Trump Shifts Deportation Focus, Pausing Most Raids on ... The New York Times
- Trump immigration crackdown: Iranians arrested after decades in U.S. CTV News
- ICE detains Iranian woman in New Orleans for 47 years - NOLA.com NOLA
- After Decades in the US, Iranians Arrested in Trump's Deportation ... US News
- Iranians living in US for decades face arrests amid deportation crackdown Business Standard
