Fact Check: "Trump is 'following orders' in foreign policy, not leading."
What We Know
The claim that "Trump is 'following orders' in foreign policy, not leading" suggests a lack of agency or leadership on the part of President Trump in shaping U.S. foreign policy. However, various sources indicate that President Trump actively directed U.S. foreign policy through executive actions and directives. For instance, on February 12, 2025, Trump signed an Executive Order to establish a unified voice for America's foreign relations, reaffirming his authority over foreign policy implementation. This order emphasized that all personnel involved in foreign policy must operate under his direction, thereby reinforcing his role as a leader rather than a follower.
Additionally, Trump's administration has been characterized by a clear focus on an "America First" agenda, which was articulated in various statements and policies. For example, a press statement from January 26, 2025, noted that Trump directed a review of U.S. foreign aid to ensure it aligns with national interests, asserting that the U.S. would no longer provide aid without clear benefits to American citizens (source). This indicates a proactive approach to foreign policy rather than a passive one.
Analysis
The assertion that Trump is merely "following orders" contradicts the evidence of his active engagement in foreign policy. The Executive Order he signed not only centralized authority but also aimed to reform the foreign service to better align with his administration's goals. This suggests a deliberate effort to lead and shape foreign policy rather than simply executing orders from others.
Moreover, the characterization of Trump's foreign policy as "imperialist and expansionist" (source) reflects a broader strategic vision rather than a lack of leadership. Critics may argue that his approach is reactionary or influenced by advisors; however, the evidence shows that Trump consistently positioned himself as the primary decision-maker, often overriding traditional diplomatic norms to assert his vision.
While it is true that any president operates within a complex web of advisors and institutional constraints, the evidence presented does not support the claim that Trump is merely following orders. Instead, it illustrates a president who actively sought to redefine U.S. foreign policy according to his administration's principles.
Conclusion
Verdict: False
The claim that Trump is "following orders" in foreign policy is misleading. Evidence from executive actions and policy statements demonstrates that Trump actively led U.S. foreign policy, asserting his authority and implementing a clear agenda. His administration's focus on an "America First" strategy and the establishment of a unified diplomatic voice further underscore his role as a leader in shaping foreign relations.
