Fact Check: Trump calls birthright citizenship a tool for 'worst people' sneaking into the US
What We Know
In a recent statement, former President Donald Trump claimed that "birthright citizenship" is exploited by "some of the worst people" to enter the United States. This assertion was made during a discussion about immigration policies and the Supreme Court's rulings on citizenship rights. Trump stated, "They used birthright citizenship, some of the worst people, some of the cartels, to get people into our country" (source-3). This comment reflects a broader narrative he has maintained regarding immigration and crime, where he often links undocumented immigrants to criminal activity (source-1).
Analysis
Trump's statement about birthright citizenship being a tool for "the worst people" is a reflection of his long-standing position on immigration. He has frequently characterized undocumented immigrants as criminals or threats to public safety. The claim that birthright citizenship is misused by individuals associated with criminal organizations, such as cartels, is contentious and lacks comprehensive evidence. While it is true that some individuals may exploit legal loopholes, the majority of those benefiting from birthright citizenship are born to parents who are legally residing in the U.S. or are citizens themselves.
The sources that report on Trump's statements, such as NPR and ABC News, are generally considered reliable news outlets. However, they often present Trump's claims without extensive fact-checking or context regarding the broader implications of his statements on immigration policy (source-1, source-3).
Moreover, the assertion that birthright citizenship is a tool for facilitating illegal immigration is not universally accepted among experts. Many argue that birthright citizenship is a constitutional right that should not be conflated with issues of immigration enforcement or criminal activity (source-5).
Conclusion
The claim that Trump called birthright citizenship a tool for "the worst people" sneaking into the U.S. is Partially True. While Trump did make this statement, the context and implications of his claim are more complex. His rhetoric often links immigration with crime, which can misrepresent the realities of birthright citizenship and its beneficiaries. Therefore, while the statement itself is accurate, the broader narrative it supports may not be fully substantiated by evidence.
Sources
- Does a president need to uphold the Constitution? Trump ... (https://www.npr.org/2025/05/04/g-s1-64239/does-a-president-need-to-uphold-the-constitution-trump-says-i-dont-know)
- Comment choisir sa cuisinière ? [Guide 2024] | Electroguide (https://www.electroguide.com/comment-choisir-sa-cuisiniere)
- Trump celebrates Supreme Court decision limiting ... (https://ruralradio.com/kool/abc_news/trump-celebrates-supreme-court-decision-limiting-nationwide-injunctions-on-birthright-citizenship-abcidb16fea1b/)
- Les 7 meilleures gazinières [2024] | Electroguide (https://www.electroguide.com/les-7-meilleures-gazinieres)
- US Supreme Court's birthright citizenship decision ... (https://m.economictimes.com/nri/latest-updates/us-supreme-courts-birthright-citizenship-decision-expected-in-october/articleshow/122116618.cms)
- Les pannes fréquentes sur une cuisinière | Electroguide (https://www.electroguide.com/pannes-frequentes-cuisiniere)
- Avis test : Avis Cuisinière gaz Smeg GP61X9 (Avis 2025) (https://www.electroguide.com/avis-cuisiniere-gaz-smeg-gp61x9)
- Fact-checking Trump's Quotes About Immigrants (https://www.themarshallproject.org/2024/10/21/fact-check-12000-trump-statements-immigrants)
