Fact Check: Trump calls birthright citizenship a 'stupid' constitutional clause.

Fact Check: Trump Calls Birthright Citizenship a 'Stupid' Constitutional Clause

What We Know

On May 15, 2025, President Donald Trump made a series of statements regarding birthright citizenship just before the Supreme Court began hearing arguments related to his executive order aimed at ending this practice. In a post on Truth Social, Trump described the United States as a "STUPID Country" for allowing birthright citizenship, claiming it was exploited by individuals who come to the U.S. temporarily and then seek to establish permanent residency for their families. He stated, “We are, for the sake of being politically correct, a STUPID Country but, in actuality, this is the exact opposite of being politically correct” (source-5, source-3).

Birthright citizenship is enshrined in the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which grants citizenship to all persons born or naturalized in the United States. This clause was ratified in 1868 to ensure citizenship for former slaves and their descendants (source-5).

Analysis

Trump's comments reflect a long-standing criticism from his administration regarding birthright citizenship, which he and his supporters argue has been misapplied. His use of the term "stupid" to describe the constitutional clause indicates a clear disdain for the legal framework surrounding birthright citizenship, suggesting that he believes it is outdated or misused (source-7).

The sources reporting on Trump's statements are credible news outlets, including The Hill and The Daily Beast, which are known for their political coverage. However, the interpretation of Trump's remarks can vary based on the political leanings of the outlets. For instance, while some may view his comments as a legitimate critique of immigration policy, others may see them as inflammatory rhetoric that undermines the constitutional rights of individuals born in the U.S. (source-3, source-7).

Moreover, Trump's framing of birthright citizenship as a "scam" by immigrants is a common narrative in his administration's rhetoric, aimed at galvanizing his base by portraying immigration as a threat to American values (source-5).

Conclusion

The claim that "Trump calls birthright citizenship a 'stupid' constitutional clause" is True. Trump's statements explicitly label the practice as "stupid," reflecting his administration's ongoing criticism of birthright citizenship. His remarks were made in the context of a Supreme Court case regarding his attempts to alter the interpretation of this constitutional right, showcasing his contentious stance on immigration and citizenship.

Fact Check: Trump calls birthright citizenship a 'stupid' constitutional clause.