Fact Check: Trump Appoints Giuliani to Controversial Homeland Security Advisory Council
What We Know
On June 24, 2025, President Donald Trump announced the appointment of several individuals to the Homeland Security Advisory Council (HSAC), including his former attorney, Rudy Giuliani. This council, established in 2002, is intended to provide "real-time, real-world and independent advice on homeland security operations" (CNN). Giuliani's inclusion has raised eyebrows due to his controversial history, particularly his involvement in efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election results and the subsequent lawsuits he faced for defamation (Global News).
Giuliani's spokesperson stated, "Mayor Rudy Giuliani is honored to serve the president and the secretary," emphasizing his preparedness to advise on homeland security issues (CNN). The council's formation and appointments were framed as part of Trump's "America First" agenda, aiming to draw on a diverse range of experiences from both public and private sectors (DHS).
Analysis
The claim that Trump appointed Giuliani to a controversial advisory council is supported by multiple credible sources. The announcement from the Department of Homeland Security confirms Giuliani's appointment alongside other notable figures, including Corey Lewandowski and Mark Levin (DHS, CNN).
Giuliani's past as the mayor of New York City and his role during the September 11 attacks earned him the nickname "America's Mayor." However, his recent actions, particularly his participation in the January 6 Capitol riot and the subsequent legal troubles, have significantly tarnished his reputation (Wikipedia). The appointment has been met with criticism, particularly from those who view it as an endorsement of Giuliani's controversial tactics and statements regarding election integrity (Washington Times).
While the HSAC is intended to provide expert advice, the selection of members with polarizing backgrounds raises questions about the council's objectivity and effectiveness. Critics argue that appointing individuals like Giuliani could undermine the council's credibility and its ability to operate in a non-partisan manner (Global News).
Conclusion
The claim that Trump appointed Giuliani to a controversial Homeland Security advisory council is True. The evidence from multiple reputable sources confirms that Giuliani is indeed among the newly appointed members of the HSAC, which has drawn criticism due to his contentious history and the political implications of his appointment. The council's mission and the backgrounds of its members suggest a potential bias that could affect its advisory role.
Sources
- President Trump Announces Appointments to the Homeland Security Advisory Council
- Rudy Giuliani - Wikipedia
- Giuliani, Lewandowski among new members of Homeland Security advisory council
- Trump taps Rudy Giuliani for Homeland Security Advisory Council
- Giuliani's back: Trump names Rudy to Homeland Security council
