TF
TruthOrFake
Fact Check: Timothy Ryback discussed the 'disturbing echoes' between Nazi Germany and contemporary America, particularly between Adolf Hitler and US President Donald Trump.

Fact Check: Timothy Ryback discussed the 'disturbing echoes' between Nazi Germany and contemporary America, particularly between Adolf Hitler and US President Donald Trump.

June 17, 2025•by TruthOrFake AI
✓
VERDICT
True

# Fact Check: "Timothy Ryback discussed the 'disturbing echoes' between Nazi Germany and contemporary America, particularly between Adolf Hitler and U...

Fact Check: "Timothy Ryback discussed the 'disturbing echoes' between Nazi Germany and contemporary America, particularly between Adolf Hitler and US President Donald Trump."

What We Know

Historian Timothy Ryback, known for his expertise on Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany, recently discussed the parallels he perceives between the rise of Hitler and the political climate in contemporary America, particularly in relation to former President Donald Trump. In a podcast episode titled “Trump, Hitler and how democracies die”, Ryback specifically referred to these similarities as "disturbing echoes." He emphasized that while Trump is not Hitler, there are "modalities that are very similar" in how both figures interacted with democratic institutions (source-4).

Ryback's recent book, Takeover, details how Hitler and his supporters dismantled democracy in Germany through constitutional means, a theme he explored in the podcast (source-3). He argues that the lessons from Hitler's rise are relevant to understanding the current political landscape in the United States (source-5).

Analysis

The claim that Timothy Ryback discussed "disturbing echoes" between Nazi Germany and contemporary America, particularly between Adolf Hitler and Donald Trump, is substantiated by multiple sources. The podcast episode from CBC Radio explicitly features Ryback discussing these parallels, confirming that he indeed used the phrase "disturbing echoes" to describe the similarities he sees (source-1, source-2).

Moreover, Ryback's analysis is not merely sensational; he draws on historical context to illustrate how democratic systems can be undermined from within, a concern he articulates in both his book and interviews (source-4). His credibility as a historian lends weight to his observations, as he is the director of the Institute for Historical Justice and Reconciliation and has authored works on the subject of Nazi Germany (source-1, source-6).

While some critics may argue that comparisons between Trump and Hitler are hyperbolic, Ryback himself acknowledges the differences while emphasizing the importance of recognizing the potential for democratic backsliding (source-5). This nuanced approach indicates a careful consideration of historical parallels rather than a direct equivalence.

Conclusion

The claim that Timothy Ryback discussed the "disturbing echoes" between Nazi Germany and contemporary America, particularly between Adolf Hitler and Donald Trump, is True. Ryback's statements are well-documented in reliable sources, and his analysis is grounded in historical context, making his observations significant in the ongoing discourse about democracy and authoritarianism.

Sources

  1. Trump, Hitler and how democracies die | CBC Radio
  2. Trump, Hitler and how democracies die - CBC.ca
  3. Trump, Hitler and how democrac… - Front Burner - Apple Podcasts
  4. A historian describes the lessons learned — and ignored — from Hitler's ...
  5. What troubles me most? International Hitler expert shares Trump trend ...
  6. Historian Timothy Ryback: "Hitler could only have dreamed" of Trump's ...
  7. Trump, Hitler and how democracies die | Front Burner
  8. Front Burner | iHeart

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

💡 Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
✓100% Free
✓No Registration
✓Instant Results

Comments

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...

More Fact Checks to Explore

Discover similar claims and stay informed with these related fact-checks

🔍
Mostly False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: US President Donald Trump recently expressed optimism about the potential for tariffs to generate substantial revenue, possibly even replacing income tax. In a conversation with Fox Noticias, Trump highlighted the significant financial gains from tariffs, drawing parallels with the late 19th century when the US imposed tariffs and amassed considerable funds. "There is a chance that the money is so great that it could replace" income tax, Trump stated, referencing the period between 1870 and 1913 when tariffs were the primary source of revenue. During this era, the US experienced unprecedented wealth, with Trump noting, "And that's when our nation was relatively the richest. We were the richest." However, Trump acknowledged that any changes to income tax would require Congressional approval, as the legislative body oversees tax policy. Trump's goal is to utilise tariff revenue to support a tax bill that would exempt tips and Social Security from taxation, among other campaign promises. He emphasised the substantial revenue potential, saying, "It could replace the income tax, that's the kind of money". Trump also discussed a historical committee established to manage excess revenue, stating, "And this committee's sole purpose was how to dispose of it, who to give it to, what do we do? And then, brilliantly, in 1913, they went to the income tax system." He further noted that attempts to revive tariffs in the 1930s were unsuccessful, and the Great Depression was incorrectly blamed on tariffs, when in fact, it predated the tariffs. Regarding tariff revenue, Trump said, "Billions and billions of dollars and, hundreds of billions of dollars over a period of a year." He also referenced the significant daily revenue generated from tariffs, stating, "Before I gave a little bit of a pause to lower just a little bit because, you know, it's a transition. You have to be, you have to have a little flexibility. But we were making two billion and three billion dollars a day. We never made money like that." The Trump administration has temporarily halted reciprocal tariffs imposed on nations for 90 days, following Trump's announcement that there would be no pause on tariffs and only negotiations. Meanwhile, the US has imposed 245% tariffs on China, reflecting the ongoing tariff dispute between the two nations.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: US President Donald Trump recently expressed optimism about the potential for tariffs to generate substantial revenue, possibly even replacing income tax. In a conversation with Fox Noticias, Trump highlighted the significant financial gains from tariffs, drawing parallels with the late 19th century when the US imposed tariffs and amassed considerable funds. "There is a chance that the money is so great that it could replace" income tax, Trump stated, referencing the period between 1870 and 1913 when tariffs were the primary source of revenue. During this era, the US experienced unprecedented wealth, with Trump noting, "And that's when our nation was relatively the richest. We were the richest." However, Trump acknowledged that any changes to income tax would require Congressional approval, as the legislative body oversees tax policy. Trump's goal is to utilise tariff revenue to support a tax bill that would exempt tips and Social Security from taxation, among other campaign promises. He emphasised the substantial revenue potential, saying, "It could replace the income tax, that's the kind of money". Trump also discussed a historical committee established to manage excess revenue, stating, "And this committee's sole purpose was how to dispose of it, who to give it to, what do we do? And then, brilliantly, in 1913, they went to the income tax system." He further noted that attempts to revive tariffs in the 1930s were unsuccessful, and the Great Depression was incorrectly blamed on tariffs, when in fact, it predated the tariffs. Regarding tariff revenue, Trump said, "Billions and billions of dollars and, hundreds of billions of dollars over a period of a year." He also referenced the significant daily revenue generated from tariffs, stating, "Before I gave a little bit of a pause to lower just a little bit because, you know, it's a transition. You have to be, you have to have a little flexibility. But we were making two billion and three billion dollars a day. We never made money like that." The Trump administration has temporarily halted reciprocal tariffs imposed on nations for 90 days, following Trump's announcement that there would be no pause on tariffs and only negotiations. Meanwhile, the US has imposed 245% tariffs on China, reflecting the ongoing tariff dispute between the two nations.

Apr 21, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer discussed de-escalation efforts regarding the Middle East conflict with U.S. President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu before the G-7 summit.
True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer discussed de-escalation efforts regarding the Middle East conflict with U.S. President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu before the G-7 summit.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer discussed de-escalation efforts regarding the Middle East conflict with U.S. President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu before the G-7 summit.

Jun 15, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Putin and Trump discussed the ongoing exchange of war prisoners between Russia and Ukraine, which included seriously wounded individuals and prisoners under 25 years of age.
Needs Research
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Putin and Trump discussed the ongoing exchange of war prisoners between Russia and Ukraine, which included seriously wounded individuals and prisoners under 25 years of age.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Putin and Trump discussed the ongoing exchange of war prisoners between Russia and Ukraine, which included seriously wounded individuals and prisoners under 25 years of age.

Jun 14, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Michèlle Bradshaw Harper is the Chairman of the IDU as of 2018, though he didn't start it. It was started in 1983 by some pretty prestigious political figures. Russia is not a member nor is Trump as an individual. The Republican party is. Ukraine is a member as well. Harper would know what was going on as he was prime minister at the time. I trust what he says any day over Carney. Carney has been caught in lies several times in the last couple of months. Flaherty was the architect of the economic recovery, not Carney. That's quite a stretch to call legally elected people "dictators". You need to learn the difference between opinion and fact. Harper was there to show support for Ukraine. I quote: " I was pleased to meet with Fidesz party leader Prime Minister Victor Orban in Budapest. We discussed the IDU's strong support of Ukraine, and the importance of centre right parties strengthening their collaboration." Stephen Harper.
Partially True

Fact Check: Michèlle Bradshaw Harper is the Chairman of the IDU as of 2018, though he didn't start it. It was started in 1983 by some pretty prestigious political figures. Russia is not a member nor is Trump as an individual. The Republican party is. Ukraine is a member as well. Harper would know what was going on as he was prime minister at the time. I trust what he says any day over Carney. Carney has been caught in lies several times in the last couple of months. Flaherty was the architect of the economic recovery, not Carney. That's quite a stretch to call legally elected people "dictators". You need to learn the difference between opinion and fact. Harper was there to show support for Ukraine. I quote: " I was pleased to meet with Fidesz party leader Prime Minister Victor Orban in Budapest. We discussed the IDU's strong support of Ukraine, and the importance of centre right parties strengthening their collaboration." Stephen Harper.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Michèlle Bradshaw Harper is the Chairman of the IDU as of 2018, though he didn't start it. It was started in 1983 by some pretty prestigious political figures. Russia is not a member nor is Trump as an individual. The Republican party is. Ukraine is a member as well. Harper would know what was going on as he was prime minister at the time. I trust what he says any day over Carney. Carney has been caught in lies several times in the last couple of months. Flaherty was the architect of the economic recovery, not Carney. That's quite a stretch to call legally elected people "dictators". You need to learn the difference between opinion and fact. Harper was there to show support for Ukraine. I quote: " I was pleased to meet with Fidesz party leader Prime Minister Victor Orban in Budapest. We discussed the IDU's strong support of Ukraine, and the importance of centre right parties strengthening their collaboration." Stephen Harper.

Mar 11, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Governor J.B. Pritzker discussed Donald Trump's abuse of the military in relation to his deportation policies during an interview with Jen Psaki.
True

Fact Check: Governor J.B. Pritzker discussed Donald Trump's abuse of the military in relation to his deportation policies during an interview with Jen Psaki.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Governor J.B. Pritzker discussed Donald Trump's abuse of the military in relation to his deportation policies during an interview with Jen Psaki.

Jun 15, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Historian Timothy Ryback published a book titled 'Takeover' in 2022, which documents how Adolf Hitler and his enablers in the German establishment cleared the pathway to Nazism through constitutional means.
Partially True

Fact Check: Historian Timothy Ryback published a book titled 'Takeover' in 2022, which documents how Adolf Hitler and his enablers in the German establishment cleared the pathway to Nazism through constitutional means.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Historian Timothy Ryback published a book titled 'Takeover' in 2022, which documents how Adolf Hitler and his enablers in the German establishment cleared the pathway to Nazism through constitutional means.

Jun 17, 2025
Read more →
Explore All Fact Checks