Fact Check: There is a Donald duck comic parodying Lovecraft

Claim Analysis: "There is a Donald Duck comic parodying Lovecraft"

1. Introduction

The claim under examination is that there exists a Donald Duck comic that parodies the works of H.P. Lovecraft. This assertion suggests a crossover between the whimsical world of Disney's Donald Duck and the cosmic horror themes prevalent in Lovecraft's literature. To evaluate this claim, we will explore available sources that discuss Donald Duck comics and their potential connections to Lovecraftian themes.

2. What We Know

Several sources provide information regarding the intersection of Donald Duck comics and Lovecraftian themes:

• Pf'legmwad: According to the H.P. Lovecraft Wiki, Pf'legmwad is a fictional monster featured in the Donald Duck comic titled "The Call of C'rruso," which is explicitly noted as a parody of the Cthulhu Mythos 4. This comic appears to incorporate elements typical of Lovecraft's work, such as bizarre creatures and cosmic horror.

• Plot Elements: A Tumblr post mentions a plot where Donald Duck is the only character capable of taming the elder god Cthulhu with his extraordinary voice 6. This further supports the idea that there are comics where Lovecraftian themes are humorously adapted.

• General Influence: A Wikipedia entry lists various works influenced by the Cthulhu Mythos, indicating that Lovecraft's ideas have permeated popular culture, including comics 1. However, it does not specifically mention Donald Duck comics.

• Comic Reviews: A review of "The Call of C'rruso" describes it as a light parody, highlighting the absurdity of the plot and the humor derived from Donald's character 5. This suggests that the comic does indeed engage with Lovecraftian themes in a comedic manner.

3. Analysis

The evidence supporting the claim that there is a Donald Duck comic parodying Lovecraft is relatively strong, particularly with the specific mention of "The Call of C'rruso." However, the reliability of the sources varies:

• H.P. Lovecraft Wiki: This source is a fan-driven platform, which may lack rigorous editorial oversight. While it provides specific information about Pf'legmwad and the comic in question, the reliability of the claims should be approached with caution due to potential bias and the nature of fan-created content 4.

• Tumblr Posts: The posts discussing the plot involving Cthulhu and Donald Duck 6 are anecdotal and lack formal citation. While they provide interesting context, they do not serve as definitive evidence of the comic's existence or its themes.

• Wikipedia: The entry on works influenced by the Cthulhu Mythos is generally reliable, as it aggregates information from various sources. However, it does not specifically address Donald Duck comics, which limits its usefulness in confirming the claim 1.

• Comic Reviews: The review from Pop Culture Buffet 5 appears to provide a direct analysis of the comic, which adds credibility to the claim. However, the review is subjective and may reflect the author's personal interpretation rather than an objective analysis.

Overall, while there is evidence suggesting that a Donald Duck comic does parody Lovecraft, the sources vary in reliability and depth of information.

4. Conclusion

Verdict: True

The claim that there exists a Donald Duck comic parodying the works of H.P. Lovecraft is supported by several pieces of evidence, particularly the comic titled "The Call of C'rruso," which features a character named Pf'legmwad, a parody of Lovecraft's Cthulhu Mythos. Additionally, anecdotal references to plot elements involving Donald Duck and Cthulhu further reinforce this assertion.

However, it is important to note that while the evidence is compelling, the sources vary in reliability. The H.P. Lovecraft Wiki is a fan-driven site, which may introduce bias, and anecdotal posts from platforms like Tumblr lack formal citation. Therefore, while the claim is substantiated, readers should approach the evidence with a critical mindset and consider the context in which it was presented.

As with any claim, it is advisable for readers to independently evaluate the information and consider the nuances involved in the intersection of popular culture and literary parody.

5. Sources

1. List of works influenced by the Cthulhu Mythos - Wikipedia. Link
2. Calisota Dreaming — In which Donald discovers the joys of... Link
3. 10 Donald Duck Comics You Didn't Even Know Existed - CBR. Link
4. Pf'legmwad | The H.P. Lovecraft Wiki. Link
5. Donald Duck: The Call of C'rruso Reviewcap... Link
6. Hey yeah, remember that time Donald met Cthulhu... Link
7. THE ARCHETYPAL ARCHIVE: MYTHCOMICS #13: MAD #19 (1955) - Blogger. Link
8. Donald Duck # 1: Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming: Internet Archive. Link
9. Category:Comic Books | The H.P. Lovecraft Wiki. Link
10. Disney Ducks Comic Universe. Link