Fact Check: The suspect had no prior criminal record in New York City.

Fact Check: The suspect had no prior criminal record in New York City.

Published July 6, 2025
by TruthOrFake AI
?
VERDICT
Unverified

# Fact Check: "The suspect had no prior criminal record in New York City." ## What We Know The claim that "the suspect had no prior criminal record i...

Fact Check: "The suspect had no prior criminal record in New York City."

What We Know

The claim that "the suspect had no prior criminal record in New York City" hinges on the accuracy of criminal history records maintained by the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS). According to the DCJS, they are the official source for criminal history records in New York State. Individuals can request their own criminal history record, which includes details of arrests, indictments, and convictions. A response may either confirm the existence of a criminal record or provide a "no record" response, indicating that the individual has no criminal history in New York State.

The process requires individuals to submit fingerprints, which allows DCJS to match them to their records. This ensures that the information is accurate and specific to the individual requesting it. Importantly, records of individuals convicted of certain serious crimes, such as sex crimes and non-drug Class A felonies, are not eligible for sealing under the state's Clean Slate Act, which is set to take effect on November 16, 2024 (NYC311).

Analysis

To evaluate the claim, we must consider the reliability of the sources and the processes involved in obtaining criminal history records. The DCJS is the only official agency responsible for maintaining and providing access to these records, making it a credible source for verifying criminal history (source-1). However, the process of obtaining a criminal history record is not straightforward; it requires a formal request and the submission of fingerprints.

The claim's validity also depends on whether the suspect has undergone this process. If the suspect has not requested their criminal history through the DCJS, there is no definitive way to confirm the absence of a record. Furthermore, third-party background checks may not provide complete or accurate information, as they often rely on public databases rather than the official records maintained by the DCJS (source-2).

Additionally, the Clean Slate Act will eventually allow for the sealing of certain records, but until the implementation of this law, any criminal history record provided through the DCJS will include all convictions that are not sealed by a court order (source-1).

Conclusion

The claim that "the suspect had no prior criminal record in New York City" is currently Unverified. While the DCJS is the authoritative source for criminal history records, the absence of a record can only be confirmed through a formal request that includes fingerprinting. Without evidence that such a request has been made or that the suspect has undergone this verification process, we cannot definitively state the accuracy of the claim.

Sources

  1. Criminal History Records, Background Checks - NY DCJS
  2. Criminal Records Basics | NY CourtHelp
  3. FAQ's - Criminal History Record Search | NYCOURTS.GOV
  4. Criminal Record ยท NYC311
  5. Criminal Background Check (CBC)
  6. YOUR NEW YORK STATE RAP SHEET
  7. Criminal Justice Process - NYPD
  8. When Is a Pre-Sentence Report Required in New York?

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

๐Ÿ’ก Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
โœ“100% Free
โœ“No Registration
โœ“Instant Results

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...