Fact Check: "The majority of immigrants coming to the US are from mental institutions, jails and insane asylums."
What We Know
The claim that the majority of immigrants coming to the United States are from mental institutions, jails, and insane asylums has been made by various public figures, notably former President Donald Trump. He asserted that "millions of people from jails, from prisons, from insane asylums, from mental institutions" are entering the U.S. (source-5). However, this assertion lacks credible evidence and is contradicted by data from multiple sources.
-
Immigration Statistics: According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, the majority of immigrants come from countries like Mexico, China, and India, primarily for reasons related to family reunification, employment, and humanitarian protection, rather than from institutional settings (source-3).
-
Mental Health and Immigration: Research indicates that individuals with severe mental illnesses are often not overrepresented among immigrants. The history of mental health treatment in the U.S. has shifted significantly, with a focus on community-based care rather than institutionalization (source-2). The current system emphasizes support for individuals already living with mental health challenges rather than exporting them as immigrants.
-
Expert Opinions: Experts from various organizations, including those that advocate for immigrant rights, have stated that there is no evidence supporting the claim that large numbers of immigrants are released from mental institutions or jails specifically to migrate to the U.S. (source-6).
Analysis
The claim is primarily rooted in a political narrative rather than factual evidence. Trump's assertion has been labeled as "ridiculous" by fact-checkers, who emphasize that there is no data or credible studies supporting the idea that a significant portion of immigrants are coming from jails or mental institutions (source-5).
-
Source Reliability: The sources that debunk this claim include reputable fact-checking organizations and academic research. For instance, the Harvard Bioethics Journal discusses the broader context of immigration and displacement, indicating that the reasons for immigration are complex and multifaceted, not simply a matter of institutional release.
-
Historical Context: The history of mental health treatment in the U.S. has evolved through several reform cycles, focusing on deinstitutionalization and community support rather than institutionalization (source-2). This context is crucial in understanding the current landscape of mental health and immigration.
-
Lack of Evidence: The assertion lacks empirical support. Organizations that typically advocate for stricter immigration policies have also been unable to provide evidence for such claims (source-6). This raises questions about the motivations behind the statement, suggesting it may be more about political rhetoric than factual accuracy.
Conclusion
The claim that the majority of immigrants coming to the U.S. are from mental institutions, jails, and insane asylums is False. There is no credible evidence to support this assertion, and it contradicts established immigration patterns and mental health treatment history in the United States. The narrative appears to be politically motivated rather than based on factual data.
Sources
- Immigration and Insanity
- Cycles of reform in the history of psychosis treatment ...
- Who Seeks Asylum in the United States and Why? Some ...
- INSANE IN HOSPITALS
- Trump's ridiculous claim that "millions" of immigrants came illegally ...
- Fact check: Trump's own campaign can't find proof for his 'mental ...
- Fact-checking Over 12,000 of Donald Trump's Quotes About Immigrants
- Trump's Asylum Rhetoric Is Rooted in the Mariel Boatlift
