Fact Check: "The Bloods and the Crips have both murdered more African Americans than the police"
What We Know
The claim that the Bloods and the Crips have murdered more African Americans than the police is a complex assertion that requires careful examination of homicide statistics and the context surrounding gang violence.
-
Homicide Rates: Homicide is a leading cause of death among African Americans, particularly young males. According to a study analyzing homicide rates in Los Angeles County, street gangs significantly contribute to local homicide rates, with gang-related homicides accounting for as much as 45% of all homicides in certain areas during specific years (Robinson et al.).
-
Gang Violence: The Bloods and the Crips are two of the most notorious street gangs in the United States, primarily involved in violent crime, including murder. Their conflicts have historically resulted in a high number of homicides, particularly among African American communities (Wikipedia).
-
Police-Involved Homicides: Data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics indicates that a significant portion of violent crime offenders are Black or African American, but it does not provide a direct comparison of the number of murders committed by gangs versus those committed by police (BJS).
-
Context of Violence: The violence attributed to gangs is often a result of territorial disputes, drug trafficking, and socio-economic factors. The presence of gangs in urban areas has been linked to higher overall homicide rates, independent of other community factors (Robinson et al.).
Analysis
The assertion that the Bloods and the Crips have murdered more African Americans than the police is partially true but requires nuanced interpretation:
-
Supporting Evidence: Studies indicate that gang-related homicides constitute a significant portion of overall homicides in urban settings. For instance, in Los Angeles, gang-related homicides accounted for a substantial percentage of total homicides during certain periods (Robinson et al.). This suggests that the cumulative impact of gang violence on African American communities is considerable.
-
Contradicting Evidence: However, quantifying the exact number of murders committed by these gangs compared to police-involved shootings is challenging. While police violence against African Americans is a critical issue, comprehensive data comparing the two is scarce. The FBI's statistics indicate that a significant percentage of murder arrests involve Black or African American individuals, but this does not directly correlate to the number of murders committed by gangs versus police (FBI).
-
Source Reliability: The sources used in this analysis vary in reliability. Academic studies like those by Robinson et al. provide peer-reviewed insights into gang violence and its effects on homicide rates, while media articles and Wikipedia entries may contain biases or lack comprehensive data. Therefore, while they provide context, they should be interpreted with caution.
Conclusion
The claim that the Bloods and the Crips have murdered more African Americans than the police is partially true. While gang violence has historically resulted in a significant number of homicides within African American communities, direct comparisons to police-involved killings are complicated by a lack of comprehensive data. The impact of gang violence is profound, but the assertion requires careful contextualization to fully understand the dynamics of violence in these communities.
Sources
- The Effect of Urban Street Gang Densities on Small Area Homicide Incidence in a Large Metropolitan County, 1994–2002
- Gangs and Race: A Look at New Jersey Police
- Race and Ethnicity of Violent Crime Offenders and Arrestees, 2018
- Blood vs. Crips: Exploring the Differences Between
- FBI — Table 43
- Crips-Bloods Gang War - Wikipedia
- African-American Organized Crime - Wikipedia
- What Does It Take to Stop Crips and Bloods From Killing Each Other?