Fact Check: Tesla's FSD Software Version 13.2.9 Demonstrated Running Over a Child-Sized Mannequin
What We Know
Recent tests conducted by an independent group, The Dawn Project, have shown that Tesla's Full Self-Driving (FSD) software version 13.2.9 failed to recognize and stop for a child-sized mannequin during simulations. In these tests, the vehicle consistently ran over the mannequin, which was dressed in various colored coats to simulate a child running across the street, particularly in scenarios involving a school bus with its stop lights activated (Driving.ca [source-2]). The tests were repeated multiple times, and in every instance, the Tesla vehicle did not stop, raising serious concerns about the safety and reliability of the FSD system (Dawn Project [source-4]).
Analysis
The evidence from the tests conducted by The Dawn Project is compelling and raises significant safety concerns regarding Tesla's FSD technology. The fact that the vehicle repeatedly failed to stop for a child-sized mannequin, even while ignoring the presence of a school bus with flashing lights, indicates a critical flaw in the software's ability to detect and respond to potential hazards (The Register [source-6]).
The reliability of the sources reporting on these tests is notable. The Dawn Project is known for its advocacy in public safety, particularly concerning autonomous vehicle technology, which lends credibility to their findings. Additionally, the reports from established automotive news outlets provide a balanced view of the situation, although it's essential to consider potential biases against Tesla due to ongoing scrutiny of its safety practices (Driving.ca [source-2]).
Critics of Tesla have long pointed out that the branding of its FSD system is misleading, as it implies a level of autonomy that the technology does not currently possess. This incident further underscores the argument that Tesla's marketing may not align with the actual capabilities of its software, potentially endangering users and pedestrians alike (Driving.ca [source-2]).
Conclusion
The claim that Tesla's FSD software version 13.2.9 demonstrated running over a child-sized mannequin is True. The independent tests conducted by The Dawn Project provide clear evidence that the software failed to detect and stop for a simulated child, raising serious concerns about its safety and effectiveness. This incident highlights the ongoing debate about the reliability of autonomous driving technologies and the implications of their marketing.
