Fact Check: Supreme Court ruling opens door for class action lawsuits against Trump's citizenship order.

Fact Check: Supreme Court ruling opens door for class action lawsuits against Trump's citizenship order

What We Know

The claim that a Supreme Court ruling has opened the door for class action lawsuits against former President Donald Trump's citizenship order is misleading. The Supreme Court has not issued a ruling that directly addresses this issue. In fact, the Supreme Court's decision in Department of Commerce v. New York (2019) primarily dealt with the inclusion of a citizenship question in the 2020 Census, which was ultimately blocked. The ruling did not establish a precedent for class action lawsuits against immigration policies or executive orders related to citizenship status (source-1).

Analysis

The assertion that the Supreme Court ruling facilitates class action lawsuits is based on a misunderstanding of the court's jurisdiction and the nature of the ruling itself. The Department of Commerce v. New York case focused on administrative procedures rather than the substantive legality of citizenship orders. The ruling emphasized the need for transparency and rationality in government decision-making, but it did not create a legal pathway for individuals or groups to file class action lawsuits against executive orders concerning citizenship (source-2).

Furthermore, the sources discussing the ruling do not indicate any legal changes that would allow for class action lawsuits specifically targeting Trump's citizenship order. The complexities of immigration law and executive power mean that any potential lawsuits would likely face significant legal hurdles, including standing and jurisdictional issues (source-3).

The credibility of the claim is further diminished by the lack of reputable legal analysis supporting it. Most legal experts and commentators have focused on the implications of the ruling regarding census procedures rather than its potential effects on immigration policy or class action lawsuits (source-4).

Conclusion

The claim that a Supreme Court ruling has opened the door for class action lawsuits against Trump's citizenship order is False. The Supreme Court's decision in Department of Commerce v. New York does not provide a basis for such lawsuits, as it primarily addressed issues related to the census rather than immigration policy. There is no legal precedent established by this ruling that would facilitate class action lawsuits against executive orders regarding citizenship.

Fact Check: Supreme Court ruling opens door for class action lawsuits against Trump's citizenship order.