Fact Check: Republicans Push to Revoke Citizenship of a Socialist Candidate in NYC
What We Know
Following the recent Democratic primary victory of Zohran Mamdani, a self-identified democratic socialist, over former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, several Republican figures have called for his deportation and denaturalization. Mamdani, who became a U.S. citizen in 2018, has faced scrutiny from Republicans who argue that he is not "American enough" due to his relatively recent citizenship and his political views. Notably, Republican Representative Andy Ogles of Tennessee has explicitly stated that Mamdani should be subject to denaturalization proceedings, claiming he may have obtained his citizenship through "willful misrepresentation" or "concealment of material support for terrorism" (Newsweek).
Additionally, Tom Homan, a former official in the Trump administration, commented on the situation, suggesting that federal law would override any local efforts by Mamdani to expel ICE from New York City, which he described as a "sanctuary city" (NDTV). The New York Young Republicans Club has also joined the calls for Mamdani's citizenship to be revoked, asserting that he poses a threat to the city (Newsweek).
Analysis
The claim that Republicans are actively pushing to revoke Mamdani's citizenship is substantiated by multiple sources. The calls for his deportation and denaturalization are not merely opinions but are being articulated by prominent Republican figures and organizations. For instance, Ogles' public statements, including derogatory remarks about Mamdani's ethnicity and political beliefs, highlight a concerted effort to challenge his legitimacy as a candidate (Newsweek, Mint).
However, the process of denaturalization in the U.S. is complex and rare, typically requiring substantial evidence of fraud or criminal activity at the time of naturalization (NDTV). This raises questions about the feasibility of the Republicans' demands, as the legal hurdles for denaturalization are significant.
The sources reporting on this issue, including Newsweek and NDTV, are generally reputable, with established journalistic standards. Newsweek has a history of covering political issues comprehensively, while NDTV is a well-known news outlet in India that also reports on international matters. However, as with any politically charged topic, it is essential to consider potential biases, particularly in how the narratives are framed.
Conclusion
Verdict: True. The claim that Republicans are pushing to revoke the citizenship of Zohran Mamdani is accurate. High-profile Republican figures have publicly called for his deportation and denaturalization, citing his political views and recent citizenship. While the legal basis for such actions is questionable, the calls themselves are well-documented and represent a significant political response to Mamdani's candidacy.
Sources
- Why Republicans Want Donald Trump To Revoke Zohran Mamdani's US Citizenship
- House Republican Wants Zohran Mamdani Deported - Newsweek
- Republicans call for Zohran Mamdani's deportation, question his citizenship over NYC mayoral candidate's anti-ICE stance
- Is Zohran Mamdani's US Citizenship at Risk? Why Republicans Want Donald Trump To Revoke It
