TF
TruthOrFake
Fact Check: ProPublica exposed 'cruel and dumb AI formulas' used to cancel VA contracts.

Fact Check: ProPublica exposed 'cruel and dumb AI formulas' used to cancel VA contracts.

Published June 27, 2025
by TruthOrFake AI
±
VERDICT
Partially True

# Fact Check: "ProPublica exposed 'cruel and dumb AI formulas' used to cancel VA contracts." ## What We Know The claim that ProPublica exposed "cruel...

Fact Check: "ProPublica exposed 'cruel and dumb AI formulas' used to cancel VA contracts."

What We Know

The claim that ProPublica exposed "cruel and dumb AI formulas" used to cancel VA contracts stems from a series of reports and statements made by U.S. Senators Richard Blumenthal and Angus King. According to their findings, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) used flawed and error-prone artificial intelligence (AI) tools to inform decisions about canceling contracts that were essential for veteran services. The Senators highlighted that these AI tools did not incorporate meaningful input from VA career experts, which raises concerns about the decision-making process and its implications for veterans' care (Blumenthal, King Call on VA's Office of Inspector General to ..., Senators Demand Investigation of DOGE's AI-Driven VA ... - ProPublica).

ProPublica's reporting indicated that the VA's Office of Government Efficiency (DOGE) employed these AI algorithms to assess contracts for cancellation, leading to significant operational disruptions within the VA (ProPublica — Investigative Journalism and News in the Public …, DOGE used flawed AI tool to 'munch' Veteran Affairs contracts, report ...). The reports suggest that the use of such AI tools resulted in a chaotic cancellation process, with hundreds of contracts being terminated in a short period, many of which were critical for veteran services (Blumenthal, King Call on VA's Office of Inspector General to ..., Senators Demand Transparency on Canceled VA Contracts - ProPublica).

Analysis

The evidence supporting the claim comes from credible sources, including statements from U.S. Senators and investigative reporting by ProPublica, a well-regarded nonprofit newsroom known for its investigative journalism. The Senators' call for an investigation into the VA's contract cancellations and the use of AI tools indicates a serious concern about the implications of these decisions on veteran care (The Honorable David Case - veterans.senate.gov, King, Blumenthal Call for Investigation into Cancelled ...).

However, the phrase "cruel and dumb" is subjective and not directly quoted from the sources. While the reports do highlight the flawed nature of the AI tools and the chaotic process, they do not explicitly label the AI as "cruel and dumb." This language appears to be an interpretation or paraphrase of the concerns raised by the Senators and ProPublica's reporting.

The reliability of the sources is high, as they include official statements from U.S. Senators and reputable investigative journalism. ProPublica has a strong track record of uncovering issues related to government and corporate accountability, which lends credibility to their findings (About Us - ProPublica).

Conclusion

The claim that ProPublica exposed "cruel and dumb AI formulas" used to cancel VA contracts is Partially True. While it accurately reflects the essence of the reports regarding the use of flawed AI tools in the VA's contract cancellation process, the specific wording "cruel and dumb" is not directly cited from the sources. The underlying issues raised about the impact of these AI tools on veterans' services are indeed serious and warrant further investigation.

Sources

  1. The Honorable David Case - veterans.senate.gov
  2. Blumenthal, King Call on VA's Office of Inspector General to ...
  3. King, Blumenthal Call for Investigation into Cancelled ...
  4. Senators Demand Investigation of DOGE's AI-Driven VA ... - ProPublica
  5. DOGE used flawed AI tool to 'munch' Veteran Affairs contracts, report ...
  6. ProPublica — Investigative Journalism and News in the Public …
  7. Senators Demand Transparency on Canceled VA Contracts - ProPublica
  8. About Us - ProPublica

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

💡 Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
✓100% Free
✓No Registration
✓Instant Results

Comments

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...

More Fact Checks to Explore

Discover similar claims and stay informed with these related fact-checks

🔍
False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Exposed: FBI in Emergency Operation to Protect Epstein’s Elite Pedophile Network — Over 1,000 Agents Reassigned to Bury the Truth Before Trump Releases the Bombshell Files! The FBI has officially declared war on truth. What’s happening in their New York office isn’t justice — it’s a high-level operation to protect child traffickers in suits, crowns, and boardrooms. Trump is forcing their hand. He holds the full list — unredacted. And now, over 1,000 FBI agents have been pulled from national security to do one thing: scrub the Epstein files before they go public. Think about that. While cartels flood the border, foreign threats rise, and Americans suffer — the FBI is pulling 12-hour overnight shifts to protect rapists of children. They're not investigating — they’re sanitizing evidence to keep the power structure intact. This is a deep state firewall operation. Agents have been ordered to redact victims’ info — but leave Epstein’s associates untouched. The monsters stay anonymous. The system stays safe. It’s not a mistake. It’s a plan. This isn’t about Epstein. It never was. This is about the ones he served — the shadow government. The ones who blackmailed politicians, compromised world leaders, and used Epstein’s island as a trap. The names in those files could shatter the global order. Judges. Tech CEOs. Media puppeteers. Royals. Intelligence assets. Trump isn’t playing their game anymore. He forced the release of JFK files last week — fully unredacted. He knows it’s all connected: JFK, MLK, Epstein. All silenced by the same machine. And now the machine is glitching. FBI’s NY field director James Dennehy was forced to resign days after the exposure. He didn’t “retire.” He was pushed out. The house of cards is falling, and Trump is pulling the thread. Pam Bondi promised transparency. She delivered lies. But she accidentally admitted it: SDNY is hiding thousands more Epstein files. The same courts that protected Epstein are still protecting the network. But Trump already has everything. That’s why they’re panicking. That’s why agents are sleeping in the office. Not to save you — to save the elites. The redactions mean nothing. The real files are coming. And when they hit — it won’t just expose Epstein. It will expose the entire shadow empire: banks, royalty, Hollywood, Big Pharma, the Vatican. This is the collapse. Trump broke the firewall. They can’t stop what’s coming. Tick-tock.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Exposed: FBI in Emergency Operation to Protect Epstein’s Elite Pedophile Network — Over 1,000 Agents Reassigned to Bury the Truth Before Trump Releases the Bombshell Files! The FBI has officially declared war on truth. What’s happening in their New York office isn’t justice — it’s a high-level operation to protect child traffickers in suits, crowns, and boardrooms. Trump is forcing their hand. He holds the full list — unredacted. And now, over 1,000 FBI agents have been pulled from national security to do one thing: scrub the Epstein files before they go public. Think about that. While cartels flood the border, foreign threats rise, and Americans suffer — the FBI is pulling 12-hour overnight shifts to protect rapists of children. They're not investigating — they’re sanitizing evidence to keep the power structure intact. This is a deep state firewall operation. Agents have been ordered to redact victims’ info — but leave Epstein’s associates untouched. The monsters stay anonymous. The system stays safe. It’s not a mistake. It’s a plan. This isn’t about Epstein. It never was. This is about the ones he served — the shadow government. The ones who blackmailed politicians, compromised world leaders, and used Epstein’s island as a trap. The names in those files could shatter the global order. Judges. Tech CEOs. Media puppeteers. Royals. Intelligence assets. Trump isn’t playing their game anymore. He forced the release of JFK files last week — fully unredacted. He knows it’s all connected: JFK, MLK, Epstein. All silenced by the same machine. And now the machine is glitching. FBI’s NY field director James Dennehy was forced to resign days after the exposure. He didn’t “retire.” He was pushed out. The house of cards is falling, and Trump is pulling the thread. Pam Bondi promised transparency. She delivered lies. But she accidentally admitted it: SDNY is hiding thousands more Epstein files. The same courts that protected Epstein are still protecting the network. But Trump already has everything. That’s why they’re panicking. That’s why agents are sleeping in the office. Not to save you — to save the elites. The redactions mean nothing. The real files are coming. And when they hit — it won’t just expose Epstein. It will expose the entire shadow empire: banks, royalty, Hollywood, Big Pharma, the Vatican. This is the collapse. Trump broke the firewall. They can’t stop what’s coming. Tick-tock.

Apr 10, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Democrat-Led Plot Against Trump EXPOSED- It's Worse Than We Thought
Partially True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Democrat-Led Plot Against Trump EXPOSED- It's Worse Than We Thought

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Democrat-Led Plot Against Trump EXPOSED- It's Worse Than We Thought

Jun 25, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Democrat-Led Plot Against Trump EXPOSED- It's Worse Than We Thought
Partially True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Democrat-Led Plot Against Trump EXPOSED- It's Worse Than We Thought

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Democrat-Led Plot Against Trump EXPOSED- It's Worse Than We Thought

Jun 25, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Trump's nature is exposed through his militarized tactics.
Partially True

Fact Check: Trump's nature is exposed through his militarized tactics.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Trump's nature is exposed through his militarized tactics.

Jun 22, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: ALL Apple, Facebook and Google users are being told to change their passwords right now – after a colossal leak exposed as many as 16 billion logins. It's being called one of the largest data breaches in history, giving hackers "unprecedented access" to your personal info and online accounts, experts warn.
Partially True

Fact Check: ALL Apple, Facebook and Google users are being told to change their passwords right now – after a colossal leak exposed as many as 16 billion logins. It's being called one of the largest data breaches in history, giving hackers "unprecedented access" to your personal info and online accounts, experts warn.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: ALL Apple, Facebook and Google users are being told to change their passwords right now – after a colossal leak exposed as many as 16 billion logins. It's being called one of the largest data breaches in history, giving hackers "unprecedented access" to your personal info and online accounts, experts warn.

Jun 20, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: The ProPublica investigation suggests that the Bukele government may have diverted U.S. aid funds to MS-13 in exchange for votes and reduced homicide rates.
True

Fact Check: The ProPublica investigation suggests that the Bukele government may have diverted U.S. aid funds to MS-13 in exchange for votes and reduced homicide rates.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: The ProPublica investigation suggests that the Bukele government may have diverted U.S. aid funds to MS-13 in exchange for votes and reduced homicide rates.

Jun 16, 2025
Read more →
Explore All Fact Checks