Fact Check: Players who use splicing in Speedrunning is against the rule of Speedrun and is considered as cheating

Fact Check: "Players who use splicing in Speedrunning is against the rule of Speedrun and is considered as cheating"

What We Know

Splicing in speedrunning refers to the practice of combining segments from different runs to create a single, continuous speedrun video. This method is widely recognized as a form of cheating within the speedrunning community, especially when the rules specify that runs must be completed in a "single segment" (Speedrunning forum, source-3). According to the Speedrunning Wikipedia page, splicing is considered the most popular method of cheating, as it undermines the integrity of the speedrun by misrepresenting the player's actual performance.

The community has established guidelines regarding what constitutes cheating, and splicing is explicitly listed as a prohibited method when the rules dictate that runs must be completed in one continuous session (Speedrun.com, source-7). Furthermore, a report on cheating in speedrunning highlights that splicing is often associated with attempts to present a false narrative of skill and achievement, which is contrary to the spirit of fair competition.

Analysis

The claim that splicing is against the rules and considered cheating is supported by multiple credible sources. The MIT project paper discusses the challenges of maintaining integrity in speedrunning, noting that as the community grows, the issue of cheating becomes more pressing. This aligns with the general consensus in the speedrunning community, as outlined in the Speedrunning Wikipedia page and the Speed Demos Archive, which both emphasize that splicing is a significant concern.

However, it is important to note that not all speedrunning categories prohibit splicing. Some categories may allow segmented runs, where players can use splicing as long as it is explicitly permitted by the rules of that specific category (Speedrunning forum, source-3). This nuance indicates that while splicing is generally viewed as cheating in single-segment categories, it is not universally banned across all speedrunning formats.

The reliability of the sources used in this analysis is high. The Wikipedia page is a well-maintained resource that aggregates information from various credible sources, while the discussions on forums like Speedrun.com and Speed Demos Archive reflect the opinions and rules established by the community itself. The MIT project paper provides an academic perspective on the integrity issues within speedrunning, further supporting the claim.

Conclusion

The claim that "players who use splicing in speedrunning are against the rules and considered as cheating" is Partially True. While splicing is indeed considered cheating in categories that require single-segment runs, it may be permissible in other categories where segmented runs are allowed. Thus, the context of the speedrun category is crucial in determining whether splicing is deemed cheating.

Fact Check: Players who use splicing in Speedrunning is against the rule of Speedrun and is considered as cheating