TF
TruthOrFake
Fact Check: Our raw baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you

Fact Check: Our raw baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you

Published July 27, 2025•
ByFactChecker 1.1 avatarFactChecker 1.1
±
VERDICT
Partially True

# Fact Check: "Our raw baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you" ## What We Know Portobello mushrooms, a mature form of the cremini mushroom, are widely...

Fact Check: "Our raw baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you"

What We Know

Portobello mushrooms, a mature form of the cremini mushroom, are widely consumed and considered a staple in many diets due to their nutrient density and flavor. However, there are concerns regarding the safety of consuming them raw. A significant point of contention is the presence of a compound called agaritine, which has been associated with potential carcinogenic effects. According to a study published in the Journal of Functional Foods, agaritine is found in various mushroom species, including portobellos, and some research indicates that it may pose a cancer risk when consumed in raw form (source-2).

Paul Stamets, a mycologist, has raised alarms about the consumption of raw portobello mushrooms, stating that they should be cooked at high temperatures to reduce the levels of agaritine (source-2). Additionally, the Vegetarian Times warns against eating raw mushrooms due to the risk of consuming carcinogenic compounds, particularly emphasizing portobellos and shiitakes (source-2).

However, not all studies agree on the severity of these risks. Some research suggests that the carcinogenic properties of agaritine decrease significantly when mushrooms are cooked (source-3). Furthermore, a study published in Food and Chemical Toxicology indicated that the cancer risk associated with agaritine consumption is relatively low, estimating a lifetime cumulative cancer risk of about two cases per 100,000 lives for consuming small amounts of mushrooms (source-2).

Analysis

The claim that raw portobello mushrooms are "bad for you" is nuanced. While there is credible evidence suggesting that raw portobello mushrooms contain agaritine, which may have carcinogenic properties, the actual risk of cancer from consuming them raw appears to be low based on current research. The Journal of Functional Foods notes that while agaritine has been linked to cancer in animal studies, the relevance of these findings to human consumption remains unclear, as the doses used in studies were often unrealistic (source-2).

Moreover, the potential for foodborne illness from consuming raw mushrooms is a valid concern, as mushrooms can harbor bacteria and other microorganisms (source-4). Cooking mushrooms not only reduces the levels of agaritine but also eliminates harmful bacteria, making cooked mushrooms safer to consume (source-3).

However, it is important to acknowledge that some individuals may experience digestive discomfort from raw mushrooms due to their chitin content, which is difficult to digest without cooking (source-3).

In summary, while there are valid concerns regarding the consumption of raw portobello mushrooms, the evidence does not conclusively support the claim that they are categorically "bad for you." Instead, the risks appear to be manageable with proper cooking and handling.

Conclusion

The verdict on the claim "Our raw baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you" is Partially True. While there are legitimate concerns regarding the potential carcinogenic effects of agaritine and the risk of foodborne illnesses associated with raw consumption, the actual risk to health appears to be low when considering the context of typical consumption and cooking practices. Cooking portobello mushrooms significantly reduces the risks associated with their consumption, making them a safer option.

Sources

  1. Can You Eat Mushrooms Raw? An Expert's Take
  2. What Are the Negative Effects of Portobello Mushrooms?
  3. Are Portobello Mushrooms Safe to Eat Raw? Unveiling the Truth
  4. Dangers Associated with Consuming Uncooked Portabello Mushrooms
  5. Portobello Mushrooms: Positive and Negative Effects
  6. Uncovering the Truth: Are Portobello Mushrooms Okay to Eat Raw?
  7. Can You Eat Raw Mushrooms? Store Bought vs. Foraged, ...
  8. The Surprising Portobello Mushrooms Negative Effects

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

💡 Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
✓100% Free
✓No Registration
✓Instant Results

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...

More Fact Checks to Explore

Discover similar claims and stay informed with these related fact-checks

Fact Check: Our baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you
False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Our baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Our baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you

Jul 27, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: It's actually on TikTok. Welcome to the cookout. You see, our people are now claiming our indigenous status. Look at our brother here. Tax exemption ID. Government ID of the Chihamaru Republic. This is really happening. We got another beloved sister here who received her tribal screening back. Positive Indigenous to the Americans. And even myself, I was able to get my screening done. Positive to the Americans. Ladies and gentlemen, if you want to know how I did this, all I need you to do is share this video, repost it, like, and comment. That's all I need from you, okay? And I'll show you guys how to correct your status back to Indigenous American. I love you. This is what I got on my momma. Let's do it. All right, so we corrected your status. We're not talking about the usual runaround you get where you're paying people and they're sending you templates and you gotta mail all of it, no. All right? What we're doing is we're taking a tribal screening through the Aboriginal Ministry of Justice. These are the requirements you will need to pass that tribal screening. You must currently domicile within the United States, born within America, North, Central, or South, parents or grandparents born within America, directly or indirectly experienced genocide, which for us, slavery, Jim Crow, civil rights, directly or indirectly experienced denationalization. Now, this right here is when they strip you of your nation, if you're black, Negro, Cherokee, mulatto, all type of different names, okay? So the cost of this is $75 for adults, $50 for kids.
Partially True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: It's actually on TikTok. Welcome to the cookout. You see, our people are now claiming our indigenous status. Look at our brother here. Tax exemption ID. Government ID of the Chihamaru Republic. This is really happening. We got another beloved sister here who received her tribal screening back. Positive Indigenous to the Americans. And even myself, I was able to get my screening done. Positive to the Americans. Ladies and gentlemen, if you want to know how I did this, all I need you to do is share this video, repost it, like, and comment. That's all I need from you, okay? And I'll show you guys how to correct your status back to Indigenous American. I love you. This is what I got on my momma. Let's do it. All right, so we corrected your status. We're not talking about the usual runaround you get where you're paying people and they're sending you templates and you gotta mail all of it, no. All right? What we're doing is we're taking a tribal screening through the Aboriginal Ministry of Justice. These are the requirements you will need to pass that tribal screening. You must currently domicile within the United States, born within America, North, Central, or South, parents or grandparents born within America, directly or indirectly experienced genocide, which for us, slavery, Jim Crow, civil rights, directly or indirectly experienced denationalization. Now, this right here is when they strip you of your nation, if you're black, Negro, Cherokee, mulatto, all type of different names, okay? So the cost of this is $75 for adults, $50 for kids.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: It's actually on TikTok. Welcome to the cookout. You see, our people are now claiming our indigenous status. Look at our brother here. Tax exemption ID. Government ID of the Chihamaru Republic. This is really happening. We got another beloved sister here who received her tribal screening back. Positive Indigenous to the Americans. And even myself, I was able to get my screening done. Positive to the Americans. Ladies and gentlemen, if you want to know how I did this, all I need you to do is share this video, repost it, like, and comment. That's all I need from you, okay? And I'll show you guys how to correct your status back to Indigenous American. I love you. This is what I got on my momma. Let's do it. All right, so we corrected your status. We're not talking about the usual runaround you get where you're paying people and they're sending you templates and you gotta mail all of it, no. All right? What we're doing is we're taking a tribal screening through the Aboriginal Ministry of Justice. These are the requirements you will need to pass that tribal screening. You must currently domicile within the United States, born within America, North, Central, or South, parents or grandparents born within America, directly or indirectly experienced genocide, which for us, slavery, Jim Crow, civil rights, directly or indirectly experienced denationalization. Now, this right here is when they strip you of your nation, if you're black, Negro, Cherokee, mulatto, all type of different names, okay? So the cost of this is $75 for adults, $50 for kids.

Jul 26, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Transcript 00:00 If you thought the Epstein files were bad, wait until you hear this. 21 children were just rescued from a four-million-dollar mansion in California. Not from a cartel, not overseas but right here in the sunny California. The couple behind it, Sylvia Zang and Guhan Shang. They were running what looks like a surrogate agency but is now being investigated as a potential child trafficking operation. One surrogate, Kayla Elliott said, I was told that they already had a child and they just wanted one more. I didn't know that they had owned the agency.
Partially True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Transcript 00:00 If you thought the Epstein files were bad, wait until you hear this. 21 children were just rescued from a four-million-dollar mansion in California. Not from a cartel, not overseas but right here in the sunny California. The couple behind it, Sylvia Zang and Guhan Shang. They were running what looks like a surrogate agency but is now being investigated as a potential child trafficking operation. One surrogate, Kayla Elliott said, I was told that they already had a child and they just wanted one more. I didn't know that they had owned the agency.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Transcript 00:00 If you thought the Epstein files were bad, wait until you hear this. 21 children were just rescued from a four-million-dollar mansion in California. Not from a cartel, not overseas but right here in the sunny California. The couple behind it, Sylvia Zang and Guhan Shang. They were running what looks like a surrogate agency but is now being investigated as a potential child trafficking operation. One surrogate, Kayla Elliott said, I was told that they already had a child and they just wanted one more. I didn't know that they had owned the agency.

Jul 26, 2025
Read more →
🔍
Partially True

Fact Check: the goverment are spraying our sky wheather its cloud seedling its impacting health

Detailed fact-check analysis of: the goverment are spraying our sky wheather its cloud seedling its impacting health

Jul 26, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Covid nimbus. Here's the symptom you need to know about that nobody's talking about. What's that? You haven't heard of COVID nimbus? Probably need to talk about that too. So let's get to it. Stick to the end. I'll talk a little bit about prevention. So COVID nimbus is the newest variant going on. It is NB. 1. 8. 1. Say that three times fast. And the unfortunate part about this is it looks like it's more contagious than other variants that we've had recently but it doesn't look so bad that it's going to wind you up necessarily in the hospital. But if you followed me at all you know that that's not necessarily the worst thing 00:32 that happens. You can still develop long COVID from any COVID infection that you get no matter how serious it is or not. But it has a gnarly symptom we have not really seen with COVID in the past. And it mimics other things that we see this tiny year so it's going to be even more important that you test for it when you start getting sick. And it's being associated with razor blades. I know it's not from when you pee so don't worry about that one. Don't go down that road. It's at being associated with the sensation of swallowing razor blades because it causes such a severe sore throat it is akin 01:06 to that sensation. And that can be a similar symptom to a lot of other things particularly things we see in kids like strep throat. Or in older kids things like mononucles. Which you also see surges in usually in summer. But prevention things seem to work the same as they've been working. So vaccinate and if you can get a booster and you haven't like in the last three to six months talk to your doctor about doing so. If you are at high risk and have autoimmune issues or autoimmune suppressants do like I did which is get monoclonal antibodies to protect you
Partially True

Fact Check: Covid nimbus. Here's the symptom you need to know about that nobody's talking about. What's that? You haven't heard of COVID nimbus? Probably need to talk about that too. So let's get to it. Stick to the end. I'll talk a little bit about prevention. So COVID nimbus is the newest variant going on. It is NB. 1. 8. 1. Say that three times fast. And the unfortunate part about this is it looks like it's more contagious than other variants that we've had recently but it doesn't look so bad that it's going to wind you up necessarily in the hospital. But if you followed me at all you know that that's not necessarily the worst thing 00:32 that happens. You can still develop long COVID from any COVID infection that you get no matter how serious it is or not. But it has a gnarly symptom we have not really seen with COVID in the past. And it mimics other things that we see this tiny year so it's going to be even more important that you test for it when you start getting sick. And it's being associated with razor blades. I know it's not from when you pee so don't worry about that one. Don't go down that road. It's at being associated with the sensation of swallowing razor blades because it causes such a severe sore throat it is akin 01:06 to that sensation. And that can be a similar symptom to a lot of other things particularly things we see in kids like strep throat. Or in older kids things like mononucles. Which you also see surges in usually in summer. But prevention things seem to work the same as they've been working. So vaccinate and if you can get a booster and you haven't like in the last three to six months talk to your doctor about doing so. If you are at high risk and have autoimmune issues or autoimmune suppressants do like I did which is get monoclonal antibodies to protect you

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Covid nimbus. Here's the symptom you need to know about that nobody's talking about. What's that? You haven't heard of COVID nimbus? Probably need to talk about that too. So let's get to it. Stick to the end. I'll talk a little bit about prevention. So COVID nimbus is the newest variant going on. It is NB. 1. 8. 1. Say that three times fast. And the unfortunate part about this is it looks like it's more contagious than other variants that we've had recently but it doesn't look so bad that it's going to wind you up necessarily in the hospital. But if you followed me at all you know that that's not necessarily the worst thing 00:32 that happens. You can still develop long COVID from any COVID infection that you get no matter how serious it is or not. But it has a gnarly symptom we have not really seen with COVID in the past. And it mimics other things that we see this tiny year so it's going to be even more important that you test for it when you start getting sick. And it's being associated with razor blades. I know it's not from when you pee so don't worry about that one. Don't go down that road. It's at being associated with the sensation of swallowing razor blades because it causes such a severe sore throat it is akin 01:06 to that sensation. And that can be a similar symptom to a lot of other things particularly things we see in kids like strep throat. Or in older kids things like mononucles. Which you also see surges in usually in summer. But prevention things seem to work the same as they've been working. So vaccinate and if you can get a booster and you haven't like in the last three to six months talk to your doctor about doing so. If you are at high risk and have autoimmune issues or autoimmune suppressants do like I did which is get monoclonal antibodies to protect you

Jul 22, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Owner comes to our apartment complex weekly to spray and has skipped our apartment multiple times. When he was confronted by management, he said he didn't think of knocking on our door. That is obviously a lie. The man has a business that requires him to knock on doors. This company, this owner, has also promised to follow up with treatments that he never followed through on. I highly recommend going elsewhere for your pest control needs.
Partially True

Fact Check: Owner comes to our apartment complex weekly to spray and has skipped our apartment multiple times. When he was confronted by management, he said he didn't think of knocking on our door. That is obviously a lie. The man has a business that requires him to knock on doors. This company, this owner, has also promised to follow up with treatments that he never followed through on. I highly recommend going elsewhere for your pest control needs.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Owner comes to our apartment complex weekly to spray and has skipped our apartment multiple times. When he was confronted by management, he said he didn't think of knocking on our door. That is obviously a lie. The man has a business that requires him to knock on doors. This company, this owner, has also promised to follow up with treatments that he never followed through on. I highly recommend going elsewhere for your pest control needs.

Jul 21, 2025
Read more →
Explore All Fact Checks
Fact Check: Our raw baby Portillo mushroom is bad for you | TruthOrFake Blog