Fact Check: "One victim still in a wheelchair due to poisoning effects."
What We Know
The claim that "one victim still in a wheelchair due to poisoning effects" lacks substantiation based on the available medical literature regarding poisoning from Atropa belladonna, commonly known as deadly nightshade. A recent case report documented two patients who experienced severe neurotoxicity due to accidental ingestion of A. belladonna leaves. Both patients presented with symptoms typical of anticholinergic toxicity, including agitation, delirium, and mydriasis (dilated pupils) (source-1). Importantly, both patients received appropriate medical treatment and subsequently improved, with one patient being discharged in stable condition after 24 hours (source-1).
The report does not mention any long-term disabilities such as remaining in a wheelchair, indicating that the claim is not supported by the documented outcomes of these cases.
Analysis
The evidence provided in the case report is critical for assessing the validity of the claim. The patients involved in the study were treated for acute poisoning and showed significant recovery after medical intervention. The report emphasizes that both patients were discharged from the hospital in stable condition, with no indication of lasting neurological damage or physical disabilities (source-1).
Furthermore, the reliability of the source is high, as it is a peer-reviewed case report published in a reputable medical journal. The authors detail the clinical presentation, treatment, and outcomes of the cases, providing a comprehensive overview of the effects of A. belladonna poisoning. There is no mention of any patient being left with long-term effects such as the inability to walk or the use of a wheelchair, which further undermines the claim.
In contrast, anecdotal reports or unverified claims about victims of poisoning can often exaggerate or misrepresent the severity of the outcomes. Without credible evidence or medical documentation to support the assertion of a victim remaining in a wheelchair, the claim appears to be unfounded.
Conclusion
Verdict: False
The claim that "one victim still in a wheelchair due to poisoning effects" is false. The documented cases of A. belladonna poisoning indicate that both patients recovered fully after appropriate medical treatment, with no lasting disabilities reported. The evidence from the case report clearly contradicts the claim, highlighting the importance of relying on verified medical sources for information regarding health outcomes.
Sources
- Severe Neurotoxicity due to Atropa belladonna Poisoning: A Case Report ... Link
- Behavioral Measures of Neurotoxicity Link
- Nerve Agents - Public Health Link
- Lead poisoning Link
- Poisoning: First aid - Mayo Clinic Link
- Poisoning, Types of Poison: Symptoms & Treatment Link
- 俄罗斯人的主要社交软件是什么? - 知乎 Link
- Poisoning victim: 'A smile relieves a lot of stress' Link