Fact Check: Noviello was a permanent resident since 1991 before his detention.

Fact Check: "Noviello was a permanent resident since 1991 before his detention."

What We Know

Johnny Noviello, a Canadian citizen, entered the United States in 1988 with legal visa status and became a lawful permanent resident on October 24, 1991, as confirmed by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) (source-1, source-2). He was detained by ICE in May 2023 following a conviction for racketeering and drug trafficking, which led to his removal proceedings (source-5). His detention and subsequent death in custody have raised significant concerns regarding the treatment of individuals in ICE facilities.

Analysis

The claim that Noviello was a permanent resident since 1991 before his detention is supported by multiple credible sources. Both ICE and reputable news outlets, such as The New York Times and USA Today, confirm that he became a lawful permanent resident in 1991 (source-1, source-2, source-5). The consistency across these sources lends credibility to the information.

While the sources reporting on his status are generally reliable, it is important to note that ICE's statements may be viewed with skepticism due to the agency's controversial history and the political context surrounding immigration enforcement. However, the corroboration from independent news organizations mitigates this concern.

Furthermore, the timeline of events leading to his detention aligns with his legal status, as he was arrested after being convicted of serious drug-related offenses, which triggered the removal proceedings (source-2, source-8).

Conclusion

The claim that Johnny Noviello was a permanent resident since 1991 before his detention is True. This conclusion is based on consistent information from multiple reliable sources, confirming his status as a lawful permanent resident since October 24, 1991, prior to his arrest and subsequent detention by ICE.