Fact Check: Medical Experts Recommended Discontinuation of Brineura Funding for Pollock
What We Know
The claim that medical experts recommended the discontinuation of funding for Brineura, a drug used by Charleigh Pollock, a 9-year-old girl with a rare condition known as CLN2 or Batten disease, has been a significant point of discussion. The British Columbia (B.C.) government announced that it would stop funding Brineura, which costs approximately $1 million per year, stating that the decision was based on recommendations from a committee of independent medical experts. According to Health Minister Josie Osborne, once a patient's motor and language functions decline beyond a certain threshold, Brineura no longer effectively slows the progression of the disease (CBC).
Osborne emphasized that the high cost of the drug was not a factor in the decision, but rather the clinical criteria established by Canada's Drug Agency (Sooke News Mirror). The review concluded that Charleigh's condition had progressed to the point where she met the criteria for discontinuation of the medication (Victoria Times Colonist). However, Charleigh's family and her medical team believe that she is still benefiting from the treatment and have expressed their disagreement with the decision (CBC, Peninsula News Review).
Analysis
The evidence surrounding the claim is mixed. On one hand, the B.C. government has stated that the decision to discontinue funding was based on recommendations from medical experts who assessed Charleigh's condition against established clinical criteria. This suggests that there was a formal review process involving medical professionals (CBC, Sooke News Mirror).
Conversely, the family's perspective, particularly that of Charleigh's mother, Jori Fales, raises concerns about the validity of the discontinuation criteria. Fales has described the criteria as "outdated" and insists that Charleigh continues to benefit from Brineura, indicating a potential disconnect between the clinical assessments and the lived experience of the patient (Peninsula News Review). This discrepancy highlights the complexity of medical decision-making in cases involving rare diseases, where individual patient responses to treatment can vary significantly.
The sources used in this analysis include reputable news organizations, which generally provide reliable information. However, the emotional weight of the family's situation may introduce bias in the reporting of the facts, particularly in how the medical recommendations are interpreted (CBC, Victoria Times Colonist).
Conclusion
The claim that medical experts recommended the discontinuation of Brineura funding for Pollock is Partially True. While it is accurate that medical experts provided recommendations that led to the decision to stop funding, the context surrounding those recommendations is contentious. The family's assertion that Charleigh continues to benefit from the drug suggests that the clinical criteria may not fully capture the nuances of her condition. Therefore, while the decision was based on expert recommendations, the implications of those recommendations are disputed.
Sources
- B.C. pulls funding on $1M drug for 9-year-old Vancouver Island girl ... (https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/cln2-b-c-funding-brineura-1.7564754)
- How to Find Minecraft Mods Folder (.minecraft/mods folder in %appdata ... (https://stealthygaming.com/make-mods-folder-for-minecraft/)
- B.C. pulls funding for terminal Langford girl's 'life-sustaining' treatment - Sooke News Mirror (https://www.sookenewsmirror.com/home/bc-pulls-funding-for-terminal-langford-kids-life-sustaining-treatment-8069913#:~:text=In%20February%2C%20the%20family%20were,a%20review%20of%20Pollock's%20case.)
- Drug coverage to be discontinued for Langford girl - Victoria Times ... (https://www.timescolonist.com/local-news/drug-coverage-to-be-discontinued-for-langford-girl-with-fatal-condition-10830120)
- AppData Minecraft Windows 10 | COMO ABRIR - Solvetic (https://www.solvetic.com/tutoriales/article/8542-appdata-minecraft-windows-10-como-abrir/)
- Devastated: Langford girl's mom speaks out on last day of B.C.-funded ... (https://www.peninsulanewsreview.com/local-news/devastated-langford-girls-mom-speaks-out-on-last-day-of-bc-funded-treatment-8082378/)
- Medication funding for Charleigh, terminally ill 9-year-old ... (https://cheknews.ca/medication-funding-for-charleigh-terminally-ill-9-year-old-discontinued-effective-june-19-1261827/)
- Why can’t I find the Minecraft mods folder? - Mining Cubes (https://miningcubes.com/minecraft-mods-folder/)
