Fact Check: "Kashanian's husband claims she followed all immigration rules for decades."
What We Know
Mandonna Kashanian, an Iranian-born woman, has lived in the United States for nearly five decades. According to her family, she has maintained compliance with immigration rules throughout her time in the U.S. Kashanian initially entered the country on a student visa, which later expired. However, she was granted a stay of deportation approximately two decades ago, allowing her to remain in the U.S. under supervision. Her family asserts that she has no criminal record and has adhered to immigration regulations during her stay (source-3).
The recent changes to immigration rules in the U.K. highlight the complexities of immigration compliance, but they do not directly pertain to Kashanian's situation in the U.S. (source-1).
Analysis
The claim that Kashanian has followed all immigration rules for decades is supported by her family's statements and the absence of any reported criminal activity. However, it is important to note that while she was granted a stay of deportation, her original student visa expired, which complicates the assertion of complete compliance with immigration laws. The distinction between being compliant under a stay of deportation and adhering to the original visa terms is significant.
The sources reporting on Kashanian's situation include local news outlets that have covered her detention by ICE, which has been described as abrupt and without explanation (source-3). These reports come from credible local news organizations, but they may carry emotional weight due to the personal nature of the story, which could introduce bias in the portrayal of her compliance.
The Home Office's statement on immigration rules provides a broader context for understanding immigration compliance but does not directly relate to Kashanian's specific case (source-1).
Conclusion
The claim that Kashanian's husband states she has followed all immigration rules for decades is Partially True. While her family asserts that she has complied with immigration regulations and has no criminal record, the fact that her original visa expired complicates the assertion of complete compliance. The nuances of her immigration status, particularly regarding the stay of deportation, must be considered when evaluating the accuracy of the claim.
