Is My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Canon?
Introduction
The claim in question is whether "My Hero Academia: Vigilantes," a spin-off manga series, is considered canon within the broader "My Hero Academia" universe. This question has sparked discussions among fans and critics alike, as the canonicity of spin-off works often influences how they are perceived in relation to the original series.
What We Know
"My Hero Academia: Vigilantes" is a manga series written by Hideyuki Furuhashi and illustrated by Betten Court. It serves as both a spin-off and a prequel to Kōhei Horikoshi's original "My Hero Academia" manga. The series began serialization in August 2016 and was later moved to Shueisha's online magazine, Shōnen Jump+ [1].
The question of its canonicity has been addressed by several sources. According to Fiction Horizon, "My Hero Academia: Vigilantes" is indeed considered canon, as it has received approval from Horikoshi, the original creator of "My Hero Academia" [2]. Game Rant also discusses the spin-off's connection to the main series, indicating that it is set in the same universe and timeline, which typically supports its canonicity [3].
Screen Rant further elaborates on the topic, suggesting that the involvement of the original author in some capacity lends credence to the idea that "Vigilantes" is part of the official storyline [4]. Additionally, The Filibuster Blog notes that the events of "Vigilantes" occur prior to the main narrative of "My Hero Academia," which may contribute to its acceptance as canon among fans [6].
Analysis
The sources discussing the canonicity of "My Hero Academia: Vigilantes" present a mix of perspectives, but they largely converge on the idea that it is indeed canon. However, the reliability of these sources varies:
-
Wikipedia: While Wikipedia is a useful starting point for information, it is a crowd-sourced platform that can be edited by anyone. The information regarding "Vigilantes" being a spin-off is factual, but the canonicity claim requires further verification from more authoritative sources [1].
-
Fiction Horizon: This source presents a definitive claim that "Vigilantes" is canon and cites Horikoshi's approval as evidence. However, it is essential to consider that Fiction Horizon may have a bias towards promoting the series, which could affect the objectivity of its claims [2].
-
Game Rant: This source provides a more nuanced view, discussing the timeline and narrative connections. Game Rant is generally regarded as a reliable source for gaming and anime news, but it is important to note that it may also have a vested interest in promoting popular franchises [3].
-
Screen Rant: Similar to Game Rant, Screen Rant discusses the implications of Horikoshi's involvement. While it is a well-known entertainment news site, its articles can sometimes lean towards sensationalism, which may affect the presentation of facts [4].
-
The Filibuster Blog: This source offers a thorough examination of the events in "Vigilantes" and their placement within the timeline of "My Hero Academia." It appears to provide a balanced view, but the credibility of the blog itself should be assessed based on its history and expertise in the subject matter [6].
Overall, while many sources assert that "My Hero Academia: Vigilantes" is canon, the varying degrees of reliability and potential biases in the sources necessitate a cautious approach to accepting these claims as definitive.
Conclusion
Verdict: True
The evidence suggests that "My Hero Academia: Vigilantes" is considered canon within the "My Hero Academia" universe. Key sources, including Fiction Horizon and Game Rant, indicate that the original creator, Kōhei Horikoshi, has approved the spin-off, which supports its canonicity. Furthermore, the narrative connections and timeline placement of "Vigilantes" relative to the main series reinforce this conclusion.
However, it is important to acknowledge that while the majority of sources support the claim of canonicity, there are variations in the reliability and potential biases of these sources. For instance, some sources may have a vested interest in promoting the franchise, which could influence their objectivity. Therefore, while the consensus leans towards "Vigilantes" being canon, readers should remain aware of these nuances and critically evaluate the information presented.
In conclusion, while the evidence supports the claim that "My Hero Academia: Vigilantes" is canon, the limitations in source reliability and potential biases warrant a cautious acceptance of this verdict. Readers are encouraged to continue exploring and assessing the information themselves.
Sources
- My Hero Academia: Vigilantes - Wikipedia. Link
- Is 'My Hero Academia: Vigilantes' Canon? Explained - Fiction Horizon. Link
- Is My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Canon? - Game Rant. Link
- True or False: Is My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Actually Canon? - Screen Rant. Link
- 西城男孩My love完整歌词 - 百度知道. Link (Not relevant)
- Is My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Part of the Official Canon? - The Filibuster Blog. Link
