TruthOrFake Logo
TruthOrFake
Fact Check: Is Canada considering becoming the 51st state?

Fact Check: Is Canada considering becoming the 51st state?

Published May 28, 2025
ByFactChecker 1.1 avatarFactChecker 1.1
✗
VERDICT
False

# Is Canada Considering Becoming the 51st State? The claim that Canada is contemplating becoming the 51st state of the United States has gained tract...

Is Canada Considering Becoming the 51st State?

The claim that Canada is contemplating becoming the 51st state of the United States has gained traction in recent discussions, particularly following remarks made by former President Donald Trump. This assertion raises questions about the political, economic, and social implications of such a potential shift. However, the context and reliability of the sources discussing this claim warrant a thorough examination.

What We Know

  1. Trump's Remarks: Donald Trump has made several statements suggesting that Canada should consider becoming the 51st state, particularly in the context of trade negotiations and tariffs. In December 2024, during a meeting at Mar-a-Lago, he reportedly suggested this to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, referring to him as "Governor Justin Trudeau" 24.

  2. Official Denials: Prime Minister Trudeau has publicly stated that Canada has no intention of becoming a U.S. state. He emphasized this point in a January 2025 statement, asserting that the notion is not grounded in reality 4.

  3. Political Commentary: Analysts have weighed in on the implications of such a move. Some suggest that it would be politically advantageous for Democrats while posing challenges for Republicans, indicating a complex political landscape surrounding the idea 3.

  4. Trump's Proposals: Recently, Trump claimed that Canada could either pay $61 billion for access to a defense system he referred to as the "Golden Dome" or become a state to receive that access for free 78. This claim has been met with skepticism, as it implies a transactional nature to statehood that is not typically part of the political discourse.

  5. Public Sentiment: There is no significant public movement or political momentum in Canada advocating for statehood. The idea appears to be largely driven by Trump's rhetoric rather than any grassroots initiative within Canada 24.

Analysis

Source Reliability

  • Mainstream Media: Articles from established news outlets like the BBC and The Washington Post provide context and analysis, but they also reflect the political biases of their respective audiences. The BBC tends to maintain a neutral stance, while The Washington Post may exhibit a more critical view of Trump’s assertions 43.

  • Social Media Claims: Trump's statements on platforms like Truth Social are often unverified and should be approached with skepticism. His claims frequently lack supporting evidence and may reflect his personal agenda rather than factual information 910.

  • Wikipedia: The Wikipedia entry on movements for the annexation of Canada provides a historical overview but may lack the rigor of peer-reviewed sources. It is useful for context but should be cross-referenced with more authoritative sources 2.

Methodological Concerns

The claims made by Trump and reported in various outlets often lack empirical support. For instance, the assertion that Canada is "considering" becoming a state appears to stem from Trump's interpretation rather than any formal discussions or negotiations. This raises questions about the methodology behind such claims, as they often rely on anecdotal evidence or political posturing rather than substantive dialogue.

Conflicts of Interest

Trump's statements are made in a political context where he has a vested interest in shaping public perception. His previous presidency and ongoing political ambitions may color his remarks, suggesting a potential conflict of interest that could influence the reliability of his claims 910.

What Additional Information Would Be Helpful?

To further evaluate the validity of the claim that Canada is considering statehood, additional information would be beneficial, including:

  • Public Opinion Polls: Data on Canadian public sentiment regarding statehood would provide insight into whether there is any grassroots support for such a drastic change.
  • Official Government Statements: More comprehensive responses from Canadian officials beyond Trudeau’s denial could clarify the government’s stance on the issue.
  • Historical Context: A deeper exploration of past discussions or movements regarding Canadian annexation could help contextualize the current claims.

Conclusion

Verdict: False

The claim that Canada is considering becoming the 51st state of the United States is unfounded. Key evidence includes Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's unequivocal denial of any intention for Canada to pursue statehood, as well as the lack of any significant public or political movement within Canada advocating for such a change. The notion appears to be primarily driven by former President Trump's rhetoric rather than any substantive discussions or proposals.

It is important to note that while Trump's statements may generate media attention, they do not reflect a reality supported by credible evidence or official government positions. The context of Trump's remarks, often made in a politically charged environment, further complicates their reliability.

However, limitations in the available evidence should be acknowledged. The political landscape is dynamic, and public sentiment can shift over time. Therefore, ongoing monitoring of public opinion and official statements is necessary to fully understand the implications of such claims.

Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information and consider the sources and motivations behind claims like these, especially those emerging from politically charged contexts.

Sources

  1. Trump's remarks on Canada becoming the 51st state raise a lot of ... AP News
  2. Movements for the annexation of Canada to the United States - Wikipedia Wikipedia
  3. Canada as a 51st state would be a political ‘nightmare’ for Trump The Washington Post
  4. Canada the 51st US state? Trudeau says 'it's not going to happen' BBC
  5. Mark Carney: Canada will deal with Donald Trump 'on our terms' BBC
  6. King Charles opens Canada’s Parliament in symbolic rebuke of Trump The Washington Post
  7. Donald Trump Makes Canada a New Offer to Become 51st State Newsweek
  8. Trump says Canada would pay $61B for Golden Dome, but zero as '51st state' Global News
  9. Trump claims Canada 'considering' offer of free Golden Dome ... Fox News
  10. Trump says Canada is considering joining US as 51st state, but there's a catch Financial Express

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

💡 Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
✓100% Free
✓No Registration
✓Instant Results

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...

More Fact Checks to Explore

Discover similar claims and stay informed with these related fact-checks

Fact Check: MASSIVE bolt of plasma burst out of the sky striking I-40 near Alma, Arkansas last night! They're getting larger and more frequent as the Earth continues charging up. The further the magnetic North Pole continues racing toward Siberia the weaker Earth's protective magnetic shield becomes. More cosmic radiation from space and more UV, UVB, and UVC radiation from the Sun are penetrating deeper into our atmosphere and into the Earth. Earth's atmosphere is becoming highly charged and electrified causing massive plasma bursts like this to strike, causing more lightning strikes period. Lightning has even been documented striking on days without a storm cloud in sight. All the signatures of the binary twin solar system and the Destroyer's arrival just amplified dramatically this year. The alarmingly endless rainfall and flooding across the world is something I have never witnessed before in my ten years of reporting Earth's climate disasters. Folks who know weather for 60 - 70 years have never witnessed the sudden incredible down bursts of several inches of rain in just minutes that have been triggering nonstop catastrophic flash flooding across America and the rest of the world. It's just been nonstop this year. I've never seen so many very strong and powerful earthquakes strike since March when the 7.0+, 6.0+, 5.0+ magnitude earthquakes accelerated in frequency so fast. With aftershocks in numbers we've never seen before, in the hundreds. I've never seen so many fires breaking out across the world that just keep coming. Canada, the United States, the entire Mediterranean region, Europe, etc. The core of the Earth is expanding from the increase in radiation causing the rock to melt underneath our feet. Magma plumes are growing, lava tubes and corridors are expanding globally and reaching the Earth's surface, on land and under water. We've got a rash of volcanic activity on land and on the ocean floor heating up the water, melting the poles, causing marine life die offs, and fueling the atmosphere with high humidity and water vapor for more frequent and intense storming. All the symptoms of the arrival of the binary twin solar system that was expected are being checked off. This will just continue to worsen in the coming days. Mid-August is almost here and watching for the extreme weather to intensify. We're heading into severe birth pangs now. Listening for updates and watching it unfold live. Remarkable days.
False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: MASSIVE bolt of plasma burst out of the sky striking I-40 near Alma, Arkansas last night! They're getting larger and more frequent as the Earth continues charging up. The further the magnetic North Pole continues racing toward Siberia the weaker Earth's protective magnetic shield becomes. More cosmic radiation from space and more UV, UVB, and UVC radiation from the Sun are penetrating deeper into our atmosphere and into the Earth. Earth's atmosphere is becoming highly charged and electrified causing massive plasma bursts like this to strike, causing more lightning strikes period. Lightning has even been documented striking on days without a storm cloud in sight. All the signatures of the binary twin solar system and the Destroyer's arrival just amplified dramatically this year. The alarmingly endless rainfall and flooding across the world is something I have never witnessed before in my ten years of reporting Earth's climate disasters. Folks who know weather for 60 - 70 years have never witnessed the sudden incredible down bursts of several inches of rain in just minutes that have been triggering nonstop catastrophic flash flooding across America and the rest of the world. It's just been nonstop this year. I've never seen so many very strong and powerful earthquakes strike since March when the 7.0+, 6.0+, 5.0+ magnitude earthquakes accelerated in frequency so fast. With aftershocks in numbers we've never seen before, in the hundreds. I've never seen so many fires breaking out across the world that just keep coming. Canada, the United States, the entire Mediterranean region, Europe, etc. The core of the Earth is expanding from the increase in radiation causing the rock to melt underneath our feet. Magma plumes are growing, lava tubes and corridors are expanding globally and reaching the Earth's surface, on land and under water. We've got a rash of volcanic activity on land and on the ocean floor heating up the water, melting the poles, causing marine life die offs, and fueling the atmosphere with high humidity and water vapor for more frequent and intense storming. All the symptoms of the arrival of the binary twin solar system that was expected are being checked off. This will just continue to worsen in the coming days. Mid-August is almost here and watching for the extreme weather to intensify. We're heading into severe birth pangs now. Listening for updates and watching it unfold live. Remarkable days.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: MASSIVE bolt of plasma burst out of the sky striking I-40 near Alma, Arkansas last night! They're getting larger and more frequent as the Earth continues charging up. The further the magnetic North Pole continues racing toward Siberia the weaker Earth's protective magnetic shield becomes. More cosmic radiation from space and more UV, UVB, and UVC radiation from the Sun are penetrating deeper into our atmosphere and into the Earth. Earth's atmosphere is becoming highly charged and electrified causing massive plasma bursts like this to strike, causing more lightning strikes period. Lightning has even been documented striking on days without a storm cloud in sight. All the signatures of the binary twin solar system and the Destroyer's arrival just amplified dramatically this year. The alarmingly endless rainfall and flooding across the world is something I have never witnessed before in my ten years of reporting Earth's climate disasters. Folks who know weather for 60 - 70 years have never witnessed the sudden incredible down bursts of several inches of rain in just minutes that have been triggering nonstop catastrophic flash flooding across America and the rest of the world. It's just been nonstop this year. I've never seen so many very strong and powerful earthquakes strike since March when the 7.0+, 6.0+, 5.0+ magnitude earthquakes accelerated in frequency so fast. With aftershocks in numbers we've never seen before, in the hundreds. I've never seen so many fires breaking out across the world that just keep coming. Canada, the United States, the entire Mediterranean region, Europe, etc. The core of the Earth is expanding from the increase in radiation causing the rock to melt underneath our feet. Magma plumes are growing, lava tubes and corridors are expanding globally and reaching the Earth's surface, on land and under water. We've got a rash of volcanic activity on land and on the ocean floor heating up the water, melting the poles, causing marine life die offs, and fueling the atmosphere with high humidity and water vapor for more frequent and intense storming. All the symptoms of the arrival of the binary twin solar system that was expected are being checked off. This will just continue to worsen in the coming days. Mid-August is almost here and watching for the extreme weather to intensify. We're heading into severe birth pangs now. Listening for updates and watching it unfold live. Remarkable days.

Aug 13, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: MASSIVE bolt of plasma burst out of the sky striking I-40 near Alma, Arkansas last night! They're getting larger and more frequent as the Earth continues charging up. The further the magnetic North Pole continues racing toward Siberia the weaker Earth's protective magnetic shield becomes. More cosmic radiation from space and more UV, UVB, and UVC radiation from the Sun are penetrating deeper into our atmosphere and into the Earth. Earth's atmosphere is becoming highly charged and electrified causing massive plasma bursts like this to strike, causing more lightning strikes period. Lightning has even been documented striking on days without a storm cloud in sight. All the signatures of the binary twin solar system and the Destroyer's arrival just amplified dramatically this year. The alarmingly endless rainfall and flooding across the world is something I have never witnessed before in my ten years of reporting Earth's climate disasters. Folks who know weather for 60 - 70 years have never witnessed the sudden incredible down bursts of several inches of rain in just minutes that have been triggering nonstop catastrophic flash flooding across America and the rest of the world. It's just been nonstop this year. I've never seen so many very strong and powerful earthquakes strike since March when the 7.0+, 6.0+, 5.0+ magnitude earthquakes accelerated in frequency so fast. With aftershocks in numbers we've never seen before, in the hundreds. I've never seen so many fires breaking out across the world that just keep coming. Canada, the United States, the entire Mediterranean region, Europe, etc. The core of the Earth is expanding from the increase in radiation causing the rock to melt underneath our feet. Magma plumes are growing, lava tubes and corridors are expanding globally and reaching the Earth's surface, on land and under water. We've got a rash of volcanic activity on land and on the ocean floor heating up the water, melting the poles, causing marine life die offs, and fueling the atmosphere with high humidity and water vapor for more frequent and intense storming. All the symptoms of the arrival of the binary twin solar system that was expected are being checked off. This will just continue to worsen in the coming days. Mid-August is almost here and watching for the extreme weather to intensify. We're heading into severe birth pangs now. Listening for updates and watching it unfold live. Remarkable days.
False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: MASSIVE bolt of plasma burst out of the sky striking I-40 near Alma, Arkansas last night! They're getting larger and more frequent as the Earth continues charging up. The further the magnetic North Pole continues racing toward Siberia the weaker Earth's protective magnetic shield becomes. More cosmic radiation from space and more UV, UVB, and UVC radiation from the Sun are penetrating deeper into our atmosphere and into the Earth. Earth's atmosphere is becoming highly charged and electrified causing massive plasma bursts like this to strike, causing more lightning strikes period. Lightning has even been documented striking on days without a storm cloud in sight. All the signatures of the binary twin solar system and the Destroyer's arrival just amplified dramatically this year. The alarmingly endless rainfall and flooding across the world is something I have never witnessed before in my ten years of reporting Earth's climate disasters. Folks who know weather for 60 - 70 years have never witnessed the sudden incredible down bursts of several inches of rain in just minutes that have been triggering nonstop catastrophic flash flooding across America and the rest of the world. It's just been nonstop this year. I've never seen so many very strong and powerful earthquakes strike since March when the 7.0+, 6.0+, 5.0+ magnitude earthquakes accelerated in frequency so fast. With aftershocks in numbers we've never seen before, in the hundreds. I've never seen so many fires breaking out across the world that just keep coming. Canada, the United States, the entire Mediterranean region, Europe, etc. The core of the Earth is expanding from the increase in radiation causing the rock to melt underneath our feet. Magma plumes are growing, lava tubes and corridors are expanding globally and reaching the Earth's surface, on land and under water. We've got a rash of volcanic activity on land and on the ocean floor heating up the water, melting the poles, causing marine life die offs, and fueling the atmosphere with high humidity and water vapor for more frequent and intense storming. All the symptoms of the arrival of the binary twin solar system that was expected are being checked off. This will just continue to worsen in the coming days. Mid-August is almost here and watching for the extreme weather to intensify. We're heading into severe birth pangs now. Listening for updates and watching it unfold live. Remarkable days.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: MASSIVE bolt of plasma burst out of the sky striking I-40 near Alma, Arkansas last night! They're getting larger and more frequent as the Earth continues charging up. The further the magnetic North Pole continues racing toward Siberia the weaker Earth's protective magnetic shield becomes. More cosmic radiation from space and more UV, UVB, and UVC radiation from the Sun are penetrating deeper into our atmosphere and into the Earth. Earth's atmosphere is becoming highly charged and electrified causing massive plasma bursts like this to strike, causing more lightning strikes period. Lightning has even been documented striking on days without a storm cloud in sight. All the signatures of the binary twin solar system and the Destroyer's arrival just amplified dramatically this year. The alarmingly endless rainfall and flooding across the world is something I have never witnessed before in my ten years of reporting Earth's climate disasters. Folks who know weather for 60 - 70 years have never witnessed the sudden incredible down bursts of several inches of rain in just minutes that have been triggering nonstop catastrophic flash flooding across America and the rest of the world. It's just been nonstop this year. I've never seen so many very strong and powerful earthquakes strike since March when the 7.0+, 6.0+, 5.0+ magnitude earthquakes accelerated in frequency so fast. With aftershocks in numbers we've never seen before, in the hundreds. I've never seen so many fires breaking out across the world that just keep coming. Canada, the United States, the entire Mediterranean region, Europe, etc. The core of the Earth is expanding from the increase in radiation causing the rock to melt underneath our feet. Magma plumes are growing, lava tubes and corridors are expanding globally and reaching the Earth's surface, on land and under water. We've got a rash of volcanic activity on land and on the ocean floor heating up the water, melting the poles, causing marine life die offs, and fueling the atmosphere with high humidity and water vapor for more frequent and intense storming. All the symptoms of the arrival of the binary twin solar system that was expected are being checked off. This will just continue to worsen in the coming days. Mid-August is almost here and watching for the extreme weather to intensify. We're heading into severe birth pangs now. Listening for updates and watching it unfold live. Remarkable days.

Aug 13, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: John Lennon is alive and performing in Canada
False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: John Lennon is alive and performing in Canada

Detailed fact-check analysis of: John Lennon is alive and performing in Canada

Aug 12, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Disabled Canadians are "not" full citizens of Canada entitled to the same legal rights and "non-disabled Canadians" on and after July 1, 1867 to present day. To prove this statement false I will need to see "the sentences", "their related paragraph numbers", "their related page numbers" and "their related web pages" from case law, conventions, ministerial orders and statutes.
False

Fact Check: Disabled Canadians are "not" full citizens of Canada entitled to the same legal rights and "non-disabled Canadians" on and after July 1, 1867 to present day. To prove this statement false I will need to see "the sentences", "their related paragraph numbers", "their related page numbers" and "their related web pages" from case law, conventions, ministerial orders and statutes.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Disabled Canadians are "not" full citizens of Canada entitled to the same legal rights and "non-disabled Canadians" on and after July 1, 1867 to present day. To prove this statement false I will need to see "the sentences", "their related paragraph numbers", "their related page numbers" and "their related web pages" from case law, conventions, ministerial orders and statutes.

Jul 23, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Did Canada have tariffs on export of gas, oil or electricity to the US before 2025?
False

Fact Check: Did Canada have tariffs on export of gas, oil or electricity to the US before 2025?

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Did Canada have tariffs on export of gas, oil or electricity to the US before 2025?

Jul 13, 2025
Read more →
🔍
False

Fact Check: Canada sever diplomatic relationship with United States over Trump's plan to annex Canada

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Canada sever diplomatic relationship with United States over Trump's plan to annex Canada

Jul 13, 2025
Read more →
Explore All Fact Checks
Fact Check: Is Canada considering becoming the 51st state? | TruthOrFake Blog