TF
TruthOrFake
Fact Check: Is Canada considering becoming the 51st state?

Fact Check: Is Canada considering becoming the 51st state?

May 28, 2025•by TruthOrFake AI
✗
VERDICT
False

# Is Canada Considering Becoming the 51st State? The claim that Canada is contemplating becoming the 51st state of the United States has gained tract...

Is Canada Considering Becoming the 51st State?

The claim that Canada is contemplating becoming the 51st state of the United States has gained traction in recent discussions, particularly following remarks made by former President Donald Trump. This assertion raises questions about the political, economic, and social implications of such a potential shift. However, the context and reliability of the sources discussing this claim warrant a thorough examination.

What We Know

  1. Trump's Remarks: Donald Trump has made several statements suggesting that Canada should consider becoming the 51st state, particularly in the context of trade negotiations and tariffs. In December 2024, during a meeting at Mar-a-Lago, he reportedly suggested this to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, referring to him as "Governor Justin Trudeau" 24.

  2. Official Denials: Prime Minister Trudeau has publicly stated that Canada has no intention of becoming a U.S. state. He emphasized this point in a January 2025 statement, asserting that the notion is not grounded in reality 4.

  3. Political Commentary: Analysts have weighed in on the implications of such a move. Some suggest that it would be politically advantageous for Democrats while posing challenges for Republicans, indicating a complex political landscape surrounding the idea 3.

  4. Trump's Proposals: Recently, Trump claimed that Canada could either pay $61 billion for access to a defense system he referred to as the "Golden Dome" or become a state to receive that access for free 78. This claim has been met with skepticism, as it implies a transactional nature to statehood that is not typically part of the political discourse.

  5. Public Sentiment: There is no significant public movement or political momentum in Canada advocating for statehood. The idea appears to be largely driven by Trump's rhetoric rather than any grassroots initiative within Canada 24.

Analysis

Source Reliability

  • Mainstream Media: Articles from established news outlets like the BBC and The Washington Post provide context and analysis, but they also reflect the political biases of their respective audiences. The BBC tends to maintain a neutral stance, while The Washington Post may exhibit a more critical view of Trump’s assertions 43.

  • Social Media Claims: Trump's statements on platforms like Truth Social are often unverified and should be approached with skepticism. His claims frequently lack supporting evidence and may reflect his personal agenda rather than factual information 910.

  • Wikipedia: The Wikipedia entry on movements for the annexation of Canada provides a historical overview but may lack the rigor of peer-reviewed sources. It is useful for context but should be cross-referenced with more authoritative sources 2.

Methodological Concerns

The claims made by Trump and reported in various outlets often lack empirical support. For instance, the assertion that Canada is "considering" becoming a state appears to stem from Trump's interpretation rather than any formal discussions or negotiations. This raises questions about the methodology behind such claims, as they often rely on anecdotal evidence or political posturing rather than substantive dialogue.

Conflicts of Interest

Trump's statements are made in a political context where he has a vested interest in shaping public perception. His previous presidency and ongoing political ambitions may color his remarks, suggesting a potential conflict of interest that could influence the reliability of his claims 910.

What Additional Information Would Be Helpful?

To further evaluate the validity of the claim that Canada is considering statehood, additional information would be beneficial, including:

  • Public Opinion Polls: Data on Canadian public sentiment regarding statehood would provide insight into whether there is any grassroots support for such a drastic change.
  • Official Government Statements: More comprehensive responses from Canadian officials beyond Trudeau’s denial could clarify the government’s stance on the issue.
  • Historical Context: A deeper exploration of past discussions or movements regarding Canadian annexation could help contextualize the current claims.

Conclusion

Verdict: False

The claim that Canada is considering becoming the 51st state of the United States is unfounded. Key evidence includes Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's unequivocal denial of any intention for Canada to pursue statehood, as well as the lack of any significant public or political movement within Canada advocating for such a change. The notion appears to be primarily driven by former President Trump's rhetoric rather than any substantive discussions or proposals.

It is important to note that while Trump's statements may generate media attention, they do not reflect a reality supported by credible evidence or official government positions. The context of Trump's remarks, often made in a politically charged environment, further complicates their reliability.

However, limitations in the available evidence should be acknowledged. The political landscape is dynamic, and public sentiment can shift over time. Therefore, ongoing monitoring of public opinion and official statements is necessary to fully understand the implications of such claims.

Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information and consider the sources and motivations behind claims like these, especially those emerging from politically charged contexts.

Sources

  1. Trump's remarks on Canada becoming the 51st state raise a lot of ... AP News
  2. Movements for the annexation of Canada to the United States - Wikipedia Wikipedia
  3. Canada as a 51st state would be a political ‘nightmare’ for Trump The Washington Post
  4. Canada the 51st US state? Trudeau says 'it's not going to happen' BBC
  5. Mark Carney: Canada will deal with Donald Trump 'on our terms' BBC
  6. King Charles opens Canada’s Parliament in symbolic rebuke of Trump The Washington Post
  7. Donald Trump Makes Canada a New Offer to Become 51st State Newsweek
  8. Trump says Canada would pay $61B for Golden Dome, but zero as '51st state' Global News
  9. Trump claims Canada 'considering' offer of free Golden Dome ... Fox News
  10. Trump says Canada is considering joining US as 51st state, but there's a catch Financial Express

Got your own claim to verify? It's 100% Free!

Join thousands who trust our AI-powered fact-checking. Completely free with no registration required. Your claim could be the next important truth we uncover.

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

💡 Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
✓100% Free
✓No Registration
✓Instant Results

Comments

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...

More Fact Checks to Explore

Discover similar claims and stay informed with these related fact-checks

🔍
Mostly False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Carney has massive direct ties to Trump and Elon Musk. 1. Carney moved Brookfield asset management to NY only 6 days after Trump imposes tariffs. This makes Trump happy. 2. Carney will not get rid of bill C69 which is no new pipelines in Canada. So this means most of our oil and gas continues to go to Trump in the US. We need to be independent. Again siding with Trump, Trump is very happy. 3. Trumps son-in-law Jared Kushner was in financial trouble and Carney’s company Brookfield signed a 99 year lease on his property at 666 fifth ave for 1.1 billion with all funds up front (unheard of terms) this cements Trumps admiration for Carney and Carney is now considered family. 4. Carney had Brookfield asset management bail out Elon Musk (Twitter) when he had the big buyout. This is Trumps best buddy and considers Carney also a big business partner with him now. 5. Trump publicly stated that he prefers dealing with the liberals as they never say anything bad about him but Pierre stands up for Canada and says Canada will never be the 51st state and he doesn’t like that. Trump says he wants to deal with Carney. 6. Carney has used off shore banking to hide Brookfields income and owes 5.3 billion to the government over the last 15 years. The address for the account in Bermuda is a bike shop. Carney says it’s legal to hide money and not pay taxes. 7. Liberals had the government prorogued for 3 months while they played around with who could take over while Trump dumped tariffs on us. 8. Carney’s company Brookfield intends to build homes to rent to Canadians with our tax dollars and Brookfield being the owner. 9. Carney sells Canadian dirty coal to China and India then blames us with contributing 1.5% of the worlds carbon and carbon taxes us to death meanwhile China is at 32% of the world’s carbon that Carney helped them get to. What a hypocrite. 10. Carney kicks Chandra Arya to the curb who has won the last 3 elections in Nepean for the liberals. Carney took the easiest seat available to win to try to get an MP job. Another set up and another slimy move. 11. Carney’s company Brookfield has clear cut 9,000 hectares of rain forest in Brazil for pure profit. I thought his idea was net zero??!! 12. Mark Carney took an all expenses paid trip to the UK before he was even temporarily made PM. This is an unelected person getting a free $500,000 trip. This is unethical and he should have used his own money. 13. Carney has used his power to influence the UK to use more expensive jet fuel, then had his company Brookfield invest $1 billion to be able to profit from that. 14. Carney is proposing an altered much higher carbon tax on corporations that will dump down on citizens with no rebates. Carney says the carbon tax has been used sparingly and needs to be doubled. 15. Carney wants to institute carbon credits that will restrict travel in your vehicle and vacations but the ultra rich can buy your credits so they can still enjoy the world. Same as China. 16. Carney wants to bring in carbon tariffs, which is called a carbon border adjustment on any country that he feels doesn’t have a high enough carbon tax. This means the whole world. Carney thinks he’s in charge of the entire planet now. This will increase the price on all imported items we buy. You can only imagine what this will do to the cost of materials. 17. The former UK British Prime Minister Liz Truss has warned Canada to stay away from him and his disasterous Net Zero scams. As did the Mayor of Lima, Peru. 18. Former UK Prime Minister Liz Truss on Mark Carney: "I strongly recommend not backing Mark Carney for his policies on Net Zero. It was disastrous for Britain. It would be disastrous for Canada. She stated he printed too much money and put their economy off track. After he left his successors have struggled to clear up the mess. Inflation spiked to 11.1 % in the UK compared to 5.2% in France. 19. Mayor Lopez Aliaga of Lima Peru said Brookfield, chaired by Carney, was “making massive profits off a toxic contract” plagued by bribes. 20. The Municipality of Lima is currently suing Brookfield (Carney is part of Brookfield asset management) in a New York City court. It’s part of an ongoing legal battle that has been going on for years. Mark Carney and Brookfield instituted tolls on the poorest people that took 1/3 of their monthly income. 21. Carney lied when he said he would build LNG pipelines across Canada to the west in English, the told Quebec in French, never without their permission! 22. Carney lied straight to everyone's faces in the debate, when he said he had nothing to do with Brookfield leaving Canada for the USA. Actually he was still Chair and recommended the move 6 days after Trump announced the tariffs. So this was a move to please Trump and avoid Canadas taxes and Trumps tariffs. 23. Brookfield owns pipelines in other countries and Carney has fought tooth and nail not to have Canada’s resources hit the open market. This is loss of profit for his company. Conservatives have fought for this for years. Now Carney and the liberals are campaigning to do this. This will end up being another lie just to get votes. 24. Carney lied when he said he worked with Paul Martin on balancing the federal budget, when he was at Goldman Sachs at that time as a Wall Street banker. 25. Carney lied when he said he helped save Canada during the 2008 banking crisis. It was not him who steered Canada away from the disaster that the "Bankers" like him at Goldman Sachs caused, it was the late Jim Flaherty. 26. Carney is involved in the Century Initiative, which was created to increase Canada's population to 100 million by 2050 that’s over 2 million per year that tax payers have to foot the bill. No matter how devastating the costs, and an end to Canadian Identity as we know it. All for profit. They have a website where you can read all about it. Trudeau brought in 1 million per year over 3 years and crashed our housing and healthcare. 27. Carney refuses to declare his assets before becoming the Pm and put them in a blind trust. That’s why the election was called with minimal notice. 28. Carney’s competitors were illegally eliminated before the liberal mini election to purposely to give Carney the job even though they raised the $350K. Ruby Dhalla is one of them, and Chandra Arya is another. Now Carney took his riding. 29. Carney says he would implement the emergency act against tariffs if necessary again. 30. In Carney’s own book he states capitalism is evil and rigid controls on personal freedoms, industry and corporations are necessary. Poverty will definitely happen but for the good of world order. In other words personal freedom is not an option. 31. Carney and the others that fought for the PM job (in the liberal debate) were forbidden to discuss the fentanyl crisis, homelessness, immigration, border issues, bail reform, China foreign interference or mass debt issues. This is from Trudeau himself. If Carney will lie this much before the election then refuse to follow all the proper ethics and conflict investigations, then he is going to continue to lie well after he gets in office. This is just another Justin Trudeau! Liar Personified! This is who Trudeau wants in office as Prime Minister without him ever being elected. His partner in corruption, greed, and immorality. Except he is even better connected, and established with the funds behind him. And soon he will have access to all of Canadas fund and Information about all companies for when he returns to the private sector. Ask yourself, why is a guy making $20 million a year here to make $203,000 as an MP (which Carney is not one) plus $203,000 for prime minister. = $406,000

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Carney has massive direct ties to Trump and Elon Musk. 1. Carney moved Brookfield asset management t...

Apr 23, 2025
Read more →
🔍
Mostly False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Carney has massive direct ties to Trump and Elon Musk. 1. Carney moved Brookfield asset management to NY only 6 days after Trump imposes tariffs. This makes Trump happy. 2. Carney will not get rid of bill C69 which is no new pipelines in Canada. So this means most of our oil and gas continues to go to Trump in the US. We need to be independent. Again siding with Trump, Trump is very happy. 3. Trumps son-in-law Jared Kushner was in financial trouble and Carney’s company Brookfield signed a 99 year lease on his property at 666 fifth ave for 1.1 billion with all funds up front (unheard of terms) this cements Trumps admiration for Carney and Carney is now considered family. 4. Carney had Brookfield asset management bail out Elon Musk (Twitter) when he had the big buyout. This is Trumps best buddy and considers Carney also a big business partner with him now. 5. Trump publicly stated that he prefers dealing with the liberals as they never say anything bad about him but Pierre stands up for Canada and says Canada will never be the 51st state and he doesn’t like that. Trump says he wants to deal with Carney. 6. Carney has used off shore banking to hide Brookfields income and owes 5.3 billion to the government over the last 15 years. The address for the account in Bermuda is a bike shop. Carney says it’s legal to hide money and not pay taxes. 7. Liberals had the government prorogued for 3 months while they played around with who could take over while Trump dumped tariffs on us. 8. Carney’s company Brookfield intends to build homes to rent to Canadians with our tax dollars and Brookfield being the owner. 9. Carney sells Canadian dirty coal to China and India then blames us with contributing 1.5% of the worlds carbon and carbon taxes us to death meanwhile China is at 32% of the world’s carbon that Carney helped them get to. What a hypocrite. 10. Carney kicks Chandra Arya to the curb who has won the last 3 elections in Nepean for the liberals. Carney took the easiest seat available to win to try to get an MP job. Another set up and another slimy move. 11. Carney’s company Brookfield has clear cut 9,000 hectares of rain forest in Brazil for pure profit. I thought his idea was net zero??!! 12. Mark Carney took an all expenses paid trip to the UK before he was even temporarily made PM. This is an unelected person getting a free $500,000 trip. This is unethical and he should have used his own money. 13. Carney has used his power to influence the UK to use more expensive jet fuel, then had his company Brookfield invest $1 billion to be able to profit from that. 14. Carney is proposing an altered much higher carbon tax on corporations that will dump down on citizens with no rebates. Carney says the carbon tax has been used sparingly and needs to be doubled. 15. Carney wants to institute carbon credits that will restrict travel in your vehicle and vacations but the ultra rich can buy your credits so they can still enjoy the world. Same as China. 16. Carney wants to bring in carbon tariffs, which is called a carbon border adjustment on any country that he feels doesn’t have a high enough carbon tax. This means the whole world. Carney thinks he’s in charge of the entire planet now. This will increase the price on all imported items we buy. You can only imagine what this will do to the cost of materials. 17. The former UK British Prime Minister Liz Truss has warned Canada to stay away from him and his disasterous Net Zero scams. As did the Mayor of Lima, Peru. 18. Former UK Prime Minister Liz Truss on Mark Carney: "I strongly recommend not backing Mark Carney for his policies on Net Zero. It was disastrous for Britain. It would be disastrous for Canada. She stated he printed too much money and put their economy off track. After he left his successors have struggled to clear up the mess. Inflation spiked to 11.1 % in the UK compared to 5.2% in France. 19. Mayor Lopez Aliaga of Lima Peru said Brookfield, chaired by Carney, was “making massive profits off a toxic contract” plagued by bribes. 20. The Municipality of Lima is currently suing Brookfield (Carney is part of Brookfield asset management) in a New York City court. It’s part of an ongoing legal battle that has been going on for years. Mark Carney and Brookfield instituted tolls on the poorest people that took 1/3 of their monthly income. 21. Carney lied when he said he would build LNG pipelines across Canada to the west in English, the told Quebec in French, never without their permission! 22. Carney lied straight to everyone's faces in the debate, when he said he had nothing to do with Brookfield leaving Canada for the USA. Actually he was still Chair and recommended the move 6 days after Trump announced the tariffs. So this was a move to please Trump and avoid Canadas taxes and Trumps tariffs. 23. Brookfield owns pipelines in other countries and Carney has fought tooth and nail not to have Canada’s resources hit the open market. This is loss of profit for his company. Conservatives have fought for this for years. Now Carney and the liberals are campaigning to do this. This will end up being another lie just to get votes. 24. Carney lied when he said he worked with Paul Martin on balancing the federal budget, when he was at Goldman Sachs at that time as a Wall Street banker. 25. Carney lied when he said he helped save Canada during the 2008 banking crisis. It was not him who steered Canada away from the disaster that the "Bankers" like him at Goldman Sachs caused, it was the late Jim Flaherty. 26. Carney is involved in the Century Initiative, which was created to increase Canada's population to 100 million by 2050 that’s over 2 million per year that tax payers have to foot the bill. No matter how devastating the costs, and an end to Canadian Identity as we know it. All for profit. They have a website where you can read all about it. Trudeau brought in 1 million per year over 3 years and crashed our housing and healthcare. 27. Carney refuses to declare his assets before becoming the Pm and put them in a blind trust. That’s why the election was called with minimal notice. 28. Carney’s competitors were illegally eliminated before the liberal mini election to purposely to give Carney the job even though they raised the $350K. Ruby Dhalla is one of them, and Chandra Arya is another. Now Carney took his riding. 29. Carney says he would implement the emergency act against tariffs if necessary again. 30. In Carney’s own book he states capitalism is evil and rigid controls on personal freedoms, industry and corporations are necessary. Poverty will definitely happen but for the good of world order. In other words personal freedom is not an option. 31. Carney and the others that fought for the PM job (in the liberal debate) were forbidden to discuss the fentanyl crisis, homelessness, immigration, border issues, bail reform, China foreign interference or mass debt issues. This is from Trudeau himself. If Carney will lie this much before the election then refuse to follow all the proper ethics and conflict investigations, then he is going to continue to lie well after he gets in office. This is just another Justin Trudeau! Liar Personified! This is who Trudeau wants in office as Prime Minister without him ever being elected. His partner in corruption, greed, and immorality. Except he is even better connected, and established with the funds behind him. And soon he will have access to all of Canadas fund and Information about all companies for when he returns to the private sector. Ask yourself, why is a guy making $20 million a year here to make $203,000 as an MP (which Carney is not one) plus $203,000 for prime minister. = $406,000

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Carney has massive direct ties to Trump and Elon Musk. 1. Carney moved Brookfield asset management t...

Apr 23, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Is Justin bieber banned in canada?
False
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Is Justin bieber banned in canada?

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Is Justin bieber banned in canada?

May 31, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Is Justin bieber banned in canada
False

Fact Check: Is Justin bieber banned in canada

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Is Justin bieber banned in canada

May 31, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Is GST increasing in 2024 Canada?
False

Fact Check: Is GST increasing in 2024 Canada?

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Is GST increasing in 2024 Canada?

May 25, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: In Canada, misgendering is a crime.
False

Fact Check: In Canada, misgendering is a crime.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: In Canada, misgendering is a crime.

May 14, 2025
Read more →
Explore All Fact Checks
Fact Check: Is Canada considering becoming the 51st state? | TruthOrFake Blog