Fact Check: "Illegal immigration is hurting America"
What We Know
The claim that "illegal immigration is hurting America" encompasses various aspects, including economic impacts, social costs, and public perceptions.
-
Economic Costs: According to a report by Congress.gov, illegal immigrants are significant users of welfare programs, with an estimated 59% of households headed by illegal immigrants utilizing one or more major welfare programs, compared to 39% of U.S.-born households (source-1). Furthermore, a Newsweek article reported that illegal immigration cost the U.S. approximately $150.7 billion in 2023, translating to an average burden of $1,156 per taxpayer (source-4).
-
Job Market Effects: Research from UC Davis indicates that the narrative of immigrants threatening jobs is largely unfounded. Studies show that immigrants often complement the native workforce rather than compete with it. For instance, a study by Giovanni Peri found that immigration increased wages for 90% of native-born workers with at least a high school diploma (source-2).
-
Crime Rates: Contrary to popular belief, immigrants, including those who are undocumented, have historically lower incarceration rates than native-born citizens. A study analyzing over 150 years of data found that immigrants have consistently had lower crime rates (source-2).
Analysis
The evidence regarding the impact of illegal immigration on America is mixed and often context-dependent.
-
Economic Burden: The assertion that illegal immigration imposes a significant financial burden on taxpayers is supported by data indicating high welfare usage and substantial costs associated with illegal immigration (source-1, source-4). However, these figures do not account for the economic contributions of illegal immigrants, such as labor in essential industries and tax contributions from those who pay taxes despite their status.
-
Labor Market Dynamics: The argument that immigrants negatively affect job opportunities for native workers is countered by extensive research suggesting that immigrants often fill labor shortages and contribute positively to the economy (source-2). This perspective is supported by studies showing wage increases for many native workers due to immigrant labor.
-
Crime and Safety: The claim that illegal immigration leads to increased crime is not substantiated by historical data, which shows lower crime rates among immigrant populations (source-2). This challenges the narrative that illegal immigrants are inherently more dangerous than native-born citizens.
The sources used in this analysis vary in reliability. Reports from Congress.gov and academic institutions like UC Davis are generally credible due to their research-based nature. In contrast, sources like Newsweek and opinion pieces may have inherent biases that could affect their conclusions.
Conclusion
The claim that "illegal immigration is hurting America" is Partially True. While there are valid concerns regarding the economic costs associated with illegal immigration, particularly in terms of welfare usage and taxpayer burden, it is essential to recognize the broader context. Research indicates that immigrants often contribute positively to the economy and do not significantly increase crime rates. Therefore, the impact of illegal immigration is complex and cannot be reduced to a simple assertion of harm.
Sources
- The Cost of Illegal Immigration to Taxpayers - Congress.gov Link
- How Does Immigration Affect the United States? - UC Davis Link
- Illegal immigration to the United States - Wikipedia Link
- How Much Do Illegal Immigrants Cost the U.S.? - Newsweek Link
- The Hidden Cost of Illegal Immigration on American Taxpayers - The Financial Guys Link
- Explainer: Illegal Immigration in the United States - Migration Policy Institute Link
- Illegal Immigration Statistics in the U.S. 2025 | Key Facts - The Global Statistics Link
