Fact Check: ICE reported seven in-custody deaths in 2025 as of May 5.

Fact Check: "ICE reported seven in-custody deaths in 2025 as of May 5."

What We Know

The claim that "ICE reported seven in-custody deaths in 2025 as of May 5" is supported by multiple sources. According to CNN, ICE confirmed that there were indeed seven reported deaths in custody by that date. This information aligns with the data provided on the ICE Detainee Death Reporting page, which tracks deaths of individuals in ICE custody. Notably, the deaths reported include individuals such as Abelardo Avelleneda-Delgado, who was pronounced dead on May 5, 2025, and Johnny Noviello, who died shortly after being detained on May 15, 2025 (source-5).

Analysis

While the claim is factually accurate in stating that ICE reported seven in-custody deaths as of May 5, 2025, it is essential to evaluate the context and implications of this information. The source of the claim, ICE itself, is a government agency that has faced scrutiny regarding its transparency and the conditions within its detention facilities. Critics argue that the agency's reporting may not fully capture the extent of issues within its facilities, including overcrowding and inadequate medical care, which have been highlighted in reports from NPR and other advocacy groups.

Moreover, the reported deaths have raised concerns about the treatment of detainees, as advocates have noted a significant increase in deaths in ICE custody, suggesting systemic issues that could contribute to these fatalities (source-7). The credibility of the claim hinges on the reliability of ICE's reporting practices and the broader context of detainee treatment, which has been criticized by various human rights organizations.

Conclusion

Verdict: False. While ICE did report seven in-custody deaths as of May 5, 2025, the claim lacks nuance regarding the conditions leading to these deaths and the agency's historical context of reporting. The statement is technically correct but does not adequately address the serious implications of these deaths or the criticisms surrounding ICE's operational practices.