Fact Check: ICE has reported 12 deaths in custody since the beginning of fiscal year 2025.

Fact Check: "ICE has reported 12 deaths in custody since the beginning of fiscal year 2025."

What We Know

The claim that ICE has reported 12 deaths in custody since the beginning of fiscal year 2025 is supported by multiple sources. According to data from ICE, the total number of reported deaths in custody reached 12 as of late March 2025, following the deaths of individuals such as Isidro Perez, a 75-year-old Cuban man, and Johnny Noviello, a Canadian citizen, both of whom died in ICE facilities during this period (MSNBC). The fiscal year 2025 for ICE began in October 2024, and the reported deaths have raised concerns about conditions within these facilities, which have been criticized for inadequate medical care and overall treatment of detainees (MSNBC).

Analysis

The evidence supporting the claim comes primarily from ICE's own data and reports from reputable news outlets. The MSNBC article cites ICE data confirming the total of 12 deaths, which aligns with the agency's reporting requirements under the DHS Appropriations Bill (ICE). This data is considered credible as it is mandated by law to be reported publicly within 90 days of each incident.

However, the reliability of the sources reporting on these deaths varies. While MSNBC is a well-known news organization, it is important to consider potential biases in reporting, especially regarding politically charged topics like immigration. The article discusses the dismissive comments made by Tom Homan, a former ICE director, which may reflect a particular viewpoint on the issue (MSNBC).

Additionally, other reports indicate that the number of deaths could rise, with some sources suggesting that the total for fiscal year 2025 could exceed previous years if the current trend continues (iAsk). This context is crucial for understanding the severity of the situation and the implications for ICE's operational practices.

Conclusion

The claim that "ICE has reported 12 deaths in custody since the beginning of fiscal year 2025" is True. The data from ICE corroborated by reputable news sources confirms that this number is accurate as of the latest reports. The ongoing scrutiny of ICE's detention conditions and the implications of these deaths highlight significant concerns regarding the treatment of detainees.

Fact Check: ICE has reported 12 deaths in custody since the beginning of fiscal year 2025.