Fact Check: "Here Are Some Stats Fox News Doesn't Want You to Know"
What We Know
California Governor Gavin Newsom recently made a claim stating that "52 million jobs have been created since the Cold War," with "Democratic administrations creating 50 million" and "Republican administrations creating 1.9 million" of those jobs. He also suggested that "Republican presidents have one thing in common: recession" (Gavin Newsom - X).
According to multiple sources, since the end of the Cold War in 1989, approximately 51 million jobs have indeed been created in the United States, with about 50 million of those jobs added during Democratic presidencies (PolitiFact - X, Yahoo). The data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics supports this, indicating that nearly 96% of jobs created since 1989 occurred under Democratic administrations (ABC News).
However, the claim that only 1.9 million jobs were created under Republican administrations is less clear. While it is true that the job growth under Republican presidents has been significantly lower than under Democrats, the specific figure of 1.9 million is not universally agreed upon and may vary depending on the timeframe and metrics used (Snopes).
Analysis
Newsom's assertion that 52 million jobs have been created since the Cold War aligns with general consensus based on labor statistics. However, the breakdown of job creation by political party is more nuanced. The claim that 50 million jobs were created under Democratic administrations is supported by several analyses, including a detailed examination by PolitiFact and other news outlets (Yahoo, ABC News).
The figure of 1.9 million jobs created under Republican administrations is contentious. Some analyses suggest that the job growth during Republican presidencies has been lower, but the exact number can vary based on the criteria used for measurement and the specific timeframes considered (Snopes).
Additionally, the assertion that "Republican presidents have one thing in common: recession" is a broad statement that lacks specific economic data to substantiate it. While it is true that some Republican administrations have faced recessions, attributing economic downturns solely to party affiliation oversimplifies complex economic factors (PolitiFact - X).
The sources used in this analysis are generally credible, with PolitiFact and ABC News being well-regarded for their fact-checking and journalistic integrity. However, the interpretation of job creation statistics can vary, and it is essential to consider the context and methodology behind these figures.
Conclusion
The claim made by Governor Newsom is Partially True. While the overall job creation figures since the Cold War and the dominance of Democratic administrations in that growth are accurate, the specific number of jobs attributed to Republican administrations is less definitive and can vary. Additionally, the assertion that Republican presidents are uniformly associated with recession lacks the necessary nuance and evidence to be fully substantiated.
Sources
- Gavin Newsom
- Gavin Newsom - X
- PolitiFact - X
- Fact Check: Bill Clinton Said Democratic Presidents Created ...
- Yes, Democrats Were in White House for 50M of 51M Jobs ...
- Why Clinton's claim that Democratic presidents created more ...
- Have 96% of jobs created over 35 years emerged under ...
- Democratic Presidents Created 50M of 51M Jobs Since ...