Fact Check: Hageman Voted Against Ukrainian Aid While Backing Israel
What We Know
Representative Harriet Hageman voted against the Ukraine Security Supplemental Appropriations Act (H.R. 8035) and in favor of the Israel Security Supplemental Appropriations Act (H.R. 8034) during a recent vote in the U.S. House of Representatives. According to her statements, Hageman expressed concerns about the amount of aid already provided to Ukraine, stating that the U.S. has committed over $172 billion to the Ukraine/Russia conflict and criticized the lack of oversight regarding these funds (Hageman Votes NO on Ukraine, YES on Israel funding). In contrast, she emphasized her support for Israel, particularly in light of recent attacks by Hamas, and described Israel as a vital ally that requires U.S. assistance (Hageman Votes to Support Our Ally Israel).
The House of Representatives approved the aid for Israel by a vote of 226-196, while Hageman's opposition to the Ukraine aid was part of a broader disapproval of combining multiple aid packages into one vote, which she argued obscured the distinct needs of each situation (Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives - Vote Details).
Analysis
Hageman's votes clearly align with the claim that she voted against aid to Ukraine while supporting aid to Israel. The official records confirm her votes on both bills, and her statements provide context for her decisions. She articulated a rationale for opposing Ukrainian aid, citing concerns over government corruption and the lack of a clear strategy for the conflict (Hageman Votes NO on Ukraine, YES on Israel funding).
The reliability of the sources is strong, as they include official statements from Hageman and the U.S. House of Representatives. The press releases from Hageman's office provide direct quotes and context for her votes, while the House vote details are a matter of public record (Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives - Vote Details).
Additionally, the broader context of U.S. foreign aid, including the recent bipartisan support for Israel and the contentious debate surrounding aid to Ukraine, is well-documented in multiple reputable news sources (Supplemental Bill Becomes Law, Provides Billions in Aid ..., Senate passes $95 billion foreign aid bill for Ukraine, Israel).
Conclusion
The claim that "Hageman voted against Ukrainian aid while backing Israel" is True. Hageman's voting record and public statements confirm her opposition to the Ukraine aid package and her support for the Israel aid package, reflecting her stated concerns about the appropriateness and oversight of U.S. spending in these contexts.
