Fact Check: "Gilbert is likely the first dog to lie in state in Minnesota history."
What We Know
Gilbert, a 4-year-old golden retriever, was a beloved pet of Minnesota State Representative Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark. Tragically, both Hortman and her husband were killed in a shooting incident on June 14, 2025, along with Gilbert, who was also injured in the attack and later euthanized due to the severity of his injuries (New York Times, Washington Post). Following their deaths, all three were honored by lying in state at the Minnesota Capitol, making Gilbert the first animal to receive this honor in Minnesota's history (Yahoo News). The event was significant, as it also marked Melissa Hortman as the first woman and Mark Hortman as the first individual who was not a public official or military figure to lie in state in the Capitol (New York Times, Washington Post).
Analysis
The claim that Gilbert is likely the first dog to lie in state in Minnesota history is supported by multiple reputable sources. The Minnesota Historical Society, which keeps records of such honors, has not documented any previous instances of a dog lying in state (Washington Post). This absence of records lends credibility to the assertion that Gilbert is indeed the first animal to receive this honor.
Moreover, the emotional context surrounding Gilbert's death and the circumstances of the Hortman family's involvement with service dogs add depth to the narrative. The Hortmans had a history of training service dogs through the nonprofit organization Helping Paws, which underscores their commitment to animal welfare (New York Times). Gilbert was initially intended to be a service dog but was deemed unsuitable for the role, ultimately becoming a cherished family pet instead. This backstory contributes to the significance of his inclusion in the memorial service.
While the sources cited are credible and provide consistent information, it is important to note that the claim is somewhat subjective, as it relies on the absence of documented precedents rather than a definitive record. However, given the available evidence, the claim stands strong.
Conclusion
Verdict: True
The claim that "Gilbert is likely the first dog to lie in state in Minnesota history" is substantiated by credible sources and the lack of any documented instances of a dog receiving this honor before. The emotional and historical context surrounding Gilbert's life and the tragic circumstances of his death further affirm the significance of this event.
