Fact Check: Florida Attorney General claims Miami lacks authority to change election date

What We Know

Recently, the Florida Attorney General, James Uthmeier, issued a warning to Miami city officials regarding their decision to postpone municipal elections from November 2025 to 2026. Uthmeier asserted that the city does not have the legal authority to change the election date, emphasizing that such changes could violate state election laws (CBS News, WUSF). This decision by Miami officials was reportedly made to align local elections with higher turnout during even-numbered years, which has been a topic of debate among local leaders and voters (Miami Herald).

The Florida Division of Elections outlines the legal framework governing election dates, indicating that any changes must comply with state regulations (Florida Department of State). The implications of Uthmeier's warning could lead to legal challenges or further scrutiny of Miami's decision-making process regarding election management.

Analysis

The claim made by the Florida Attorney General raises significant legal and procedural questions about the authority of local governments to alter election dates. The warning issued by Uthmeier appears to be grounded in a broader interpretation of state election laws, which are designed to ensure uniformity and integrity in the electoral process.

The sources cited provide a mix of perspectives. The Miami Herald reports on the rationale behind the city's decision, suggesting that the move aims to increase voter turnout by synchronizing local elections with federal and state elections (Miami Herald). However, this rationale does not negate the legal concerns raised by Uthmeier, who is acting in accordance with state law to prevent what he perceives as an overreach by local officials (WUSF).

The reliability of the sources is generally high, with the Florida Division of Elections being a primary governmental authority on election matters (Florida Department of State). Meanwhile, local news outlets like CBS News and the Miami Herald provide timely reporting on the unfolding situation, though they may carry some local bias in favor of community interests (CBS News, Miami Herald).

Conclusion

Needs Research. The claim that Miami lacks the authority to change the election date is supported by the Florida Attorney General's warning, but further investigation is necessary to fully understand the legal implications and the potential for local governance to adapt election schedules. The situation is evolving, and additional legal opinions or court rulings may clarify the authority of local officials in this context.

Fact Check: Florida Attorney General claims Miami lacks authority to change election date