Fact Check: Florida AG Found in Contempt for Defying Court Order on Immigration Laws
What We Know
On June 17, 2025, a federal judge found Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier in civil contempt for violating a court order that temporarily blocked the enforcement of a new state immigration law. This law made it a misdemeanor for individuals living in the U.S. illegally to enter or re-enter Florida. U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams ruled that Uthmeier's arguments for not complying with her injunction were unconvincing and described his interpretations of the law as "implausible" (AP News, NBC News).
The judge's order required Uthmeier to file biweekly reports to ensure compliance, detailing any law enforcement actions taken under the contested law (AP News). Uthmeier had previously sent conflicting memos to law enforcement, initially instructing them to refrain from enforcing the law, but later asserting that he could not prevent enforcement despite the injunction (New York Times).
Analysis
The ruling by Judge Williams is significant as it underscores the authority of the judiciary in enforcing compliance with court orders. Uthmeier's actions were seen as a direct challenge to the court's authority, particularly when he publicly expressed his disagreement with the injunction and indicated that he would not prevent law enforcement from acting on the law (NBC News).
The judge's decision was informed by a prior ruling from the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, which had already denied Uthmeier's request to stay the injunction, indicating that the case was far from resolved and that Uthmeier had not demonstrated a strong likelihood of success on appeal (AP News).
The sources reporting on this incident, including the Associated Press and NBC News, are reputable and provide comprehensive coverage of legal matters, making them reliable for understanding the implications of this ruling. Both outlets emphasize the seriousness of Uthmeier's defiance and the potential consequences for his office's operations moving forward.
Conclusion
The claim that Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier was found in contempt for defying a court order regarding immigration laws is True. The evidence presented from multiple credible sources confirms that a federal judge ruled against him for failing to comply with an injunction that barred the enforcement of the controversial immigration law. This ruling highlights the importance of adherence to judicial orders and the potential repercussions of non-compliance.
Sources
- Judge finds Florida attorney general in contempt over ... AP News
- Florida Attorney General Defied Order Blocking Part of ... New York Times
- Judge finds Florida attorney general in contempt for ... NBC News
