The Claim: "Finding out Katy Perry bullied a nun to DEATH and caused another nun to UNALIVE herself"

Introduction

The claim that pop star Katy Perry "bullied a nun to DEATH" and caused another nun to "unalive herself" stems from a tragic incident involving Sister Catherine Rose Holzman, who collapsed and died during a court hearing related to a property dispute with Perry. This assertion has circulated in various forms, often sensationalized, but it requires careful examination of the facts and context surrounding the events.

What We Know

1. Incident Details: Sister Catherine Rose Holzman, aged 89, collapsed and died in a Los Angeles courtroom on March 9, 2018, during a legal dispute over the sale of a convent. Prior to her collapse, she had publicly pleaded with Perry to "please stop" pursuing the property, which had been sold to Perry without the approval of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles 145.

2. Legal Context: The legal battle involved the Sisters of the Most Holy and Immaculate Heart of the Blessed Virgin Mary, who were attempting to sell the convent to a restaurateur, Dana Hollister, against the wishes of the Archdiocese. Perry's legal team successfully argued that the nuns did not have the authority to sell the property, leading to a court ruling in favor of Perry and the Archdiocese 23.

3. Claims of Bullying: Some nuns involved in the dispute, including Sister Rita Callanan, have described feeling bullied during the legal proceedings. Callanan stated that Perry's actions led to a significant emotional toll on Holzman, suggesting that the stress contributed to her health decline 39.

4. Subsequent Statements: Following Holzman's death, Callanan publicly stated that Perry had "blood on her hands," implying that the stress of the legal battle and Holzman's death were directly connected to Perry's actions 9. However, this statement reflects an opinion rather than a verifiable fact.

Analysis

The sources discussing this claim vary in reliability and potential bias:

• Mainstream News Outlets: Articles from NPR 1, BBC 2, and The Washington Post 5 provide factual accounts of the events, including the legal context and the circumstances of Holzman's death. These sources are generally credible and adhere to journalistic standards.

• Sensationalist Coverage: Some reports, such as those from BuzzFeed 8 and UNILAD 7, while still based on factual events, tend to sensationalize the narrative, which could lead to misinterpretations of the events. This type of coverage may prioritize engaging headlines over nuanced reporting.

• Conflicting Statements: The claim that Perry "bullied" Holzman is largely based on subjective interpretations of the events and statements made by the nuns involved. While there is evidence of emotional distress, attributing direct causation to Perry's actions lacks concrete evidence and relies heavily on personal opinions 9.

• Methodological Concerns: The assertion that Perry caused another nun to "unalive herself" is particularly problematic, as it suggests a direct cause-and-effect relationship that is not substantiated by evidence. No credible sources indicate that any nun took her own life as a result of the legal dispute with Perry.

Conclusion

Verdict: False

The claim that Katy Perry "bullied a nun to DEATH" and caused another nun to "unalive herself" is false. The evidence indicates that while Sister Catherine Rose Holzman did collapse and die during a court hearing related to a property dispute involving Perry, attributing her death to bullying or direct actions by Perry lacks substantiation. The statements made by some nuns, including claims of feeling bullied, reflect personal opinions rather than verifiable facts. Furthermore, there is no credible evidence to support the assertion that any nun took her own life due to this dispute.

It is important to recognize that while emotional distress was reported, the complexities of the legal situation and the personal health of the individuals involved cannot be reduced to a simple cause-and-effect narrative. The sensationalized nature of some reports may contribute to misunderstandings about the events.

Limitations in the available evidence include the reliance on subjective interpretations and the absence of direct causal links between Perry's actions and the tragic outcomes. Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information and consider the context and nuances surrounding such claims before drawing conclusions.

Sources

1. NPR. "Nun Involved In Katy Perry Convent Lawsuit Collapses And Dies In Court." NPR
2. BBC. "Katy Perry lawsuit: Nun involved in property row 'dies in court'." BBC
3. The New York Times. "Nuns Intensify Fight Over Sale of Convent to Katy Perry." NYT
4. Associated Press. "Nun involved in lawsuit with Katy Perry over convent dies." AP News
5. The Washington Post. "‘Katy Perry, please stop,’ begged a nun. Then she collapsed and died." Washington Post
6. UNILAD. "Nun’s final words before she collapsed and died in court in middle of Katy Perry property legal dispute." UNILAD
7. BuzzFeed News. "A Nun Involved In A Lawsuit With Katy Perry Collapsed And Died In Court." BuzzFeed
8. Sky News. "Nun claims Katy Perry has 'blood on her hands' over property deal after ..." Sky News
9. Threads. "The nun didn't agree with the purchaser ..." Threads