Fact Check: Does JD Vance Wear Eyeliner?
What We Know
The claim that JD Vance wears eyeliner has gained traction, particularly following his appearances during political debates and public events. Observers have noted that his eyes appear to be heavily outlined, leading to speculation about whether he uses makeup, specifically eyeliner. According to a report by ELLE, after a recent vice presidential debate, many viewers commented on Vance's eye makeup, with some jokingly suggesting he might be using "guyliner." Notably, former congressman George Santos stated on social media that Vance does not wear eyeliner, attributing the appearance of darkened eyes to his naturally long eyelashes that cast shadows on his waterline.
Interestingly, a resurfaced photo from Vance's time at Yale Law School shows him wearing eyeliner, which adds complexity to the discussion. Makeup artists consulted by ELLE provided varying opinions; some suggested that while he may not be wearing eyeliner, he could have a lash tint or simply possess naturally dark and thick eyelashes that create the illusion of eyeliner (ELLE).
Further speculation arose during the 2024 vice presidential debate, where many viewers noted that Vance's eye makeup seemed particularly pronounced. A report from Nicki Swift highlighted that Vance's makeup choices have been a topic of conversation for years, with his wife claiming that his lashes are natural and that she has always been envious of them.
Analysis
The evidence surrounding JD Vance's use of eyeliner is mixed and somewhat anecdotal. The comments from various makeup artists suggest a lack of consensus on whether he applies eyeliner or if his eye appearance is due to natural features. For instance, celebrity makeup artist Joseph Carrillo mentioned the possibility of a lash tint, while others like Daniel Martin and Romy Soleimani expressed skepticism about Vance using makeup at all, attributing his eye appearance to his naturally dark lashes (ELLE).
The credibility of the sources discussing Vance's makeup is generally high, as they include professional makeup artists who have experience in the field. However, the opinions are subjective and based on visual observations rather than definitive evidence. The social media discourse, while reflective of public perception, does not provide conclusive proof of Vance's makeup habits.
Moreover, the resurfaced photo from Yale Law School, which shows Vance wearing eyeliner, adds a layer of complexity to the claim. It suggests that he has, at least at one point in his life, used eyeliner, but it does not confirm whether he currently does so.
Conclusion
The claim that JD Vance wears eyeliner is Partially True. While there is evidence suggesting he has worn eyeliner in the past, particularly in a photo from Yale Law School, current opinions from makeup artists and public commentary indicate that his eye appearance may also be attributed to his natural eyelashes. The lack of definitive evidence regarding his current makeup routine leaves the claim somewhat ambiguous.
